38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, March 28, 2024
Judiciary

A letter to the Husband’s Senior at work, citing facts of Criminal Case against him, in Good Faith, does not Amount to Defamation

By LawStreet News Network      29 March, 2022 12:59 AM      0 Comments
Criminal Case against him does not Amount to Defamation

The Calcutta High Court recently in a case had observed that writing a letter to the husband's superior at work, in good faith, intimating him about a criminal case lodged against the husband for inflicting torture, would not amount to criminal defamation under Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. 

The wife (petitioner) in the present case had written a letter dated 24th May, 1997 to the Manager, Indian Overseas Bank intimating him that her husband who was the Assistant Manager of Overseas Bank had been torturing her and she been thrown out by him from her matrimonial house. 

She mentioned that a criminal case under Section 498A CrPC, 1973, (cruelty) had been initiated against her husband following which he had been arrested and subsequently released on bail. 

The petitioner in her letter had also attached a certified copy of the order and had requested the Manager to take necessary actions as he deemed, considering the relevant set of facts which she had mentioned through her letter. 

"There remains little to be said that the letter in question was a statement of fact instead of any imputation to harm the reputation of the opposite party", the Court observed.

Justice Ananda Kumar Mukherjee noted that there was absolutely nothing in the petitioner’s letter that was instigative in nature. She had simply suggested that actions be taken in accordance with what is considered to be the best possible recourse in the said situation. 

It was simply the narration of facts which were in corroboration with the incidents that had taken place with her i.e. facts relating to filling of cases for alleged torture. 

He further said that there was no 'embellishment of facts' and that no coercive action had been sought by the petitioner against her husband vide the letter. 

It was also noted, by the Bench, that any representation made by a person in good faith for protecting his/her own interest would not amount to defamation as the Ninth Exception under Section 499 IPC, 1860, protects imputations made in good faith by person for protection of his or other's interests. 

The Court further highlighted that the Fifth Exception under Section 499 IPC, 1860, stipulates that a representation would not amount to defamation if an opinion is expressed on the merits of any case in good faith which has been decided by a Court in respect of the conduct of a person. 

"In the instant case on the basis of the material available in the Case Diary the bail of the opposite party was rejected by the court. Therefore, subsequent acquittal of the opposite party cannot undo his arrest and his released on bail by the court, therefore such representation when made in the letter would be covered by the 5th exception of section 499 of IPC", the Court remarked further.

The court took into consideration that the letter was written by the petitioner to the husband’s Superior on the 24th of May’ 1997 whereas the complaint of defamation was initiated by him on June 8, 2009, which is a huge lapse of twelve long years. Thus it was held that the complaint filed under Section 200 CrPC by the husband against the petitioner alleging criminal defamation is barred by the law of limitation under Section 468 CrPC, 1973

Accordingly, the Court observed that case initiated by the husband is barred by limitation as the date of offence should be construed from the date of issuing the letter that is on May 24, 1997. 

Reliance was placed on the Allahabad High Court decision in Naresh Chand Jain Vs. State of U.P and others and on the Calcutta High Court judgment in Rabindra Nath Pal v. Ratikanta Paul & others the Court opined that a case for the offence of defamation should be filed within three years from the date of publication.

Thus, the Court set aside the complaint lodged by the husband against the petitioner for the offence of defamation by observing that the same is barred by limitation and thus a continuation of such proceedings would lead to an abuse of the process of Court.

Case Title: Malancha Mohinta v. Dipak Mohinta 



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

india-summons-us-diplomat-over-state-dept-remarks-on-kejriwals-arrest
Trending International
India summons US diplomat over state dept remarks on Kejriwal's arrest

After CAA, U.S. wades into Arvind Kejriwal’s arrest. Here's how India responded.

27 March, 2024 04:41 PM
delhi-high-court-warns-against-aaps-call-for-protest-in-court-premises-amid-kejriwal-arrest
Trending Judiciary
Delhi High Court Warns Against AAP's Call for Protest in Court Premises Amid Kejriwal Arrest

Delhi High Court warns Aam Aadmi Party's Legal Cell of severe action for any protest in Delhi Courts against Arvind Kejriwal's arrest.

27 March, 2024 05:57 PM

TOP STORIES

global-entertainment-giants-warner-bros-netflix-amazon-get-relief-from-delhi-hc-in-copyright-protection-case
Trending Business
Global entertainment giants Warner Bros, Netflix, Amazon get relief from Delhi HC in copyright protection case

Delhi HC grants relief to global entertainment giants like Netflix, Amazon, Warner Bros, ordering takedown of copyrighted content on rogue websites.

22 March, 2024 12:13 PM
arvind-kejriwal-arrested-can-cm-administer-a-region-while-being-in-jail
Trending Top Stories
Arvind Kejriwal Arrested | Can CM administer a region while being in jail?

Will President's rule be imposed in Delhi after Kejriwal’s arrest? Read the full article to know more.

22 March, 2024 03:16 PM
merely-because-you-are-politician-cant-bypass-statutory-remedies-procedure-sc-refuses-to-consider-bail-by-kavitha
Trending Judiciary
'Merely because you are politician, can't bypass statutory remedies, procedure,' SC refuses to consider bail by Kavitha

Supreme Court denies bail to politician Kavitha in Delhi Liquor Policy Scam; ED alleges Rs 100 crore illegal gratification.

22 March, 2024 03:34 PM
ponmudi-to-be-sworn-in-as-minister-tn-governor-relents-before-sc
Trending Judiciary
Ponmudi to be sworn in as Minister, TN Governor relents before SC

Tamil Nadu Governor relents to Supreme Court's order, agrees to swear in DMK leader K Ponmudi as Minister after court's rap.

22 March, 2024 03:54 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email