38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, March 29, 2024
Judiciary

'No Rule that Poor People Can't Donate Organs': Kerala High Court Directs Authority to Reconsider Plea for Unrelated Kidney Transplantation [READ JUDGMENT]

By Nargis Bano      02 October, 2021 02:46 PM      0 Comments
'No Rule that Poor People Can't Donate Organs': Kerala High Court Directs Authority to Reconsider Plea for Unrelated Kidney Transplantation [READ JUDGMENT]

The Kerala High Court recently ruled that a donor's low socioeconomic status does not preclude him or her from donating organs.

It thus allowed a petition challenging the order of the District Level Authorization Committee, which had rejected a woman's application for organ donation on the grounds, among other things, that the donor comes from a poor family.

While deliberating on the petition, Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan stated:

"I don't understand the respondent's reasoning. There is no barrier to donating organs simply because a donor comes from a poor family... There is no rule that prohibits poor people from donating organs. It is not a sin to be poor. There are many people in our country with big hearts who can save them. That is how we can narrow the gap between the haves and the have-nots."

The Judge also mentioned that the donee comes from a low-income family.

Background:

The petitioner's case was that the first petitioner, Reeja P., is a kidney patient in need of an urgent transplant. She is currently undergoing dialysis three times per week, and the kidneys of her close relatives were not found to be suitable.

Given the dire circumstances, the second petitioner, Saraswathi K, expressed her willingness to donate her kidney to the first petitioner. It is claimed that their husbands worked together for years and that their families are very close.

However, the respondent District Level Authorization Committee denied the petitioner's application, citing the donor's poor family background and the fact that there were several unrelated previous kidney donors from the area to which the second petitioner belonged.

Dissatisfied, a writ petition was filed by Advocate C.M. Mohammed Iquabal.

The Government Pleader objected to the plea, claiming that the respondent, after reviewing the records and questioning the petitioners and concluded that approval could not be granted in this case. As a result, it was argued that the Court should not intervene.

Findings:

The Bench, on the other hand, did not understand the respondent's reasoning, pointing out that poverty is not a barrier to organ donation.

The Court also determined that one of the other grounds cited by the respondent for rejection was that the document signed by the Village Officer was discovered to be false following the interrogation of the husband and wife enrolled in the document.

"I'm not sure how the respondent came to the conclusion that the document signed by the Village Officer was false. Respondent does not have the authority to declare that a certificate issued by a Village Officer is false while considering a transplantation application," it stated.

The Court also established that while questioning the parties, the respondent should take a "mild stand." The respondent's intention should be solely to determine whether or not there is a commercial transaction.

The respondent also stated that there were several unrelated kidney donors in the donor's neighbourhood. However, the Bench refused to accept such a claim in the absence of evidence.

"In light of the facts and circumstances of the case, I believe it is a matter for the respondent to reconsider. The respondent must decide whether or not there is a commercial transaction," it stated.

The incident came to light after Mathrubhumi, a leading Malayalam daily newspaper, reported on the first petitioner's unfortunate situation.

As a result, the Court took judicial notice of the report, praising the media for bringing such incidents to light:

"This court takes judicial notice of the Ext.P3 report of Mathrubhumi, one of Kerala's leading Malayalam daily newspapers. We must value such news items from print and visual media so that people with big hearts will come forward to help those in need," it had duly noted.

Case Title: Reeja P. & Anr v. District Level Authorization Committee

 

[READ JUDGMENT]



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

arvind-kejriwals-plea-for-interim-release-rejected-by-delhi-high-court
Trending Judiciary
Arvind Kejriwal's plea for interim release rejected by Delhi High Court [Read Order]

Delhi High Court rejects Arvind Kejriwal's plea for interim release in money laundering case related to liquor policy scam, pending ED's response.

28 March, 2024 10:50 AM
youtuber-strings-plea-against-youtube-accounts-suspension-andhra-pradesh-hc-issues-notice-to-centre-google
Trending Top Stories
BREAKING: Youtuber String’s plea against Youtube accounts suspension: Andhra Pradesh HC issues notice to Centre, Google

Andhra Pradesh High Court issues notice to the Centre and Google LLC on Youtube journalist String’s plea against suspension of its accounts by Google (which owns Youtube).

28 March, 2024 11:26 AM

TOP STORIES

delhi-liquor-scam-court-remands-arvind-kejriwal-to-ed-custody-till-march-28-read-remand-application
Trending Judiciary
Delhi liquor scam: Court remands Arvind Kejriwal to ED custody till March 28 [Read Order]

Delhi liquor scam: Arvind Kejriwal remanded to ED custody till March 28. Court grants agency permission for interrogation in liquor policy case.

23 March, 2024 11:53 AM
sc-dismisses-centres-plea-for-review-of-judgment-directing-ed-to-furnish-written-grounds-of-arrest-to-pmla-accused
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses Centre’s plea for review of judgment directing ED to furnish written grounds of arrest to PMLA accused [Read Order]

Supreme Court dismisses Centre's plea, upholds judgment mandating Enforcement Directorate to provide written grounds of arrest in PMLA cases.

23 March, 2024 03:14 PM
kerala-hc-to-hear-lesbian-couples-plea-against-forced-conversion-therapy-on-april-9
Trending Judiciary
Kerala HC to hear lesbian couple’s plea against forced conversion therapy on April 9

Kerala HC will hear a lesbian couple’s plea highlighting that one of them was subjected to forced conversion therapy.

23 March, 2024 03:30 PM
how-can-people-be-compelled-to-vote-madras-hc-asks
Trending Judiciary
“How can people be compelled to vote? Madras HC asks

“How can people be compelled to vote?”, the Madras HC queried in a plea asking employers in Tamil Nadu to demand proof from employees of having voted on polling day.

23 March, 2024 05:04 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email