38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, April 19, 2024

Supreme Court Transfers NDPS Case Against Brazilian Citizen Due To Communication Problem [Read Order]

By Ghazal Bhootra      03 August, 2020 01:27 PM      0 Comments
Supreme Court Transfers NDPS Case Against Brazilian Citizen Due To Communication Problem

The Supreme Court recently shifted an NDPS case against a Brazilian Citizen from Chennai Court to Delhi Court. 

Justice Hrishikesh Roy observed that the hearing against Jailson Manoel Da Silva has not made much headway in the Chennai Court for the last four years mainly due to the communication issue. 

The petitioner argued before the court that the trial in the Chennai Court is basically hauled for the last about four years mainly due to the face that he cannot express himself properly with his counsel due to his language issue and organizing his defense has mainly become impossible. He also expressed before the court that the Embassy of Brazil in Delhi is ready to provide aid to the accused if the trial of the case is shifted to a Delhi Court from the Chennai Court. 

Narcotics Control Bureau contended before the court that the accused is definitely qualified to an able legal representation, but the requisite is being given to the accused, in the Chennai Court as well. Taking his contention into consideration, Justice Roy allowed the Transfer Petition and observed: 

“I have considered the circumstances of the case and also the fact that the trial has not made much progress in the Chennai Court for the last four years primarily because of the communication problem. If the case is transferred to the court in Delhi, the Narcotics Control Bureau who are the Prosecutor in this case will have no difficulty, as their officers and lawyers are available in Delhi.”

Although the order in this instance talks about Section 25 CPC, it appears to be a typographical mistake. The provision to be cited for asking for a transfer of a criminal case is Section 406 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure is quite similarly worded and gives the Supreme Court the power to transfer civil cases. 

To desire a transfer of a criminal case, one must file under Section 406 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This provision gives Supreme Court the jurisdiction to transfer a case if it seems to it that a transfer order is needed for justice. The Supreme Court can issue instructions so that any particular case or appeal be transferred from one High Court to another High Court or from a Criminal Court subordinate to one High Court to another Criminal Court of equal or superior jurisdiction subordinate to another High Court.

In a case entitled Nahar Singh Yadav vs. Union Of India AIR 2011 SC 1 549, the Supreme Court has analyzed the scope of this provision. 

It noted that “an order of transfer of trial is not to be passed as a matter of routine or merely because an interested party has expressed some apprehension about the proper conduct of a trial. It held that this power has to be exercised cautiously and in exceptional situations, where it becomes necessary to do so to provide credibility to the trial. The three-judge bench then listed some broad factors that should be kept in mind while considering an application for transfer of the trial: 

When it appears that the State machinery or prosecution is acting hand in glove with the accused, and there is a likelihood of a miscarriage of justice due to the lackadaisical attitude of the prosecution; When there is material to show that the accused may influence the prosecution witnesses or cause physical harm to the complainant;

Comparative inconvenience and hardships likely to be caused to the accused, the complainant/the prosecution and the witnesses, besides the burden to be borne by the State Exchequer in making payment of traveling and other expenses of the official and non-official witnesses; 

A communally surcharged atmosphere, indicating some proof of the inability of holding fair and impartial trial because of the accusations made and the nature of the crime committed by the accused; and 

Existence of some material from which it can be inferred that some persons are so hostile that they are interfering or are likely to interfere either directly or indirectly with the court of justice.”



[Read Order] 

Share this article:

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
PIL filed by Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay in SC for 3-yr Bachelor of Law degree after Class XII

PIL by Ashwini Kumar in SC seeks to shorten law degree to 3 years post-Class XII, citing current 5-year span as irrational.

18 April, 2024 11:21 AM
Trending Judiciary
'We all know what happened when there were ballot papers,' SC on return of ballot papers or 100% VVPATs count

SC questions EVM process, debates ballot paper return and 100% VVPAT count verification, citing past issues.

18 April, 2024 01:53 PM


Trending Interview
LSJ Exclusive Interview: How BJP govt will free Chhattisgarh from “Naxal menace”? [Watch Video]

What is Chhattisgarh govt's plan for solving the Maoist/Naxalite problem in the state? Will there be a surgical strike against the Naxals or solution will be found via diplomatic channels? Read the Exclusive Interview with the Deputy Chief Minister Vijay Sharma.

13 April, 2024 12:33 PM
Trending Judiciary
SC rejects review of order to pay Rs 1.54 Cr compensation to ex Air Force staff for transfusion of HIV infected blood [Read Order]

SC denies review of Rs 1.54 Cr HIV compensation order to ex-Air Force staff for medical negligence.

13 April, 2024 03:13 PM
Trending Legal Insiders
CJI cautions against overlooking ethical legal consideration on use of AI in court adjudication

CJI D Y Chandrachud warns about ethical, legal challenges in AI use in courts, stressing need for thorough review.

13 April, 2024 07:08 PM
Trending Legal Insiders
Need to safeguard judiciary from unwarranted pressures: 21 ex-judges write letter to CJI

21 ex-judges write to CJI Chandrachud urging protection of judiciary from pressures undermining its integrity and autonomy.

15 April, 2024 12:17 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email