38.6c New Delhi, India, Monday, May 27, 2024

"Today is The 'Test Night,' Ensure No One Dies Due to Lack of Oxygen as it is a Violation of Article 21," says the Bombay High Court to the Goa government [READ ORDER]

By Kartikey Garg      14 May, 2021 08:52 PM      0 Comments

On Wednesday (May 12, 2021) the Bombay High Court (Goa Bench) observed that it is every state's responsibility to protect the lives of its citizens, emphasizing that if a COVID positive patient dies due to a lack of oxygen, it is an infringement of the right to life under Article 21.

Noting that patients are indeed suffering and, in some cases, dying due to a lack of oxygen supply, the Bench of Justice M. S. Sonak and Justice N. W. Sambre specifically stated in the State of Goa, "The Constitution says that no lives should be lost, if deaths occur due to a lack of oxygen, then it is a clear case of violating the fundamental right to life, and it is not acceptable." The Court also noted that the situation regarding oxygen supply at the Goa Medical College is quite dire, and that we have long passed the stage of determining whether or not patients are suffering from a lack of oxygen.

Notably, the Court also stated, "There is a corresponding duty imposed on the State to ensure that this life is not extinguished as a result of the State's inability to supply oxygen to these unfortunate victims of the pandemic. This duty cannot be avoided by claiming helplessness or citing logistical difficulties in obtaining and supplying oxygen."

Submissions made in front of the Court

All of the officials who appeared in court explained the problems with the supply of oxygen, particularly at Goa Medical College. They pointed out that, despite the fact that Goa Medical College has a bed capacity of about 700, there are approximately 950 patients admitted there, and that such excess patients must be administered oxygen via loose cylinders. Given the GMC's oxygen crisis, the Court stated that the State must take all necessary steps to ensure that such logistical difficulties are overcome as soon as possible and that no casualties result from a lack of oxygen supply to the pandemic victims.

Observations of the Court

Postponing the matter until tomorrow, the Court expressed hope that there will be no casualties at the Goa Medical College due to a lack of oxygen tonight, and even tomorrow, thanks to the Dean and the State Administration of which he is a part. Furthermore, accepting the conditions proposed by the learned Advocate General and directing the authorities to comply with such conditions, the Court waived the requirement of a COVID negative certificate for two drivers and one helper per goods vehicle until further orders were issued.

However, the Court made it clear that at each border, the police or other authorities will be required to scan such individuals with thermal guns to see if they exhibit any symptoms. Finally, emphasizing that the limited waiver is not to be construed as a general license allowing any person to enter the State of Goa without a COVID negative certificate, the Court stated, "We clarify that we have not ordered the sealing of Goa borders but, having regard to the unfortunate fact that Goa is one of the worst affected States, we have only directed that a COVID negative certificate be insisted from persons entering into Goa." As a result, all parties involved were directed to recognize that there is no need for unnecessary waiver in the name of protecting the economy's interests.



Share this article:

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [May 20 - May 25]

Get the latest updates from the Supreme Court of India and the High Courts ! Here’s a round up of the week's top legal stories in a quick, easy-to-read summary.

26 May, 2024 11:25 AM
Trending Executive
Arvind Kejriwal moves Supreme Court to extend interim bail by 1 week for medical tests

Arvind Kejriwal seeks Supreme Court extension of interim bail by one week for medical tests in Delhi excise policy case amid ongoing ED investigation.

27 May, 2024 11:24 AM


Trending Business
Agarwal Family Plans to Sell Haldiram for Rs. 71,000 Crores as Next Generation Steps Back

The Agarwal family plans to sell Haldiram, valued at Rs. 71,000 crores, with a Blackstone-led consortium bidding. This marks India's largest private equity buyout.

21 May, 2024 03:32 PM
Trending Crime, Police And Law
13 Year old boy booked for impregnating 15 year old sister, after watching porn together

Minor siblings watch porn together brother rapes and impregnates sister. Police official probing the matter shared that the siblings tried to have sex for the first time in Dec 2023, but failed.

21 May, 2024 03:54 PM
Trending Judiciary
“Replacing colonial-era codes,” new criminal laws to come into effect on July 1

“Replacing colonial-era codes,” the new criminal laws to come into effect on July 1. However, Section 106(2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) has been put on hold. Read the full article to know why.

21 May, 2024 04:57 PM
Trending Judiciary
Offences Under Section 354D Ipc And Section 506 Ipc Are Personal To Parties: Rules Supreme Court

The Supreme Court quashed stalking and criminal intimidation charges to preserve marital ties, invoking Article 142, deeming the offences personal to the parties involved.

21 May, 2024 05:40 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email