38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, March 28, 2024
Legal Insiders

“We Have the Constitutional Duty to Protect Human Dignity as it is as Important as the Freedom of Speech and Expression”: Justice DY Chandrachud in Sudarshan TV Show Case

By Meghna Mishra      19 September, 2020 05:52 PM      0 Comments
“We Have the Constitutional Duty to Protect Human Dignity as it is as Important as the Freedom of Speech and Expression”: Justice DY Chandrachud in Sudarshan TV Show Case

Justice DY Chandrachud was presiding in the matter of the Sudarshan TV suit. In a recent statement, the Hon’ble Justice stated that the right to human dignity is of grave importance. It is as important as freedom of speech and expression.

The Justice made this statement as he presided over the case regarding the much-debated show “Bindas Bol” which has been creating abuzz due to its controversial content. The court also opined that the show vilified the Muslim community.

While giving his statement, Justice Chandrachud further opined that “Let the marketplace of ideas flourish in India. We know what happened during the Emergency. But we have the constitutional duty to protect human dignity and that Is as important as protecting free speech.” He has also directed the channel in the current matter to file a clear affidavit. The affidavit must indicate that the channel would take good faith efforts to protect the dignity of the community in question.

The bench, which also comprised of Justices Indu Malhotra and KM Joseph stated that the show was presented in and “inciteful manner”

Another important point highlighted by Hon’ble Justice 

Chandrachud was that any community should not be represented that stereotypically. A prejudiced representation of the Muslim community, with the repeated insistence that the community has infiltrated the bureaucracy, is dangerous and needs to be addressed.

“Representation of Muslims with a beard, skull cap and green face, with frames in the background” should be considered inciteful and hurtful to the feelings of the community.

The bench did agree that the channel has been successful in raising significant questions regarding natural security. But, this cannot be done at the cost of human dignity. Investigative journalism cannot supersede human dignity. “Whenever you refer to the Civil Services, you refer to the ISI and that is a serious concern as you show it as a conspiracy by Muslims. Of course, do your investigative journalism, but can we allow such implications being made. As judges, we are also concerned about national security. But we have to protect human dignity as well”, the Bench further opined.

Stating this, the bench highlighted that it was not their intention to restrict investigative journalism. However, the journalism cannot reflect that each member of a particular community is from a terrorist organization, just because a funding member is “not above the Board”.

The bench concluded by passing an order for the channel to file an affidavit along with chalking out a plan which would state how the channel planned to strike a balance.



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

supreme-court-orders-cbi-probe-into-alleged-murder-of-manipur-girl-emphasizes-fair-criminal-investigation
Trending Judiciary
Supreme Court Orders CBI Probe into Alleged Murder of Manipur Girl: Emphasizes Fair Criminal Investigation [Read Judgment]

Supreme Court emphasizes fair criminal investigation, warns unresolved crimes erode public trust. Orders CBI probe into Manipur girl's alleged murder.

27 March, 2024 01:09 PM
india-summons-us-diplomat-over-state-dept-remarks-on-kejriwals-arrest
Trending International
India summons US diplomat over state dept remarks on Kejriwal's arrest

After CAA, U.S. wades into Arvind Kejriwal’s arrest. Here's how India responded.

27 March, 2024 04:41 PM

TOP STORIES

global-entertainment-giants-warner-bros-netflix-amazon-get-relief-from-delhi-hc-in-copyright-protection-case
Trending Business
Global entertainment giants Warner Bros, Netflix, Amazon get relief from Delhi HC in copyright protection case

Delhi HC grants relief to global entertainment giants like Netflix, Amazon, Warner Bros, ordering takedown of copyrighted content on rogue websites.

22 March, 2024 12:13 PM
arvind-kejriwal-arrested-can-cm-administer-a-region-while-being-in-jail
Trending Top Stories
Arvind Kejriwal Arrested | Can CM administer a region while being in jail?

Will President's rule be imposed in Delhi after Kejriwal’s arrest? Read the full article to know more.

22 March, 2024 03:16 PM
merely-because-you-are-politician-cant-bypass-statutory-remedies-procedure-sc-refuses-to-consider-bail-by-kavitha
Trending Judiciary
'Merely because you are politician, can't bypass statutory remedies, procedure,' SC refuses to consider bail by Kavitha

Supreme Court denies bail to politician Kavitha in Delhi Liquor Policy Scam; ED alleges Rs 100 crore illegal gratification.

22 March, 2024 03:34 PM
ponmudi-to-be-sworn-in-as-minister-tn-governor-relents-before-sc
Trending Judiciary
Ponmudi to be sworn in as Minister, TN Governor relents before SC

Tamil Nadu Governor relents to Supreme Court's order, agrees to swear in DMK leader K Ponmudi as Minister after court's rap.

22 March, 2024 03:54 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email