38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, August 30, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Business

Arguments Raised By Parsoli Motors Are Illogical And Repugnant To Reason, BMW India Gets Clean Chit: NCLAT [Read Judgment]

By Shanya Sharma      04 December, 2019 01:12 PM      0 Comments
Arguments Raised By Parsoli Motors Are Illogical And Repugnant To Reason, BMW India Gets Clean Chit: NCLAT [Read Judgment]

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal in the case of Parsoli Motors Works Pvt. Ltd. v. BMW India Private Ltd & Ors. Competition Appeal (AT) No. 52 of 2018 on November 25, 2019 held that BMW does not hold a dominant position in the relevant market, i.e., passenger car segment in India and hence, the question of abuse of dominant position does not even arise. 

A division bench comprising of Justices S.J. Mukhopadhaya (Chairperson) and Bansi Lal Bhat (Judicial Member) was hearing an appeal against the order dated May 30, 2018 passed by the Competition Commission of India or CCI under Section 26 (2) of the Competition Act, 2002 in Case No. 11 of 2018 whereby the information relating to allegations of contravention of provisions of Section 4 of the Act filed by the Appellant (Parsoli Motors, i.e. Informant before CCI) was ordered to be closed on the ground that the existing Dealership Agreement between the Appellant and Respondent No. 1 (BMW India) stood expired by efflux of time on December 31, 2017 due to non-renewal thereof and the Informant had not challenged any term of the aforesaid Dealership Agreement which has since expired.

Parsoli Motors was a dealer of BMW India in Gujarat from 2007 to 2017. BMW India Financial Services is a group company of BMW India that financially supports the sales effected by BMW India.  Abuse of dominant position by an enterprise, forbidden under Section 4 of the Act, essentially arises out of a position of strength enjoyed by an enterprise in the relevant market enabling it to operate independent of the competitive forces or affects its competitors or consumers or the relevant market in a manner that tilts the balance in its favour. While holding and enjoyment of a dominant position in itself is not prohibited, its abuse is proscribed.

Therefore, to establish abuse of dominance on part of BMW India, it was necessary to firstly, establish that BMW held a dominant position in the relevant market and secondly, that dominant position was being abused by it. In the first scenario, the court held that BMW India held negligible shares in the market of passenger cars in India and its competitors like Maruti, Tata and Hyundai were the ones having a significant share in the market. Hence, when there was no dominant position, the question of abuse of such position did not even arise.

The court further clarified that if the termination of the dealership of Parsoli Motors or refusal on the part of BMW India to further renew dealership in favour of the Parsoli Motors is in derogation of the policy framed in this regard and if Parsoli Motors had altered its position by raising infrastructure and making investment for running such dealership, breach thereof may give rise to civil liability but not have the consequence of abuse of dominant position under the competition laws of the country.

[Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

supreme-court-appoints-two-new-judges-justice-alok-aradhe-and-future-cji-vipul-pancholi
Trending Judiciary
Supreme Court Appoints Two New Judges: Justice Alok Aradhe & Future CJI Vipul Pancholi

SC gets two new judges — Justices Alok Aradhe and Vipul Manubhai Pancholi, with Pancholi set to be CJI in 2031. Oath administered by CJI Gavai.

29 August, 2025 02:23 PM
sc-to-hear-on-monday-pleas-to-extend-september-1-deadline-for-claims-objections-in-bihar-sir
Trending Judiciary
SC to hear on Monday pleas to extend September 8 deadline for claims, objections in Bihar SIR [Read Order]

SC to hear on Monday pleas seeking extension of Sept 8 deadline for filing claims, objections in Bihar voter list revision.

29 August, 2025 02:32 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-restores-mandatory-20-percent-deposit-for-suspension-of-sentence-in-cheque-bounce-case
Trending Judiciary
SC Restores Mandatory 20% Deposit for Suspension of Sentence in Cheque Bounce Case [Read Order]

SC sets aside P&H HC order; rules 20% deposit mandatory for suspension of sentence in ₹8.65 crore cheque bounce case under NI Act.

25 August, 2025 12:35 PM
18-former-judges-write-to-union-home-minister-amit-shah-criticizing-his-remarks-on-justice-b-sudershan-reddy
Trending Judiciary
18 Former Judges write to Union Home Minister Amit Shah, criticizing his remarks on Justice B Sudershan Reddy

18 ex-judges write to Union HM Amit Shah, criticizing his remarks on Justice B Sudershan Reddy, stressing judicial independence and dignity.

25 August, 2025 03:09 PM
sc-stays-investigation-into-firs-against-csds-co-director-sanjay-kumar
Trending Judiciary
SC stays investigation into FIRs against CSDS co director Sanjay Kumar

SC stays probe into FIRs against CSDS co-director Sanjay Kumar over Maharashtra polling data post; says multiple cases show harassment motive.

25 August, 2025 03:14 PM
influencers-indulging-in-commercial-speech-cant-claim-fundamental-right-sc
Trending CelebStreet
Influencers indulging in commercial speech can't claim fundamental right: SC

SC: Influencers making commercial speech can’t claim fundamental rights; must apologize and act responsibly towards community sensitivities.

25 August, 2025 04:18 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email