38.6c New Delhi, India, Monday, April 15, 2024

Zee Media v. Mahua Moitra: Delhi HC Refuses to Stay Defamation Proceedings before the Trial Court

By Richa Shah      06 November, 2020 08:26 PM      0 Comments
Zee Media v. Mahua Moitra: Delhi HC Refuses to Stay Defamation Proceedings before the Trial Court

The defamation proceedings of Rouse Avenue Court (pertaining to the criminal defamation case filed by Zee Media’s editor Sudhir Chaudhary against Member of Parliament Mahua Moitra) which was pending before the Delhi High Court was refused a stay.

A plea was filed seeking the quashing of a summoning order passed by the trial court in a defamation case filed against her by Zee Media. The order had come in response to this plea which was moved by a Member of Parliament from Trinamool Congress.

The Single Bench of Justice VibhuBakhru while observing that criminal reference concerning this matter is pending before a Division Bench of the court noted that it was unlikely that there will be the commencement of the recording of evidence by the trial court will be done before the said reference is taken up the High Court.

The present petition which is filed by Mahua Moitra seeks to quash the summoning order dated 25.09.2019. This order dated 25.09.2019 was passed by an Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate in a criminal defamation case filed against her by Zee Media.

The order dated 10.01.2020 was also challenged by Ms. Moitra whereby the ACMM had framed notice against her by noting that a no power vests with the Magistrate to discharge an accused in a summons triable case.

The court is also asked in the petition to exercise its powers under Article 227 of the Constitution to issue practice directions to the subordinate courts in relation to exercise powers under Section 251 of the Criminal Procedure Code to discharge an accused in a summons triable case instituted on a complaint.

The Petitioner while claiming that the said order was passed by the Magistrate without even providing proper hearing to him, a set of following questions of law has been presented before the court:

  1. Whether a Magistrate seized a complaint case that contains offences that are in nature of ‘summons triable cases” has the power to discharge an Accused under Section 251 of the CrPC.
  2. Whether a magistrate is to act as a post box upon appearance by a person summoned and to simpliciter frame notice under Section 251 CrPC, irrespective of the reason placed by such person appearance?
  3. Whether a complainant in a defamation case can claim defamation in respect of utterances made while being hounded and abused continuously?
  4. Whether the right of self-defense exists in the case of defamation?

The petitioner argued that the court did not consider the fact that the statements made by the petitioner were in the form of a fair retort to the constant haranguing buy the reporters of Zee Media.

The said controversy came to light after the speech given by Moitra on the floor of the Parliament. In this speech, she had highlighted early signs of fascism. Moitra’s parliamentary speech was plagiarized according to Sudhir Choudhary from Zee Media.

Share this article:

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Legal Insiders
Need to safeguard judiciary from unwarranted pressures: 21 ex-judges write letter to CJI

21 ex-judges write to CJI Chandrachud urging protection of judiciary from pressures undermining its integrity and autonomy.

15 April, 2024 12:17 PM
Trending Judiciary
SC notice to ED; declines early date on plea by Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal against arrest

SC issues notice to ED, declines early hearing on Delhi CM Kejriwal's plea against arrest in liquor scam.

15 April, 2024 03:08 PM


Trending Judiciary
Location sharing of accused as bail condition: SC directs Google to explain how its PIN location-sharing work

Supreme Court directs Google to explain its PIN location-sharing feature as bail condition for accused, raising privacy concerns. Details sought on technical aspects.

09 April, 2024 02:06 PM
Trending Judiciary
'Can't jail everyone for making allegations against CM,' SC tells Tamil Nadu government

Supreme Court rebukes Tamil Nadu, saying not everyone making allegations against CM can be jailed; restores bail for YouTuber Sattai.

09 April, 2024 02:07 PM
Trending Judiciary
HC dismisses Kejriwal's plea challenging arrest by ED in liquor policy case

Delhi High Court dismisses Arvind Kejriwal's plea challenging his arrest by ED in liquor policy case, ruling it legal. Kejriwal remains in Tihar jail pending Supreme Court relief.

09 April, 2024 05:22 PM
Trending Judiciary
SC allows man to undergo potency test as wife claims marriage not consummated more than 7 years of alliance [Read Judgment]

Supreme Court permits potency test for husband in divorce case where wife alleges marriage unconsummated after 7+ years.

09 April, 2024 05:38 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email