38.6c New Delhi, India, Sunday, November 10, 2024
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Executive

Central Government files review petition against the judgment of the Supreme Court, abrogating the powers of State Government to identify and notify SEBCs.

By Aishwarya Gairola      17 May, 2021 02:35 PM      0 Comments
Central Government files review petition against the judgment of the Supreme Court, abrogating the powers of State Government to identify and notify SEBCs.

A constitutional bench of the Supreme Court comprising Justices L Nageswara Rao, Hemant Gupta and S Ravindra Bhat, Ashok Bhushan and S Abdul Nazeer, on May 5th, 2021 while dealing with the constitutionality of the Maratha Quota ha by 3:2 majority held that after the 102nd Constitutional Amendment, only the President has the power to notify Socially and Economically Backward Classes and the State Government can simply make recommendations. However, the minority held that the effect of the amendment was only related to the power of the Centre to identify SEBCs for the central list.

The Union Government in this case took held the stance expressed through Attorney General KK Venugopal that the amendment will not affect the power of the states and that the Parliamentary Committee and the union minister who introduced the amendment bill had unequivocally said that the amendment will not have any impact on the powers of the State to identify SEBCs.

The amendment in question, 102ndConstitutional Amendment Act of 2018 introduced Article 338B and Article 342A, providing for National Commission for Backward Classes and specification and identification of the socially and educationally backward class by public notification in the states by the President after consultation with the Governor, which shall for the purpose of the Constitution be deemed to be socially and educationally backward classes in relation to the State or Union territory.

Justice Ravindra Bhat, who wrote the leading judgment for himself and Hemant Gupta,  interpreted 102ndAmendment and observed that, by the introduction of Article 366 (26C) and Article 342A, the President alone to the exclusion of all the other authority is empowered to specify and identify SEBCs and the state can only make recommendations for inclusion, exclusion or modification of castes or communities, in the list to be published under Article 342A(1) and the reference to the Central List under Article 342A (2) is the list notified by the President under Article 342A(1) and doesnt make any inference to any power that the states may have to publish their own lists. The lists once published can only be amended through a law enacted by the Parliament by virtue of Article 342A (2) and the states power to make reservations in favour of a particular community or caste, the quantum of reservation and the nature and kind of benefits, among other matters falling under the ambit of Article 15 and 16, except with respect to identification of SEBCs remain undisturbed.

Justice Rao wrote a separate judgment, agreeing with Justice Bhats interpretation of !02ndConstitutional Amendment Act and observed that there is only one list that can be issued by the President specifying the socially and economically backward classes and only those classes are treated as SEBCs for the purpose of the Constitution of India.

Justice Ashok Bhushan and S Abdul Nazeer (minority) opined that the 102ndConstitutional Amendment doesnt take away the power of the state to identify backward class in the state, and observed that usage of the word Central in Article 342A(2) was used for purpose and object and that it was a well-settled rule of interpretation that no word in a statute is used without purpose, thus the word has to be given meaning and purpose, which upon interpretation means list prepared for service under the government of India and organizations under the government of the definition given under Article 366(26C) which specifically refer to Article 342A has to be read together and list of backward classes which is not Central List shall not be governed by the definition under Article 366(26C). Since the (26C) has been inserted in the context of Article 342A if the context is a list prepared by the State and it is State List, the definition under (26C) shall not govern and held that Article 342A was brought by Constitution 102nd Amendment to give constitutional status to National Backward Classes Commission and for publication of list by the President of socially and educationally backward classes which were to be Central List for governing employment under Government of India and the organisations under it.



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS


TOP STORIES

scba-scaora-strongly-condemn-ghaziabad-court-incident
Trending Judiciary
SCBA, SCAORA strongly condemn Ghaziabad court incident [Read SCBA, SCAORA Resolution]

SCBA, SCAORA condemn Ghaziabad court incident, demand inquiry, dismissal of judge, police, and Advocate Protection Act to prevent future violence.

04 November, 2024 11:18 AM
bail-conditions-must-be-fair-reasonable-cannot-tantamount-to-deprivation-of-civil-rights-sc
Trending Judiciary
Bail conditions must be fair, reasonable; cannot tantamount to deprivation of civil rights: SC [Read Judgment]

SC asserts that bail conditions must be fair and reasonable, ensuring accused’s presence without infringing civil rights, overturns Madhya Pradesh HC’s excessive terms.

04 November, 2024 11:55 AM
sc-declines-interim-relief-to-death-row-convict-rajoana-gives-two-weeks-to-punjab-to-file-response-to-plea-on-delay-in-mercy-petition
Trending Judiciary
SC declines interim relief to death row convict Rajoana; gives two weeks to Punjab to file response to plea on delay in mercy petition

SC denies interim relief to death row convict Rajoana; grants Punjab two weeks to respond on plea over delay in mercy petition. Next hearing on Nov 18.

04 November, 2024 03:56 PM
sc-modifies-bail-condition-to-report-to-local-police-station-every-week-for-kerala-journalist-sidhique-kappan
Trending Judiciary
SC modifies bail condition to report to local police station every week for Kerala journalist Sidhique Kappan

SC relaxes bail condition for Kerala journalist Sidhique Kappan, removing weekly police station visits in UAPA case linked to Hathras incident.

04 November, 2024 05:16 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email

kaisarpoker kaisarpoker
https://kurbali.com/doc/available/
https://rodithahotel.com/public/core/
https://smpn43sby.sch.id/sma/kaisarpoker/
https://banksyariahdanamulia.co.id/wap/scatter-hitam/
https://banksyariahdanamulia.co.id/log/available/
https://wayan.com.mx/doc/core/
https://kaisarpoker.banksyariahdanamulia.co.id/
https://banksyariahdanamulia.co.id/wap/scatter-hitam
https://kaisarpoker.banksyariahdanamulia.co.id
https://banksyariahdanamulia.co.id/wap/scatter-hitam https://banksyariahdanamulia.co.id/public/crownking/ https://4csupremelawint.com/doc/kaisarpoker/ https://cianjurkotasantri.com/wap/superkaisar/
slot gacor
https://kaisarpoker.missteeninternational.us/ https://www.phprentacar.ro/doc/superkaisar/ https://kaisarpoker.camaraayacucho.org.pe/
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
grafindo.id
kaisar-poker.banksyariahdanamulia.co.id
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
situs anti rungkat
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
bandar slot
kaisar poker
situs anti rungkat
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
situs anti blokir
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
Link Alternatif Terbaru Global
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
situs anti rungkat
slot anti rungkat
bandar bola slot
bocoran parlay
situs slot pakai qris
slot bet 200
slot gampang maxwin
slot gacor
slot anti lag
situs anti blokir
slot gacor kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker anti rungkat
slot gampang scatter kaisarpoker
kaisarpoker
slot online kaisarpoker
scatter hitam
slot online kaisarpoker
situs slot sudirman168
slot gacor sudirman168
rtp slot sudirman168
situs anti rungkat sudirman168
scatter hitam mahjong wins 3
sudirman168
sudirman168
sudirman168
sudirman168
situs sudirman168
kaisarpoker kaisarpoker link kaisarpoker club kaisarpoker 2024 kaisarpoker scatter hitam kaisarpoker slot kaisarpoker slot 5k kaisarpoker slot qris kaisarpoker slot dana kaisarpoker slot gacor kaisarpoker slot online kaisarpoker slot 5000 kaisarpoker slot pulsa kaisarpoker slot 200 kaisarpoker slot 400 kaisarpoker deposit murah kaisarpoker deposit qris kaisarpoker deposit dana kaisarpoker deposit pulsa kaisarpoker rtp slot kaisarpoker rtp live kaisarpoker situs slot kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker agen slot kaisarpoker agen pulsa kaisarpoker link gacor kaisarpoker link slot kaisarpoker pola gacor kaisarpoker anti rungkat kaisarpoker apk kaisarpoker apk slot kaisarpoker cheat slot kaisarpoker anti rungkat kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker blackjack sbs kaisarpoker wap kaisarpoker today kaisarpoker loan kaisar 888 kaisar poker club prediksi parlay deposit qris deposit murah deposit tanpa antrian situs situs gacor situs slot situs terpercaya situs anti rungkat
https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=scatter%20hitam https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=game%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=pragmatic%20play https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=pg%20soft https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=mahjong%20ways https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=bonanza%201000 https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=zeus%20X15000 https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20terbaru https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20terlengkap https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20demo https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%205k https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20qris https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20dana https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20gacor https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20online https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%205000 https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20pulsa https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20200 https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20400 https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20maxwin https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=slot%20anti%20rungkad https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=tips%20maxwin https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20murah https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20qris https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20dana https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20pulsa https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=rtp%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=rtp%20live https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20gacor https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=agen%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=agen%20pulsa https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=link%20gacor https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=link%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=pola%20gacor https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=anti%20rungkat https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=apk%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=cheat%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=anti%20rungkat https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20gacor https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=kaisar%20888 https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=prediksi%20parlay https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20qris https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20murah https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=deposit%20tanpa%20antrian https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20gacor https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20slot https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20terpercaya https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=situs%20anti%20rungkat https://www.cammelplasticsurgery.com/kaisar-poker/?terbaru=tips%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20link https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20club https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%202024 https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20scatter%20hitam https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%205k https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20qris https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20dana https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20online https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%205000 https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20pulsa https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20200 https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20slot%20400 https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20deposit%20murah https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20deposit%20qris https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20deposit%20dana https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20deposit%20pulsa https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20rtp%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20rtp%20live https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20situs%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20situs%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20agen%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20agen%20pulsa https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20link%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20link%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20pola%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20anti%20rungkat https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20apk https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20apk%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20cheat%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20anti%20rungkat https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20situs%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20blackjack%20sbs https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20wap https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20today https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisarpoker%20loan https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisar%20888 https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=kaisar%20poker%20club https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=prediksi%20parlay https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=deposit%20qris https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=deposit%20murah https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=deposit%20tanpa%20antrian https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=situs https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=situs%20gacor https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=situs%20slot https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=situs%20terpercaya https://nomore.pt/kaisarpoker/?akses=situs%20anti%20rungkat
kaisarpoker kaisarpoker link kaisarpoker club kaisarpoker 2024 kaisarpoker scatter hitam kaisarpoker slot kaisarpoker slot 5k kaisarpoker slot qris kaisarpoker slot dana kaisarpoker slot gacor kaisarpoker slot online kaisarpoker slot 5000 kaisarpoker slot pulsa kaisarpoker slot 200 kaisarpoker slot 400 kaisarpoker deposit murah kaisarpoker deposit qris kaisarpoker deposit dana kaisarpoker deposit pulsa kaisarpoker rtp slot kaisarpoker rtp live kaisarpoker situs slot kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker agen slot kaisarpoker agen pulsa kaisarpoker link gacor kaisarpoker link slot kaisarpoker pola gacor kaisarpoker anti rungkat kaisarpoker apk kaisarpoker apk slot kaisarpoker cheat slot kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker blackjack sbs kaisarpoker jackpot kaisarpoker official kaisarpoker live chat kaisarpoker daftar kaisarpoker website kaisarpoker image kaisarpoker website kaisarpoker indonesia kaisarpoker murah kaisarpoker online kaisarpoker wap kaisarpoker login kaisarpoker today kaisarpoker loan kaisarpoker prediksi parlay kaisarpoker deposit murah kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker situs terpercaya kaisarpoker situs slot kaisarpoker deposit qris kaisar 888 kaisar poker club deposit tanpa antrian situs anti rungkat
kaisarpoker kaisarpoker link kaisarpoker club kaisarpoker 2024 kaisarpoker scatter hitam kaisarpoker slot kaisarpoker slot 5k kaisarpoker slot qris kaisarpoker slot dana kaisarpoker slot gacor kaisarpoker slot online kaisarpoker slot 5000 kaisarpoker slot pulsa kaisarpoker slot 200 kaisarpoker slot 400 kaisarpoker deposit murah kaisarpoker deposit qris kaisarpoker deposit dana kaisarpoker deposit pulsa kaisarpoker rtp slot kaisarpoker rtp live kaisarpoker situs slot kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker agen slot kaisarpoker agen pulsa kaisarpoker link gacor kaisarpoker link slot kaisarpoker pola gacor kaisarpoker anti rungkat kaisarpoker apk kaisarpoker apk slot kaisarpoker cheat slot kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker blackjack sbs kaisarpoker jackpot kaisarpoker official kaisarpoker live chat kaisarpoker daftar kaisarpoker website kaisarpoker image kaisarpoker website kaisarpoker indonesia kaisarpoker murah kaisarpoker online kaisarpoker wap kaisarpoker login kaisarpoker today kaisarpoker loan kaisarpoker prediksi parlay kaisarpoker deposit murah kaisarpoker situs gacor kaisarpoker situs terpercaya kaisarpoker situs slot kaisarpoker deposit qris kaisar 888 kaisar poker club deposit tanpa antrian situs anti rungkat
bacan4d
bacansport
bacan4d
xx1toto
mahjong scatter
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacansport
bacansport
xx1toto
bacansport
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacansport
xx1toto
bacan4d
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
linkbacan4d
bacan4d
bacan4d
bacansports
bacan4d
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacan4d
scatter hitam
xx1toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacan4d
xx1toto scatter hitam
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacansport
bacan4d
ts77casino bet 200
bacansport
aplikasi slot
xx1toto scatter hitam
bacan4d
bacan4d
situs toto
xx1toto
xx1toto
bacansport
bacan4d
xx1toto
slottoto
xx1toto
bacan4d
bacan4d
ts77casino
ts77casino
ts77casino
ts77casino
Scatter Hitam
Situs Toto
toto slot
Scatter Hitam
Situs Toto
toto slot
scatter hitam
slot mahjong wins 3
mahjong wins 3 black scatter
scatter hitam
ts77casino
ts77casino
tabel shio 2025