38.6c New Delhi, India, Monday, May 20, 2024

'Transgender, MSM, sex workers high risk category,' Centre defends in SC guidelines prohibiting blood donation by them

By LawStreet News Network      13 March, 2023 05:59 PM      0 Comments
'Transgender, MSM, sex workers high risk category,' Centre defends in SC guidelines prohibiting blood donation by them

NEW DELHI: The Centre has opposed before the Supreme Court a plea for a change in the guidelines that prohibited transgender persons, men having sex with men (MSM) and female sex workers from donating blood.

Maintaining that it is imperative that donors and recipients of blood donation have complete faith that the collected sample is safe and clinically effective, the government said the exclusion of transgender persons, MSM and female sex workers as blood donors were based on scientific evidence which is globally recognised and accepted by subject experts in India.

In an affidavit, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare said the blood transfusion system (BTS) in the country relied on blood donation and the guidelines have been put in place on account of the existing reality with regard to the quality of health system that varied throughout the country.

“It is important that every effort be made to strengthen the integrity of India’s BTS so as to instil confidence in people who have little option but to use the BTS in what may perhaps be the most difficult situation in their lives,” it said.

The government's response came in a PIL filed Manipur-based, Thangjam Santa Singh. The top court had on March 5, 2021 issued notice to the Centre in the matter.

The plea questioned validity of the Guidelines for Blood Donor Selection and Blood Donor Referral 2017 as it prohibited transgender persons, and men having sex with men and female sex workers from being donor. It contended that guidelines, which considered them as high-risk category for being HIV and AIDS infected, were violative of fundamental rights under Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution in view of being discriminatory on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation.

In reply, the government said it was imperative that both donor and recipient at opposite end have complete faith that the blood available in blood banks was not only safe but also clinically effective and of appropriate and consistent quality.

"Ensuring the safety and availability of blood was a major public health responsibility," the government said, adding the situation in developed countries was different as they deployed nucleic acid testing (NAT) which reduced the window period for transfusion-transmitted infections (TTIs).

In India, only a fraction of the 3,866 licensed blood banks deployed NAT technology, the government pointed out, saying the NAT technology was very expensive, required trained manpower and specialised equipment which demanded proper handling and regular maintenance.

The Ministry also pointed out, scientific evidence clearly showed that transgender persons, MSM and female sex workers are globally recognised as a population group with a higher prevalence of HIV and other TTIs, which has been the basis for subject experts, in the present case the NBTC, to prescribe the exclusions.

“A robust BTS is an essential feature of any country’s healthcare system without which quality medical care is impossible...In India, the quality of the healthcare system varies immensely across different geographies and one has to be mindful of this reality while framing guidelines for the entire country,” the Centre said.

In 2021, while seeking the government's response in the matter, the court had refused to stay the guidelines.

Share this article:

User Avatar

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
Supreme Court refuses to entertain plea for stay on new criminal laws

SC refuses plea to stay new criminal laws. Court deems the plea casual, noting laws aren't yet implemented. Petitioner withdraws. Laws effective from July 1, 2024.

20 May, 2024 12:58 PM
Trending Know The Law
SCBA Election Result 2024, Know the newly elected members

SCBA Election Result 2024: Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal elected President. Know the newly elected members and key office bearers leading the Supreme Court Bar Association.

20 May, 2024 03:03 PM


Trending Judiciary
SC Issues Notice to ED on Hemant Soren's Plea Against Arrest in Land Scam

Supreme Court issues notice to ED on Hemant Soren's plea against arrest in a land scam case, sets hearing for May 17 after senior advocate Kapil Sibal's request for an earlier date.

14 May, 2024 11:24 AM
Trending Environment
3,800 metric tonnes of solid wastes going untreated everyday in Delhi SC records concern

The Supreme Court expressed concern as 3,800 metric tonnes of solid waste in Delhi go untreated daily. The issue must be addressed promptly beyond political lines.

14 May, 2024 11:30 AM
Trending Judiciary
Plea filed in SC for review of April 26 EVM VVPAT verdict

A plea has been filed in the Supreme Court to review its April 26 verdict on EVM VVPAT verification, challenging the decision that dismissed a demand for 100% vote cross-verification.

14 May, 2024 12:13 PM
Trending Judiciary
AI can’t detect consent Microsoft and Google tell Delhi High Court

Microsoft and Google tell Delhi HC that AI can't detect consent for NCII takedowns, challenging a 24-hour removal directive under IT Act's safe harbour protections.

14 May, 2024 01:33 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email