38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, June 22, 2024

Article 370 Hearing: Ruckus Between AG/SG And Rajiv Dhavan On 5th Day Of Hearing; SC Reserves Order On Reference To Larger Bench

By LawStreet News Network      23 January, 2020 11:01 PM      0 Comments
Article 370 Hearing: Ruckus Between AG/SG And Rajiv Dhavan On 5th Day Of Hearing; SC Reserves Order On Reference To Larger Bench

A five-Judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court headed by Justices NV Ramana and comprising Justices SK Kaul, R Subhash Reddy, BR Gavai and Surya Kantis presently hearing the matters related to the constitutional validity of the abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution which has effectively removed the special status granted to the Jammu & Kashmir state. Today was the 5th day of hearing and some interesting exchanges between Attorney General (AG) KK Venugopal, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and Senior Advocate Rajiv Dhavan took place in the court room. 

Senior advocate Rajiv Dhavan conveyed to the court at the beginning that he supports the AG in question of reference to a larger bench, as there is no need to do it. 

AG countered to the submissions made by Senior Advocate Zafar Ahmed Shah yesterday by saying that the tribesmen under command of Pakistan army officials had come till Baramulla & “raped & killed right through” prompting the then Maharaja to seek help of Indian army. He also explained on how accession of J&K to the Indian Union had taken place and added that “it is irreversible”.

AG KK Venugopal while defending the government’s move to abrogate Article 370 told the Supreme Court that “the sovereignty of J&K was always temporary and India is after all a Union of States.”

AG apprised the court that there is no conflict between Prem Nath Kaul vs The State of Jammu & Kashmir [AIR 1959 SC 749] and Sampat Prakash vs State of Jammu & Kashmir & Anr [AIR 1970 SC 1118] necessitating reference of the matter to a 7-judge bench. 

At the end AG told the court that all questions regarding Article 370 and power of Parliament under it were settled in earlier judgments and there is no need to reopen it. 

Following AG, the Solicitor General (SG) Tushar Mehta while making submissions concurred with AG and told the court that Prem Nath Kaul and Sampat Prakash judgments may have taken different perceptions but there is no conflict and hence, matter need not be referred to a larger bench.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta pointed out to the Court that "No argument favouring secession or giving wrong picture about Kashmir should be permitted”.

After SG’s submissions Rajeev Dhavan explained the bench that the issue before this court is not whether Jammu & Kashmir is a part of India or not but the real issue is on what terms Jammu & Kashmir is a part of India.

Rajeev Dhavan further argued that a treaty and a J&K Constitution are in reality dismissed by the government’s move and for the first time Article 3 is used to demote any state in the constitutional history of India. He also criticised the imposition of the President’s rule prior to the abrogation of Article 370.

When AG proceeded to handover to bench copies of the Pakistani media reports on the SC hearing, Dhavan opposed it and said that AG is giving political argument. To which SG countered by saying that yesterday’s argument by Senior Advocate Zafar Ahmed Shah were also political. 

AG defended his historical arguments made at the beginning of the submissions by saying that he had to make it as a reply to what the opposite side had said it in their arguments and submissions. 

Justice BR Gavai also said that they had to hear what AG had to say as they had already heard the other side on historical perspective. 

When Rajiv Dhavan showed the maps of J&K, SG objected to it and asked why he was not arguing on merits. Dhavan was quick to bounce back by saying that if AG can rely on Mountbatten to criticise former PM Jawaharlal Nehru, then why he cannot show the map of J&K.

Following this ruckus Justice BR Gavai inquired with Dhavan on what was the point of showing the map, to which Dhavan replied by saying that he wanted to point out that a brick state has been reduced, dismembered and devoured by two powers.

At the end of the hearing, bench has reserved the order on the issue of reference of the matter to larger bench. 


Author: Parth Thummar

Share this article:

User Avatar

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
Gravity of offence not relevant when considering bail for juvenile [Read Order]

Allahabad High Court grants bail to a juvenile in a serious criminal case, ruling that the gravity of the offence is not a relevant factor in bail decisions.

22 June, 2024 11:18 AM
Trending Executive
New Anti-Cheating Law enacted: Analysis

In-depth analysis of India’s new Anti-Cheating Law, the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024, aimed at curbing exam malpractices.

22 June, 2024 11:38 AM


Trending Crime, Police And Law
Women, including housewife, approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh

Two women approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh, citing harassment for tweets based on news reports about his involvement in high-profile cases.

17 June, 2024 03:10 PM
Trending Judiciary
Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [June 10 - June 15]

Get the latest updates from the Supreme Court of India and the High Courts ! Here’s a round up of the week's top legal stories in a quick, easy-to-read summary.

17 June, 2024 03:29 PM
Trending Business
Man sues Apple for £5 million, blaming company for divorce after wife discovers ‘deleted messages’ with sex workers

A UK man sues Apple for £5M, claiming their unclear policy on deleted messages led to his divorce after his wife found texts to sex workers on another device.

17 June, 2024 04:26 PM
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Ex-Karnataka CM Yediyurappa appears before CID for POCSO case probe, with protection of 'no arrest'

Ex-Karnataka CM Yediyurappa appears before CID for POCSO case probe, denies allegations, granted ‘no arrest’ protection. Next hearing: June 28.

17 June, 2024 04:46 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email