38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, June 18, 2024
Judiciary

Bombay High Court Quashes Criminal Defamation Proceedings Against Ratan Tata, N Chandrasekaran [Read Judgment]

By LawStreet News Network      24 July, 2019 12:00 AM      0 Comments
Bombay High Court Quashes Criminal Defamation Proceedings Against Ratan Tata, N Chandrasekaran [Read Judgment]

The Bombay High Court on July 22, 2019, quashed proceedings initiated against Tata Sons’ former chairman Ratan Tata, its current chairman N. Chandrasekaran and eight directors of the firm in a criminal defamation case filed by Nusli Wadia.

In December 2018, a Magistrate Court in Mumbai issued notices to Ratan Tata and others in the criminal defamation case filed by Wadia in 2016 after he was voted out of the boards of some Tata Group companies.

Tata and others then approached the Bombay High Court seeking to quash and set aside the proceedings initiated against them.

A Division Bench of Justices Ranjit More and Bharati Dangre on July 22, 2019, quashed and set aside the proceedings.

Senior Counsel Abhishek Manu Singhvi, appearing for Ratan Tata, submitted before the court that the defamation case was because of a fallout of a corporate dispute.

He said the entire case was led with complete non-application of mind.

“The case is only a fallout of a corporate dispute between Ratan Tata and Nusli Wadia, who is a strong supporter of Cyrus Mistry,” Singhvi argued.

On the other hand, Wadia, in his complaint before the Magistrate, claimed that Tata and others made defamatory statements against him after they removed Cyrus Mistry on October 24, 2016, as the group chairman of Tata Sons.

Wadia was on the board as an independent director of group companies like Indian Hotels Company, which runs the Taj group of hotels, TCS, Tata Motors and Tata Steel, among others. He was voted out by shareholders at a specially convened general meeting between December 2016 and February 2017.

Wadia said that he approached the court as he was not satisfied with the explanation given by the respondents (Tata and others) following his letters to them.

He, therefore, initiated criminal defamation proceedings against Tata and others under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

Singhvi argued before the high court that what the complainant, Wadia, has termed as defamatory is wrong and not “defamatory per se”.

“The November 2016 letters and minutes of the meeting circulated by Tata Sons to its group companies only sought for Wadia’s removal as he was acting against the company’s interest,” Singhvi said.

Judgment

On hearing both the parties, the High Court ruled that a company is well within its rights to remove a Director as per Section 169 of the Companies Act, 2013, if it is found that he was acting against the interests of the company.

The court found merit in Singhvi's submission that there was non-application of mind on the part of the Magistrate in issuing notice. As noted in the judgment,

The Magistrate before issuing the process, has failed to take into consideration the conspectus of the matter and though it is the duty cast upon him to be satisfied before issuance of a process, he had concluded without any material being placed before him that the statement is defamatory.”

The court observed that there was no prima facie defamation involved and that it could not find any actual harm caused to Wadia's reputation. Moreover, it also noted that the element of mens rea was absent.

It, therefore, allowed Tata's plea, ruling that, “We conclude that the order passed by the magistrate is without application of mind and cannot be sustained and resultantly, we quash and set aside the impugned order.”

[Read Judgment]



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

women-including-housewife-approach-ncw-against-controversial-ips-officer-gyaneshwar-singh
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Women, including housewife, approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh

Two women approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh, citing harassment for tweets based on news reports about his involvement in high-profile cases.

17 June, 2024 03:10 PM
courts-this-week-law-street-journal-s-weekly-round-up-of-sc-anf-hcs-june-10-june-15
Trending Judiciary
Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [June 10 - June 15]

Get the latest updates from the Supreme Court of India and the High Courts ! Here’s a round up of the week's top legal stories in a quick, easy-to-read summary.

17 June, 2024 03:29 PM

TOP STORIES

bjp-workers-stabbed-near-village-masjid-for-celebrating-pm-narendra-modis-victory-by-raising-bharat-mata-ki-jai-slogan
Trending Crime, Police And Law
BJP workers stabbed near village Masjid, for celebrating PM Narendra Modi's victory by raising 'Bharat Mata ki Jai slogan'

BJP workers stabbed near village Masjid in Karnataka for celebrating Narendra Modi's third term as PM.

12 June, 2024 12:11 PM
meghwal-assumes-charge-as-minister-of-state-ind-in-law-and-justice-ministry
Trending Executive
Meghwal assumes charge as Minister of State (Ind) in Law & Justice Ministry

Arjun Ram Meghwal assumes charge as Minister of State (Independent Charge) for Law & Justice, focusing on speedy justice and awareness of new criminal laws.

12 June, 2024 12:39 PM
allahabad-high-court-quashes-fir-grants-protection-to-adult-couple-who-married-against-familys-wishes
Trending Judiciary
Allahabad High Court quashes FIR, grants protection to adult couple who married against family’s wishes [Read Order]

Allahabad High Court quashes FIR, protects couple who married against family’s wishes, emphasizing their constitutional rights and condemning threats to their lives.

12 June, 2024 02:00 PM
inform-on-action-taken-against-tanker-mafia-sc-asks-delhi-govt-on-water-crisis
Trending Judiciary
'Inform on action taken against tanker mafia,' SC asks Delhi govt on water crisis

SC demands Delhi govt to explain action against tanker mafia amid water crisis, heatwave in the capital. Affidavit required on measures taken by June 13.

12 June, 2024 03:52 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email