38.6c New Delhi, India, Wednesday, June 19, 2024

Bombay HC Slaps Rs. 5.80 Lacs Cost On 29 For Filing ‘Frivolous’ Petitions

By LawStreet News Network      04 February, 2020 11:02 PM      0 Comments
Bombay HC Slaps Rs. 5.80 Lacs Cost On 29 For Filing ‘Frivolous’ Petitions

The Nagpur bench of the Bombay High Court (HC) slapped a cost of Rs. 5.80 lakhs on 29 persons calling their petition a frivolous one on the 4th of February, 2020. While dismissing their plea, the High Court asked them to deposit the amount within four weeks & asked an Amravati collector to recover it in case of default.

In spite of such conduct on judgment debtors (petitioners) part, if this court is to lend its helping hand to them, a litigant would lose faith in country’s legal system & would start resorting to ‘Courts of Men’ & not ‘Courts of Law’,” a division bench of Justices Sunil Shukre and Milind Jadhav observed.

“If High Court helps petitioners, it would be doing great disservice to law & justice administration system. In that case, what was said about more than 100 years ago by the Privy Council, would continue to hold the field. It famously says that in India it is very easy to obtain a court’s decree, but it’s very difficult to execute it. The ordeal of a litigant in India really begins after he obtains a decree from the civil court & it happens when the decree holder is compelled to initiate execution proceeding,” the judges said adding they find this petition as “frivolous & vexatious” which deserves to be dismissed with exemplary costs"

Chandrashekhar Rathi, the managing trustee of Fattehlal Saligram Trust in Dhamangaon, had filed a civil suit before the civil court at Telhara in Akola for getting possession of agriculture land from petitioners Devidas Gavai & 28 others. The judgement went in Rathi’s favour on July 3, 2010, which directed Gavai & others to return land’s possession. Thereafter, an application was filed for executing court’s orders while seeking directives to police authorities to provide protection to facilitate sowing operations on disputed land, as it was in petitioners’ possession, which they challenged in High Court.

The judges pointed out that when a court passes a decree against judgment debtor to vacate land & hand over possession to the applicant, the former is obliged under the law to obey it. “S/he should voluntarily hand over the possession within stipulated period without requiring a decree holder to file execution proceedings. Ordinarily, a judgment debtor shouldn't create a situation wherein an applicant would be required or compelled to once again knock at court’s doors for enforcing a decree, else it will only be reduced to a paper having no meaning,” they observed.

The judges added that the petitioners enjoyed the possession of disputed land for about a decade and that even today, they are desirous of perpetuating their illegal possession. They further contended that a judgment debtor must respect the law by showing deliberate and voluntary compliance. If they refuse & seek refuge in some technicality of law, they do not deserve any help from High Court exercising its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, 1949


Author: Dyuti Pandya 

Share this article:

User Avatar

Leave a feedback about this

Trending News Updates
Jain Community dresses up as Muslims to buy 124 Goats , saves them from Bakrid slaughter

Jain community in Delhi raises Rs 15 lakh, dresses as Muslims to buy and rescue 124 goats from Bakrid slaughter, garnering praise and attention.

18 June, 2024 01:19 PM
Trending Judiciary
Act fairly, admit if any mistake conducted in NEET UG, SC tells NTA

SC tells NTA to act fairly, admit mistakes in NEET UG. The court stresses thorough investigation and timely action to ensure students’ confidence.

18 June, 2024 05:26 PM


Trending CelebStreet
Karan Johar moves Bombay High Court against film ‘Shaadi Ke Director Karan Aur Johar’

Karan Johar files a lawsuit in Bombay High Court against the film “Shaadi Ke Director Karan Aur Johar,” seeking to prevent the use of his name in the title.

13 June, 2024 12:01 AM
Trending Judiciary
Conspired to transform India into an Islamic country by 2047: Bombay HC denies bail to 3 Islamists PFI members [Read Order]

Bombay High Court denies bail to three PFI members accused of plotting to turn India into an Islamic state by 2047, citing strong evidence and risk of tampering.

13 June, 2024 12:37 AM
Trending Judiciary
Delhi HC refuses to stay NEET-UG admissions counselling, over paper leak allegations

Delhi High Court refuses to stay NEET-UG 2024 counselling amidst allegations of irregularities.

13 June, 2024 12:48 PM
Trending Judiciary
Centre to hold re-test for 1563 candidates awarded grace marks in NEET UG, 2024 [Read Order]

Centre to hold re-test for 1563 candidates awarded grace marks in NEET UG 2024. Date for re-test to be notified on June 13, results by June 30.

13 June, 2024 01:39 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email