38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, September 09, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Bombay HC Disposes PILs demanding Facilities for prisoners lodged in various corrections homes during COVID-19 [READ JUDGEMENT]

By Prachi Misra.      04 July, 2020 01:56 PM      0 Comments
BombayHC COVID19

On 2nd July 2020, the Bombay High Court accepted and disposed of various PILs stating concern with respect to providing proper facilities to prisoners lodged in various corrections homes during the times of Pandemic COVID19. 

These suggestions were given by various petitioners and have been accepted by the state. A Division bench comprising of Justice Dipankar Dutta and Justice MS Karnik was informed by the Advocate General of Maharashtra with respect to the acceptance of the suggestion to conduct a random test of prisoners in jail. The court ordered the working authorities of prison to implement such measures.

There were several important suggestions put by petitioners before the court through Senior Advocate Mihir Desai along with Advocate Isha Khandelwal.

Some of the suggestions accepted by the state are as follows: -

  1. The staff engaged with the correctional homes will be tested in the same manner as that of SOP.
  2. The staff member engaged in such correctional homes shall be posted in the present place of posting and they will not be rotated.
  3. The guidelines provided by the State Government, Central Government should be complied with.
  4. An email-id for taking an appointment for meeting their prison-clients shall be notified soon on the website of the Prison Authorities.
  5. A session will be conducted by Prison Authorities to educate the prisoners with respect to the prevention of hygiene due to coronavirus disease.
  6. The women prisoners will be provided with utmost hygiene facilities. Will be given free sanitary napkins and a proper way of disposal of such napkins will be ensured by the authorities.
  7. A telephone facility will be given to all the prisoners as that is done in regular correctional homes.
  8. The prison authorities will inform their family members with respect to their transfer of the prisoners to temporary jails, quarantine centers, or COVID centers.

Moreover, Desai suggested that High-Risk Prisoners shall be treated as per proper Standard Operating Procedure issued by the National Centre Disease Control for contact tracing of COVID cases. According to him, the state has not placed any record that how these High-Risk Prisoners will be indicated. However, AG Kumbhakoni submitted that various guidelines will be given by ICMR, Government of India as also the State Government will be complied with. 

The Court observed that: -

It is not possible for us to accept the submission of Shri Desai that the definition of High-Risk Prisoners should be as per SOP issued by National Centre Disease Control (NCDC) for contact tracing COVID-19 cases.

We cannot substitute our opinion for that of the experts in the field and direct the State Government to accept the definition of High-Risk Prisoners as per the SOP issued by NCDC. Once the learned Advocate General has made a statement that the state will follow the guidelines issued by ICMR, the Central Government, the State Government, and its authorities in the case of High-Risk Prisoners, then it is not possible for us to substitute our opinion in matters of state which are in the realm of policy based on the opinion of the experts.

AG Kumbhakoni told the court that it is not possible to immediately provide the above facilities due to such unforeseen situations and the challenges faced by the Government, but the resources given will be evenly distributed to all the concerned societies. 

Justice Karnik said-

We do not find this submission of Shri Kumbhakoni unreasonable. In any case, we are satisfied with the measures taken by the State Government for the present. The state has accepted most of the suggestions of the petitioners during the course of this hearing. We, therefore, do not propose to issue any directions on this submission of Shri Desai. We may, however, hasten to add that whenever an inmate shows signs of any physical discomfort or complaints of such discomfort like cough, cold, etc. Such an inmate should be immediately tested.

Finally, the court said that it was State High-Power Committee constituted following the directions of SC to all the states and UNs to determine the class of prisoners and release then on temporary bail in the wake of Covid-19 as the jails are overcrowded. 

The Court remarked-

The petitioners contend that the categorization by the HPC affects their rights. As noted earlier, the HPC has been constituted for a specific purpose by the Apex Court for decongesting the prisons for a specific period in view of the outbreak of the present pandemic and thus it is for the HPC to determine the categories in the light of the observation of the Supreme Court. We are afraid that the case put forth by the petitioners is not in the nature of transgressing any constitutional right or statutory prescription.

It further directed that the state shall fully comply with the directions issued in the interim orders passed in the matter and noted that the suggestions made by the petitioners have been accepted by the state and their compliance be ensured by the Advocate General on their behalf. The court disposed of the PILs and dismissed one PIL filed by the Advocates Devmani Shukla and Nikita Abhyankar

 

[READ JUDGEMENT] 



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

sc-notice-to-ed-on-plea-by-journalist-in-money-laundering-case
Trending Judiciary
SC notice to ED on plea by journalist in money laundering case

SC issues notice to Gujarat govt & ED on plea of ex-‘The Hindu’ journalist Mahesh Langa seeking bail in money laundering case linked to alleged fraud.

08 September, 2025 02:37 PM
absence-of-cheque-bank-transfer-or-receipt-wont-always-negate-cash-transaction-sc
Trending Judiciary
Absence of cheque, bank transfer or receipt won't always negate cash transaction: SC [Read Order]

Absence of cheque, transfer or receipt doesn’t negate cash deal; promissory note & oral statement can establish enforceable debt: SC

08 September, 2025 02:43 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-rejects-plea-upholds-3500-aibe-exam-fee-by-bci-as-not-unconstitutional
Trending Judiciary
SC Rejects Plea, Upholds ₹3,500 AIBE Exam Fee by BCI as Not Unconstitutional

SC dismisses plea against Rs 3,500 AIBE fee, upholding Bar Council of India’s right to charge for exam expenses, ruling fee not unconstitutional.

03 September, 2025 11:16 AM
hc-dismisses-plea-for-bail-by-umar-khalid-sharjeel-imam-in-case-of-conspiracy-to-delhi-riots
Trending Judiciary
HC dismisses plea for bail by Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam in case of conspiracy to Delhi riots [Read Judgment]

Delhi HC dismisses bail pleas of Umar Khalid, Sharjeel Imam in 2020 riots conspiracy case, citing strong evidence and grave role in instigating violence.

03 September, 2025 12:20 PM
elgar-parishad-case-sc-defers-bail-plea-of-accused-lawyer-surendra-gadling-to-sep-17
Trending Judiciary
Elgar Parishad Case: SC Defers Bail Plea of Accused Lawyer Surendra Gadling to Sep 17

SC defers Surendra Gadling’s bail plea in Elgar Parishad case to Sep 17; advocate jailed over 6 years under UAPA charges without trial.

03 September, 2025 06:31 PM
unacceptable-sc-says-everyone-cant-come-to-it-just-due-to-physical-proximity
Trending Judiciary
'Unacceptable,' SC says everyone can't come to it just due to physical proximity

SC: Not acceptable to approach top court just due to proximity; raps Sukesh Chandrashekar’s wife Leena Paulose over bail plea hearing.

03 September, 2025 08:03 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email