38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, October 31, 2024
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Case Based on Circumstantial Evidence is a Factor in Favor of the Accused: SC

By Parul Singhal      13 October, 2020 04:58 PM      0 Comments
Circumstantial Evidence

Supreme Court reinstated in Anwar Ali case, that if the motive of the accused is not established in a case that is to be assessed on the parameter of circumstantial evidence, then the same is taken in the favor of the accused. 

In the present case, the accusers were accused of murder. The charges against the accused were confirmed by the Himachal Pradesh High Court. Conversely, the appeal is filed before the Supreme Court by the accused to be non-guilty and thus prayed to release the charge of murder framed upon them. 

The contention raised in the appeal by the accused was that since the prosecution has failed to establish the motive for the above-stated charge, thus the accused is to be acquitted on the lack of clear motive. 

It was further contended that the recovery of the jeep from Chandigarh and recovery of photographs and a mobile phone from the jeep create a cloud of suspicion as there is no clue or proper information with respect to the recoveries or no direct link to strengthen the case and charged against the accused. The investigating officer in the present case also did not follow the procedure as is required to be followed under Section 166 (3& 4) and Section 100(4) Cr.P.C. 

The offences charged against the accused are Section 302 r/w 34, 392, 201, and 420 IPC. 

The Court in this case held that even though it is a set proposition of law that solely in the absence of motive one cannot set aside the entire case, as settled in Suresh Chandra Bahri v. State of Bihar 1995. In the present case, it was explicitly held that if the motive of the accused is established, it makes a direct link with the circumstantial evidence but the absence of the same cannot be a ground to dismiss the case entirely. 

Thus the bench while allowing the appeal held that the findings made by the High Court and the Judgment this pronounced by the High Court of reversal of the acquittal order pronounced by the trial court is not justified as the trial court took into consideration all the valid circumstantial evidence or record and after proper application of mind the charges were dropped. 

The Honble Supreme Court states that in the present case the failure of the establishment of a vivid motive of the accused demands their acquittal. 



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS


TOP STORIES

sc-tells-ncp-led-by-ajit-pawar-to-declare-use-of-clock-symbol-sub-judice
Trending Judiciary
SC tells NCP led by Ajit Pawar to declare use of Clock symbol sub judice

SC directs Ajit Pawar-led NCP to declare ‘Clock’ symbol use as sub judice in all election materials, pending final court ruling on its rightful ownership.

25 October, 2024 11:12 AM
justice-sanjiv-khanna-to-take-oath-as-chief-justice-of-india-on-nov-11-2024
Trending Legal Insiders
Justice Sanjiv Khanna to take oath as Chief Justice of India on Nov 11, 2024 [Read Notification]

Justice Sanjiv Khanna appointed as the 51st Chief Justice of India, succeeding CJI Chandrachud, with a tenure starting on November 11, 2024.

25 October, 2024 11:17 AM
sc-grants-bail-to-businessman-in-delhi-liquor-policy-scam-case
Trending Judiciary
SC grants bail to businessman in Delhi liquor policy scam case

Supreme Court grants bail to businessman Amandeep Singh Dhall in Delhi liquor policy scam case, noting the lengthy trial process with over 300 witnesses.

25 October, 2024 04:11 PM
sc-dismisses-ex-jharkhand-cms-plea-for-suspension-of-conviction-to-allow-him-contest-assembly-polls
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses ex Jharkhand CM's plea for suspension of conviction to allow him contest Assembly polls

The Supreme Court rejects ex-Jharkhand CM Madhu Koda’s plea to stay his conviction, barring him from contesting the upcoming Assembly elections.

25 October, 2024 05:10 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email