38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, April 19, 2024
Judiciary

MV Act: Court Can Grant Compensation Of Any Amount In Excess To What Has Been Claimed: SC [Read Order]

By LawStreet News Network      25 November, 2019 11:11 AM      0 Comments

The Supreme Court on November 13, 2019, in the case of Jabbar v. The Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, has observed that the court under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, can grant compensation of any amount in excess to that which has been claimed.

A Division Bench comprising of Justices Ashok Bhushan and M.R. Shah was hearing an appeal filed against the judgment and order passed by the High Court wherein it had enhanced the compensation granted to the appellant from Rs.1.50 lac to Rs.2.50 lac.

The appellant was a fruit seller whose right hand was amputated after the accident. In the claim petition, he has claimed that he is entitled for compensation of Rs.9,05,000/- from the respondents. However, due to financial crisis, he was unable to pay court fees on the said amount and thus restricted his claim to the tune of Rs.3,00,000/-. The Tribunal accepted the case setup by the appellant and allowed the claim to Rs.1.50 lacs. 

On appeal, the High Court enhanced the compensation granted to the appellant from Rs.1.50 lac to Rs.2.50 lac. Being unsatisfied with the amount of compensation, the appellant moved the Supreme Court. 

The learned counsel for the appellant submitted before the Supreme Court that the High Court having noticed that the appellant was carrying business of fruits on a hand-cart, the amputation of right hand has made the business of the appellant non-functional. In this view, the amount of Rs.2.5 lacs awarded by the High Court is neither fair nor a just compensation.

Learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submitted that the appellant having confined his claim to Rs.3 lacs before the High Court cannot be allowed to contend that he is entitled for any higher compensation.

After hearing both the parties, the court took into consideration the injury caused to the appellant which resulted into permanent disability substantially affecting his business and opined that the award of Rs.2.5 Lakhs cannot be held to be a just and reasonable compensation.

This Court in large number of cases has laid down that it is permissible to grant compensation of any amount in excess to that one which has been claimed. This Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution has awarded just and reasonable compensation,” the court said. 

It referred to a judgment in Ramla v. National Insurance Company Limited [(2019) 2 SCC 192] wherein the apex court had observed that “There is no restriction that the Court cannot award compensation exceeding the claimed amount, since the function of the Tribunal or Court under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is to award "just compensation". The Motor Vehicles Act is beneficial and welfare legislation. A "just compensation" is one which is reasonable on the basis of evidence produced on record. It cannot be said to have become time barred. Further, there is no need for a new cause of action to claim an enhanced amount. The Courts are duty bound to award just compensation."

Placing reliance on the above judgment and also noting that in the claim petition the appellant had expressly stated that if it is entitled to get more than Rs.3 Lakhs, the claimant is ready to deposit deficient court fee, the court allowed the appeal and granted an amount of Rs.5 lacs as compensation to the appellant.

[Read Order]



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

pil-filed-by-ashwini-kumar-upadhyay-in-sc-for-yr-bachelor-of-law-degree-after-class
Trending Judiciary
PIL filed by Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay in SC for 3-yr Bachelor of Law degree after Class XII

PIL by Ashwini Kumar in SC seeks to shorten law degree to 3 years post-Class XII, citing current 5-year span as irrational.

18 April, 2024 11:21 AM
we-all-know-what-happened-when-there-were-ballot-papers-sc-on-return-of-ballot-papers-or-100-vvpats-count
Trending Judiciary
'We all know what happened when there were ballot papers,' SC on return of ballot papers or 100% VVPATs count

SC questions EVM process, debates ballot paper return and 100% VVPAT count verification, citing past issues.

18 April, 2024 01:53 PM

TOP STORIES

lsj-exclusive-interview-how-bjp-govt-will-free-chhattisgarh-from-naxal-menace
Trending Interview
LSJ Exclusive Interview: How BJP govt will free Chhattisgarh from “Naxal menace”? [Watch Video]

What is Chhattisgarh govt's plan for solving the Maoist/Naxalite problem in the state? Will there be a surgical strike against the Naxals or solution will be found via diplomatic channels? Read the Exclusive Interview with the Deputy Chief Minister Vijay Sharma.

13 April, 2024 12:33 PM
sc-rejects-review-of-order-to-pay-rs-154-cr-compensation-to-ex-air-force-staff-for-transfusion-of-hiv-infected-blood
Trending Judiciary
SC rejects review of order to pay Rs 1.54 Cr compensation to ex Air Force staff for transfusion of HIV infected blood [Read Order]

SC denies review of Rs 1.54 Cr HIV compensation order to ex-Air Force staff for medical negligence.

13 April, 2024 03:13 PM
cji-cautions-against-overlooking-ethical-legal-consideration-on-use-of-ai-in-court-adjudication
Trending Legal Insiders
CJI cautions against overlooking ethical legal consideration on use of AI in court adjudication

CJI D Y Chandrachud warns about ethical, legal challenges in AI use in courts, stressing need for thorough review.

13 April, 2024 07:08 PM
need-to-safeguard-judiciary-from-unwarranted-pressures-21-ex-judges-write-letter-to-cji
Trending Legal Insiders
Need to safeguard judiciary from unwarranted pressures: 21 ex-judges write letter to CJI

21 ex-judges write to CJI Chandrachud urging protection of judiciary from pressures undermining its integrity and autonomy.

15 April, 2024 12:17 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email