38.6c New Delhi, India, Monday, July 15, 2024

When Conviction By Trial Court Was Not For Dowry Demand U/S 498A IPC, HC Can’t Convict Accused For It Without Appreciating Evidence On Record: SC

By LawStreet News Network      19 July, 2019 12:00 AM      0 Comments
When Conviction By Trial Court Was Not For Dowry Demand U/S 498A IPC, HC Can’t Convict Accused For It Without Appreciating Evidence On Record: SC

The Supreme Court on July 18, 2019, in the case of Wasim v. State NCT of Delhi has observed that when the Trial Court conviction under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, was not for demand for dowry, the High Court could not convict the accused under the same for demand of dowry without a detailed discussion of the evidence on record.

In this case, the Trial Court convicted the accused under Section 306 and 498A of IPC. Conviction under Section 498A was not for demand of dowry, but on account of finding that the accused caused mental cruelty by having an extra marital relation and the threats held out by him to the deceased that he would leave her and marry the other woman.

In appeal before the High Court, it acquitted the accused under Section 306 IPC by reaching a conclusion on the basis of evidence that the charge of abetment of suicide was not proved. However, it convicted him under Section 498A finding that though there was no demand of dowry soon before the death, the prosecution proved dowry demand immediately after the marriage.

When the matter came before the Supreme Court, the Bench comprising Justice L. Nageswara Rao and Justice Hemant Gupta observed that there is no discussion of the evidence pertaining to demand of dowry and the findings recorded by the Trial Court regarding the demand of dowry.

Elucidating the meaning of 'cruelty' dealt with in the Explanation to Section 498A IPC, the Bench said: “Conviction under Section 498A IPC is for subjecting a woman to cruelty. Cruelty is explained as any wilful conduct which is likely to drive a woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health. Harassment of a woman by unlawful demand of dowry also partakes the character of 'Cruelty'. It is clear from a plain reading of Section 498A that conviction for an offence under Section 498A IPC can be for wilful conduct which is likely to drive a woman to commit suicide OR for dowry demand.”

Further, explaining Section 306 IPC, the court said: “Section 306 IPC provides for punishment with imprisonment that may extend to ten years. There should be clear mens rea to commit the offence for conviction under Section 306 IPC. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and this act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he/she committed suicide.”

The court observed that any wilful conduct which is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide is sufficient for conviction under Section 498A IPC. But In this case, the Bench observed, that the High Court recorded a categorical finding that neither mental nor physical cruelty on the part of the accused was proved.

Setting aside the High Court judgment, the Bench observed: “The High Court ought not to have convicted the Appellant under Section 498A for demand of dowry without a detailed discussion of the evidence on record, especially when the Trial Court found that there is no material on record to show that there was any demand of dowry. The High Court did not refer to such findings of the Trial Court and record reasons for its disapproval.”

Read the judgment.

Share this article:

User Avatar

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
Need to develop law, legal education in vernacular languages: CJI [Read Speech]

CJI D.Y. Chandrachud emphasizes the need for developing law and legal education in vernacular languages to make legal systems accessible to all citizens.

15 July, 2024 09:30 AM
Trending Judiciary
CIC has powers to set up benches: SC [Read Judgement]

The Supreme Court affirms CIC's authority to set up benches, emphasizing its autonomy for efficient case management under the RTI Act, overturning the 2010 Delhi HC order.

15 July, 2024 09:42 AM


Trending Crime, Police And Law
Journalist Soumya Vishwanathan murder case: SC issues notice to 4 convicts on appeal by Delhi police

SC issues notice to 4 convicts in Soumya Vishwanathan murder case on Delhi police's appeal against their bail. Convicts had served over 14 years.

09 July, 2024 09:49 AM
Trending Judiciary
Why Indian High Courts still have old names despite change in city name ? [Watch Video]

Know the reasons why Indian High Courts, like Bombay HC, Madras HC, and Calcutta HC, Allahabad HC still retain their old names despite the cities’ name changes. LawStreet Journal delves into the historical and legal context. Watch report !

09 July, 2024 09:56 AM
Trending International
What is Keir Starmer’s stance on Kashmir issue ? [Watch Video]

Under Keir Starmer, the UK's Labour Party shifts its stance on Article 370, focusing on strategic ties with India, moving from past criticisms to cooperation.

09 July, 2024 10:04 AM
Trending Judiciary
ED moves SC against Jharkhand HC order of bail to CM Hemant Soren

ED moves SC against Jharkhand HC's bail order for CM Hemant Soren in a money laundering case linked to an alleged land scam.

09 July, 2024 12:14 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email