38.6c New Delhi, India, Monday, July 15, 2024
Judiciary

In Arbitration, parties must give a resounding ‘Yes’: Calcutta High Court

By Rintu Mariam Biju      24 January, 2024 04:43 PM      0 Comments
In Arbitration, parties must give a resounding ‘Yes’: Calcutta High Court

Cuttack: In arbitration, there can’t be any confusion, parties must be certain and give a resounding ‘green signal’. This is what the Calcutta High Court ruled recently. 
“In essence, there cannot be any ifs and buts or an undecided mumble; the parties must give a resounding “Yes” to arbitration. For a movement analogy; the arbitration agreement is not about a hesitant 1 step ahead – 2 steps backward / back-tracking but a confident 1–way stride forward to arbitration”, Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya clarified. 

The Court was considering a plea that sought the appointment of an arbitrator under Section 11 of The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The dispute occurred after the respondent, Eastern Coalfields Limited (ECL), filed an e-tender notice for a project. The petitioner claimed that Clause 13 of the e-tender notice's General Terms and Conditions served as the arbitration clause.

The counsel for the petitioner submitted that the disputes had arisen between the parties pursuant to the petitioner being engaged as the contractor for the work described in the e-tender notice. The dispute allegedly revolves around the parties disagreeing to changes made to the price component of the contract. 

The counsel appearing for the respondent argued on the point of maintainability of the present application on the ground that there is no arbitration agreement between the parties.

The point for consideration, according to the court was, whether the part of the clause containing the word “may” can be construed to be an arbitration agreement as contemplated under section 7 of the 1996 Act.

Section 7 underscored the unequivocal intent of the parties to go to arbitration by giving shape and form to the arbitration agreement and exit options to the parties under sub-sections (4) and (5) of section 7, the court highlighted. 

“Presence of the word “may” in the arbitration clause in the matter at hand is required to be tested against mindset of the parties to the agreement. Parties consenting to arbitration including to the mode and mechanism of the procedure forms the mainstay of the 1996 Act.”

The Court referred to Supreme Court judgement in Jagdish Chander vs. Ramesh Chander to understand the intention of parties to arbitrate. “The will to arbitrate must clearly be articulated in the arbitration clause. There is no room for any doubt or second-guessing. Parties must be clear in their minds that they wish to subject themselves to arbitration as the chosen mechanism of dispute resolution and ensure that the intention is expressed in writing in the form of the arbitration agreement”. 

Further, them court said that clarity of intention should be spelt out in clear-cut words. 

“The clarity of intention should hence be expressed through clear-cut words. Therefore, words such as “the parties wish …..”, or “the parties will consider …..”, or “the parties will thereafter decide ….” and “the parties may …..” will be counter-productive to the unequivocality of the intention to arbitrate. The above instances are not exhaustive and may include other words which VERDICTUM.IN 6 give a sense of indecision, lack of purpose, prevarification or even saving the option for arbitration to a later date or as a last resort.”

The Court also noted previous cases, such as Food Corporation of India v. National Collateral Management Services Limited and Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. v. IVRCL AMR Joint Venture, where the presence of similar terms like "may" led to the conclusion that there was no clear intention to enter into an arbitration agreement. The Court dismissed the petitioner's application on the grounds of maintainability, stating that Clause 13 does not constitute or contain a valid arbitration agreement. The Court emphasized the need for clarity in dispute resolution clauses and urged parties to be cautious about vague or uncertain terms in such agreements.



Share this article:

About:

Rintu Mariam Biju graduated from the National University of Advanced Legal Studies, Kochi after comp...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Birbhum Massacre | Calcutta High Court Orders CBI Probe, SIT Asked To Stop Investigation Birbhum Massacre | Calcutta High Court Orders CBI Probe, SIT Asked To Stop Investigation

It was also questioned by the petitioners that the inclusion of Gyanwant Singh in the State's Special Investigation Team (SIT) by alleging that Singh had been served notice by the Enforcement Directorate in 2021 regarding a coal smuggling case. It had also been alleged that no statements of witnesses have been recorded yet.

Birbhum Violence: CBI Informs Calcutta High Court That Chargesheet Is Likely To Be Filed Within 2 Weeks Birbhum Violence: CBI Informs Calcutta High Court That Chargesheet Is Likely To Be Filed Within 2 Weeks

Last month, the Court dismissed a petition seeking cancellation of bail granted to two minor accused persons by the Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice Board, Birbhum at Suri in the case, stating that the aggrieved parties have the right to file a revision petition with the High Court under Section 102 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 (2015 Act), and that such a plea requesting cancellation of bail cannot be entertained.

Calcutta High Court judge directs Supreme Court's Secy Gen to produce transcripts of his interview [Read Order] Calcutta High Court judge directs Supreme Court's Secy Gen to produce transcripts of his interview [Read Order]

A Calcutta High Court judge has directed the Secretary General of the Supreme Court to produce transcripts of his interview to a TV Channel furnished before the top court. The order was given in connection with the recruitment scam in government schools in West Bengal.

Calcutta High Court to Examine Plea for Free and Fair Panchayat Polls in West Bengal [Read Petition] Calcutta High Court to Examine Plea for Free and Fair Panchayat Polls in West Bengal [Read Petition]

The Calcutta High Court will examine pleas for fair and free panchayat elections in West Bengal, including the deployment of central police forces and an extended time period for filing nomination papers. Learn about the concerns raised by Congress and BJP leaders, the court's stance, and the importance of ensuring a transparent electoral process.

TRENDING NEWS


TOP STORIES

journalist-soumya-vishwanathan-murder-case-sc-issues-notice-to-4-convicts-on-appeal-by-delhi-police
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Journalist Soumya Vishwanathan murder case: SC issues notice to 4 convicts on appeal by Delhi police

SC issues notice to 4 convicts in Soumya Vishwanathan murder case on Delhi police's appeal against their bail. Convicts had served over 14 years.

09 July, 2024 09:49 AM
why-indian-high-courts-still-have-old-names-despite-change-in-city-name
Trending Judiciary
Why Indian High Courts still have old names despite change in city name ? [Watch Video]

Know the reasons why Indian High Courts, like Bombay HC, Madras HC, and Calcutta HC, Allahabad HC still retain their old names despite the cities’ name changes. LawStreet Journal delves into the historical and legal context. Watch report !

09 July, 2024 09:56 AM
what-is-keir-starmer-stance-on-kashmir-issue
Trending International
What is Keir Starmer’s stance on Kashmir issue ? [Watch Video]

Under Keir Starmer, the UK's Labour Party shifts its stance on Article 370, focusing on strategic ties with India, moving from past criticisms to cooperation.

09 July, 2024 10:04 AM
ed-moves-sc-against-jharkhand-hc-order-of-bail-to-cm-hemant-soren
Trending Judiciary
ED moves SC against Jharkhand HC order of bail to CM Hemant Soren

ED moves SC against Jharkhand HC's bail order for CM Hemant Soren in a money laundering case linked to an alleged land scam.

09 July, 2024 12:14 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email