38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, July 25, 2024
Judiciary

Judge Loya's death: Supreme Court dismisses pleas for independent investigation

By LawStreet News Network      19 April, 2018 01:10 AM      0 Comments

The Supreme Court of India today has dismissed the petitions filed seeking an independent investigation into the death of Judge Loya. The judgment was adjudicated by a three-Judge bench comprising of Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, Justice AM Khanwilkar, and Justice DY Chandrachud, in a batch of PILs demanding an independent probe into the death of CBI special judge B. H. Loya.

Justice Chandrachud, while pronouncing the judgment said,

An aura of good faith was sought to be created by the petitioners, but as submissions progressed, it fell apart.

The Bench has observed that the Senior Counsel Dushyant Dave has transversed to the extent of insinuating even judges not associated to the present petitions, being members of the Bombay High Court Administrative Committee as well as Justices Chandrachud and Khanwilkar. The Bench also held that the business and political battles may not be fought in courts by abusing the process of the PIL and that the petitions lack merit.

Judge Loya passed away on December 1, 2014, during the pendency of the politically sensitive Sohrabuddin case. He was the second judge to hear this case, despite the 2012 Supreme Court directive that required the case to be heard by a single judicial officer from beginning to end.

Senior Counsel Dushyant Dave, Indira Jaising and V. Giri had appeared on behalf of the Bombay Lawyers Association, Former chief of the navy Admiral L. Ramdas, an intervenor, and Activist Tehseen Poonawalla respectively.

During the hearings, Dave had urged the Supreme Court to disallow Harish Salve from representing the State of Maharashtra in the case, claiming this would be a serious conflict of interest since Salve had represented Amit Shah in the Sohrabuddin case.

Dave had also alleged conflict of interest on the part of Senior Counsel Pallav Shishodia representing Bandhuraj Lone, pointing out that Shishodia too was a Counsel engaged by Amit Shah in 2011.

Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi, on the other hand, had submitted that these petitions were motivated and ill-founded. He had relied on the statements made by four judges who had claimed to be present with Judge Loya at the time of his death.



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

investor-vishvanidhi-dalmia-accused-of-collusion-in-nsel-scam-maharashtra-govt-affidavit-reveals
Trending Judiciary
Investor Vishvanidhi Dalmia accused of collusion in NSEL Scam, Maharashtra Govt Affidavit reveals [Read Affidavit]

Investor Vishvanidhi Dalmia accused of colluding with NSEL's prime accused Jignesh Shah, as revealed in Maharashtra Government's affidavit filed in Bombay High Court.

24 July, 2024 09:34 AM
sc-declines-re-test-of-neet-ug-2024
Trending Judiciary
SC declines re-test of NEET UG, 2024

SC declines re-test for NEET UG 2024 due to insufficient evidence of systemic paper leak, affecting only 155 students and preserving the sanctity of the exam.

24 July, 2024 10:00 AM

TOP STORIES

supreme-court-allows-compounding-of-offence-in-cheque-dishonour-case
Trending Judiciary
SUPREME COURT ALLOWS COMPOUNDING OF OFFENCE IN CHEQUE DISHONOUR CASE [Read Judgement]

Supreme Court allows compounding of offence in cheque dishonour case, emphasizing the priority of compensatory aspects over punitive in settlements.

19 July, 2024 09:12 AM
allahabad-hc-directs-passport-authority-to-decide-on-application-without-prior-court-permission-in-pending-criminal-cases
Trending Judiciary
Allahabad HC directs Passport Authority to decide on application without prior court permission in pending criminal cases [Read Order]

Allahabad HC directs Passport Authority to decide applications without prior court permission for individuals with pending criminal cases within a specified timeframe.

19 July, 2024 10:03 AM
restrictions-in-law-not-to-prevent-constitutional-court-from-granting-bail-if-right-to-speedy-trial-infringed-sc
Trending Judiciary
Restrictions in law not to prevent constitutional court from granting bail if right to speedy trial infringed: SC [Read Judgement]

SC affirms constitutional courts can grant bail despite restrictive laws if the right to a speedy trial under Article 21 is infringed.

19 July, 2024 10:17 AM
sexual-harrasment-charges-against-wb-governor-sc-to-examine-constitutional-immunity
Trending Judiciary
Sexual harrasment charges against WB Governor: SC to examine constitutional immunity

The Supreme Court will examine a plea to investigate sexual harassment allegations against West Bengal Governor C V Ananda Bose, challenging his constitutional immunity.

19 July, 2024 01:46 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email