38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, June 20, 2024
Judiciary

Karnataka HC Refuses Petition to Move Covid19 Testing Laboratory In Residential Neighborhood

By Manthan Pandit      22 July, 2020 11:28 AM      1 Comments
KarnatakaHC Covid19 Testing Laboratory

On Monday, 20th July 2020, the Karnataka High Court declined to entertain a public interest litigation filed by two citizens seeking guidance from the authorities to move or close a nearby COVID-19 research facility.

A division bench of Chief Justice Abhay Oka and Justice M Nagaprasanna said "The petitioner counsel is unable to point out any statutory provisions which impose an embargo on setting up a laboratory in residential society for collecting swab samples of covid19. In absence of any such provision, we cannot direct the state govt to cancel permission, if any, granted to Mediclu Diagnostics and Speciality Centre.

Advocate Bharat Kumar S, appearing for the petitioners S GANGAPPA (77) and V.SHIVA MURTHY (35) relying on photographs annexed to the petition had argued that "So many patients standing in the queue outside the lab to undergo the test pose a threat to the people residing in the area. The petitioners have to pass through the same road on which the laboratory is situated. Moreover, the staff taking the swab test is also seen in the photographs not wearing PPE Kits. Even after approaching the local corporator of the area since no action has been taken the petitioners have moved the court."

The bench dismissed the petition primarily on the grounds that a writ of mandamus cannot be given to a private company because it is not a state agency or instrumentality. However, the bench made the following comments during the hearing.

"Even assuming that everybody standing in the queue is covid19, can the infection spread because people are standing in the queue. By that logic, we will have to close down the court, because 13 members have tested positive for Covid19. One Staff member in the govt advocates office has tested positive, does that mean the government advocates cannot appear in any matter? Because people stand outside the center (laboratory) will COVID-19 spread?

As regards the arguments that petitioners have to pass by the laboratory the bench observed "We will give you an example. Five members of the writ scrutiny branch were tested positive, can other members say we will not pass through the same passage from where these people have passed. There are 2,000 cases testing positive every day, can you say this? This is all ridiculous."

The bench while concluding said "Grievance of petitioners is that respondent 4 (laboratory) is not taking any precautions which may result in the spread of covid19. If that is so, the petitioner can make representation to the district health officer and BBMP. If substance is found in the grievance the respondents can issue necessary instruction to the respondent 4."



Share this article:



John Doe
gggclaboratories Jan 15, 2021

It is a great blog post.I am always read your blog helpful and informative tips. I like it thanks for sharing this information with us

Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

mk-stalin-urges-amit-shah-to-withdraw-new-criminal-laws
Trending Executive
MK Stalin Urges Amit Shah to Withdraw New Criminal Laws

Tamil Nadu CM Stalin urges Home Minister Amit Shah to withdraw new criminal laws, citing lack of consultation and fundamental errors in the enactments.

19 June, 2024 11:16 AM
calcutta-hc-mandates-reservation-for-transgenders-in-west-bengal-public-employment
Trending Judiciary
Calcutta HC mandates 1% reservation for transgenders in West Bengal Public Employment [Read Order]

Calcutta HC directs 1% reservation for transgenders in West Bengal public employment, ensuring equal opportunities and implementing Supreme Court’s 2014 mandate.

19 June, 2024 11:33 AM

TOP STORIES

sc-notice-to-petitioners-on-ntas-plea-to-transfer-petitions-on-neet-ug
Trending Judiciary
SC notice to petitioners on NTA's plea to transfer petitions on NEET UG

SC issues notice on NTA’s plea to transfer NEET UG petitions from various High Courts to apex court. Court to review alleged irregularities on July 8.

14 June, 2024 12:44 PM
hyundai-motor-india-set-to-file-ipo-papers-aiming-for-historic-billion-share-sale
Trending Business
Hyundai Motor India Set to File IPO Papers, Aiming for Historic $3 Billion Share Sale

Hyundai Motor India to file for IPO, aiming to raise $2.5-$3 billion in what could be India’s largest share sale, enhancing its market value and competitive edge.

14 June, 2024 01:55 PM
madras-hc-sentences-contemnor-to-6-months-jail-for-scandalous-allegations-against-judges
Trending Judiciary
Madras HC sentences Contemnor to 6 months jail for scandalous allegations against Judges [Read Order]

Madras High Court sentenced PU Venkatesan to 6 months in prison for making scandalous allegations against judges, emphasizing the need to uphold judicial dignity.

14 June, 2024 03:40 PM
release-of-aamir-khans-sons-debut-film-maharaj-stayed-by-gujarat-hc-on-plea-by-shri-krishna-devotees
Trending Business
Release of Aamir Khan's son's debut film 'Maharaj' stayed by Gujarat HC on plea by Shri Krishna devotees

Gujarat HC stays release of Aamir Khan’s son Junaid Khan’s debut film ‘Maharaj’ till June 18 on plea by Shri Krishna devotees of the Pushtimarg sect.

14 June, 2024 05:51 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email