38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, April 01, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Mere Registration of FIR Is Not Sufficient To Pass A Detention Order: Gujarat High Court

By ANUSHKA BHATNAGAR      04 April, 2022 06:50 PM      0 Comments
Mere Registration Of FIR Is Not Sufficient To Pass A Detention Order

Gujarat High Court has noted that offences alleged in the First Information Report (FIR) have no bearing on public order. 

BACKGROUND 

The single-judge bench of Justice A. P. Thaker observed that detention order under Section 3 (2) of the Prevention of Illicit Trafficking in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 cannot be passed on mere instance of an FIR.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PETITIONER: 

Learned Counsel for the petitioner-detenu vehemently argued that the entire exercise undertaken by the detaining authority is merit less and since there is no strict compliance with the provisions of the act in question, the detention order itself is illegal ab initio.

He relied on catena of decisions including Banka Sneha Sheela Vs. State of Telangana, 2021 Latest Caselaw 301 SC.

CONTENTIONS OF THE ADDITIONAL GOVERNMENT PLEADER: 

The AGP submitted that the offence against the detenu is under the NDPS Act and considering the effect of the Narcotic Drugs, the authority has properly passed the impugned order and which deserves to be upheld by this Court.

OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT: 

The Court at the outset recalled Section 3 of the Illicit Trafficking in NDPS Act, 1988 for convenience. The Court was prima facie doubtful of the involvement of the detenu which may fall under the definition of Illicit Trafficking in NDPS Act under Section 2(e).

The Court observed that the subjective satisfaction arrived at by the detaining authority cannot be said to be legal, valid and in accordance with law, inasmuch as the offences alleged in the FIR cannot have any bearing on the public order as required under the Act and other relevant penal laws are sufficient enough to take care of the situation and that the allegations as have been levelled against the detenu cannot be said to be germane for the purpose of bringing the detenu within the meaning of section 3(1) of the Act.

"Unless and until, the material is there to make out a case that the person has become a threat and menace to the Society so as to disturb the whole tempo of the society and that all social apparatus is in peril disturbing public order at the instance of such person, it cannot be said that the detenue is a person within the meaning of section 3(1) of the Act. Except general statements, there is no material on record which shows that the detenu is acting in such a manner, which is dangerous to the public order."

PRECEDENTS OF THE COURT 

The Court referred to Pushkar Mukherjee & Ors Vs. The State of West Bengal, 1968 Latest Caselaw 271 SC wherein the distinction between 'law and order' and 'public order' has been clearly laid down.

It also referred to Rekha Vs. State of Tamil Nadu Tr.Sec.To Govt. & ANR, 2011 Latest Caselaw 286 SC. 

CONCLUSION: 

The Court therefore allowed the petition noting that registration of FIR by itself cannot have any nexus with the breach of maintenance of public order and the authority cannot have recourse under the Act and no other relevant and cogent material exists for invoking power under section 3(2) of the Act.



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

allahabad-high-court-bar-association-suspends-strike-lawyers-to-boycott-justice-yashwant-varmas-oath-ceremony
Trending Judiciary
Allahabad High Court Bar Association Suspends Strike, Lawyers To Boycott Justice Yashwant Varma’s Oath Ceremony

Allahabad HC Bar suspends strike, to boycott Justice Yashwant Varma’s oath. Judicial work resumes April 1; national press conference set for April 26-27.

31 March, 2025 01:49 PM
husbands-spiritual-obsession-and-denial-of-sex-amount-to-mental-cruelty-kerala-hc-grants-divorce
Trending Judiciary
Husband’s Spiritual Obsession and Denial of Sex Amount to Mental Cruelty: Kerala HC Grants Divorce [Read Judgment]

Kerala HC upholds divorce, ruling that the husband’s spiritual obsession and denial of conjugal rights amounted to mental cruelty and irretrievable breakdown.

31 March, 2025 03:44 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-stays-alld-hcs-observations-on-grabbing-breasts-opening-pyjama-strings-in-attempt-to-rape-case
Trending Judiciary
SC stays Alld HC's observations on "grabbing breasts, opening pyjama strings" in attempt to rape case

SC stays Allahabad High Court’s remarks on attempt to rape case, calling them “inhuman” and “unknown to law,” after nationwide outrage over the controversial observations.

26 March, 2025 11:48 AM
madras-high-court-awards-rs-100000-compensation-for-mental-agony-over-denial-of-maternity-leave
Trending Judiciary
Madras High Court awards Rs. 1,00,000 compensation for mental agony over denial of maternity leave [Read Order]

Madras HC awards ₹1 lakh compensation for denial of maternity leave, stressing a humane approach to employee rights and rejecting archaic legal views.

26 March, 2025 03:42 PM
punjab-and-haryana-hc-directs-bar-council-of-india-to-address-aibe-fee-concerns
Trending Judiciary
Punjab & Haryana HC directs Bar Council of India to address AIBE fee concerns [Read Order]

Punjab & Haryana HC directs Bar Council of India to review AIBE fee concerns raised in a PIL, seeking a reasoned response within 30 days.

26 March, 2025 03:59 PM
sc-refuses-to-consider-pil-for-probe-into-honey-trap-incident-in-karnataka
Trending Judiciary
SC refuses to consider PIL for probe into honey trap incident in Karnataka

SC declines PIL seeking probe into Karnataka honey trap case involving ministers, judges, citing lack of merit. Petitioner sought independent investigation.

26 March, 2025 05:02 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email