38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, March 28, 2024
Judiciary

Moral Choice Of The College Cannot Be Imposed On Others, Kerala HC strikes Down Discriminatory College Hostel Rules

By LawStreet News Network      18 March, 2019 12:00 AM      0 Comments
Moral Choice Of The College Cannot Be Imposed On Others, Kerala HC strikes Down Discriminatory College Hostel Rules

The Kerala High Court on February 21, 2019, in the case of Anjitha K. Jose v. State Of Kerala, has struck down discriminatory and anti-women college hostel rules by observing that moral choice of the college cannot be imposed on others.

Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque was hearing a petition filed by students of Sree Kerala Varma College. In the petition, the petitioners challenged certain instructions issued by the college authority in regard to the maintenance of discipline in hostel. It was contended that the instructions were discriminatory and anti-women.

The petitioners referred to clause 3.2(13) under the UGC (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal of Sexual harassment of Women Employees and Students in Higher Educational Institutions) Regulations, 2015, which is as follows:

“3.2. (13) Concern for the safety of women students must not be cited to impose discriminatory rules for women in the hostels as compared to male students. Campus safety policies should not result in securitization, such as over monitoring or policing or curtailing the freedom of movement, especially of women employees and students.”

The instructions issued by the college restricted the members of the hostel to take active part in political meetings, processions or propaganda and not to go for the first and second show movie screening.

To this, the court observed that the college does not have a right to interfere with a female student’s choice to participate in political movements or to attend a movie screening of her choice.

Striking down both the instructions, the court held that “This instruction have nothing to do with any discipline in the hostel. It is the fundamental right of every citizen to have its own political views as part of the freedom of expression. That can be only reasonably restricted for securing any objectives of the management of the hostel. Since it has no relation with power conferred with the management, I find this instruction has to be struck down as violative of fundamental rights of the petitioners.”

In view of the instruction refraining girl students from attending late-night screenings for movies, the court said that “It appears that moral choice of the management is attempted to be imposed upon the Boarders. The moral paternalism is something to be frowned upon. A girl is having equal freedom similar to a boy. There are no similar restriction in the boy’s hostel. It is for the students to decide whether they should go for first or second show movies or not. This is an activity outside the hostel activity. The College can fix timing for return in the evening, but that timing should also be reasonably fixed.”

Further, the court also noted such differential treatment cannot be justified, even if they were signed off by the parents of the students.

The court observed that the fundamental right of a management to administer and manage cannot be overlooked and when there are competing fundamental rights involved, the court has to uphold the fundamental right of the management.

Therefore, certain other instructions concerning the need for special permission to remain in the hostel during working hours and disciplinary action for mischievous conduct by students were upheld by the court.

However, the court said that “… Court will have to find out such measures imposed by the management are measures for to secure the object for which such power is conferred upon. If such measures have no correlation with object for which the power is conferred, Court will have to strike it down holding it as arbitrary.

Read the judgment below.



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

india-summons-us-diplomat-over-state-dept-remarks-on-kejriwals-arrest
Trending International
India summons US diplomat over state dept remarks on Kejriwal's arrest

After CAA, U.S. wades into Arvind Kejriwal’s arrest. Here's how India responded.

27 March, 2024 04:41 PM
delhi-high-court-warns-against-aaps-call-for-protest-in-court-premises-amid-kejriwal-arrest
Trending Judiciary
Delhi High Court Warns Against AAP's Call for Protest in Court Premises Amid Kejriwal Arrest

Delhi High Court warns Aam Aadmi Party's Legal Cell of severe action for any protest in Delhi Courts against Arvind Kejriwal's arrest.

27 March, 2024 05:57 PM

TOP STORIES

global-entertainment-giants-warner-bros-netflix-amazon-get-relief-from-delhi-hc-in-copyright-protection-case
Trending Business
Global entertainment giants Warner Bros, Netflix, Amazon get relief from Delhi HC in copyright protection case

Delhi HC grants relief to global entertainment giants like Netflix, Amazon, Warner Bros, ordering takedown of copyrighted content on rogue websites.

22 March, 2024 12:13 PM
arvind-kejriwal-arrested-can-cm-administer-a-region-while-being-in-jail
Trending Top Stories
Arvind Kejriwal Arrested | Can CM administer a region while being in jail?

Will President's rule be imposed in Delhi after Kejriwal’s arrest? Read the full article to know more.

22 March, 2024 03:16 PM
merely-because-you-are-politician-cant-bypass-statutory-remedies-procedure-sc-refuses-to-consider-bail-by-kavitha
Trending Judiciary
'Merely because you are politician, can't bypass statutory remedies, procedure,' SC refuses to consider bail by Kavitha

Supreme Court denies bail to politician Kavitha in Delhi Liquor Policy Scam; ED alleges Rs 100 crore illegal gratification.

22 March, 2024 03:34 PM
ponmudi-to-be-sworn-in-as-minister-tn-governor-relents-before-sc
Trending Judiciary
Ponmudi to be sworn in as Minister, TN Governor relents before SC

Tamil Nadu Governor relents to Supreme Court's order, agrees to swear in DMK leader K Ponmudi as Minister after court's rap.

22 March, 2024 03:54 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email