38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, July 25, 2024

New trend among SC judges to make prejudiced oral comments based on media reports: Justice Dhingra on transfer plea of Waqf Act

By Editor. Jhanak Sharma      21 September, 2022 12:09 AM      0 Comments
New trend among SC judges to make prejudiced oral comments based on media reports: Justice Dhingra on transfer plea of Waqf Act

NEW DELHI: Former Delhi High Court judge, Justice S N Dhingra has expressed his strong reservations over the Supreme Court's judges making unwarranted comments based on media reports about a case being heard by them, showing their "prejudiced view and predetermined mind".

Referring to the SC's oral observations made on Monday on transfer petition on validity of Waqf Act by advocate Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay, he said, "The Supreme Court did not say anything on transfer plea whether it can be allowed or not but it formed an opinion based on media reports and questioned the petitioner citing the trusts formed in other laws. The court forgot that status of Waqf Board and that of trusts in other state laws is quite different."

"The question before the court was for transfer of the matter pending before the High Court and not on the issue of validity of Waqf Act," he added.

A bench of Justices K M Joseph and Hrishikesh Roy told senior advocate Ranjit Kumar, representing Upadhyay that the court was pained and shocked with the objection with the fact all the members of Waqf Board are Muslims. "Are we going to go by religion," the bench further asked.

Talking to LawStreet Bharat, Justice Dhingra said, "I am surprised with this new practice and trend started in the Supreme Court that the matter is of one thing while the observations are about something else."

He said this was exactly what had happened in Nupur Sharma case as well.

"She (Nupur Sharma) went to court for transfer but the SC judges pronounced her guilty. Same is the case here. There was no argument on validity of the Waqf Act but the SC made comments on objection raised over Muslim members of the Board," he said.

"There was no question for the petitioner to raise all these arguments before the SC on validity or presence of Muslim members in the board. To make comments on what is being discussed in media shows that judges have a predetermined views and prejudiced mind," former Justice Dhingra said.

The former judge said making oral comments had an adverse impact on the general public as well as media which also start making free comments on such observations.

"I have a suggestion to the judges that they should not watch TV or consume other media. If they continue to form their views based on media reports, then what is need for them to hear arguments," he said.

He said instead of making oral observations, the judges should put it down in writings by dictating the order.

"Why do you invite general public and media to give their comments on your oral observations? Had you given a written order, I would have gone through it and made my views whether the order has got substance or not," he said.

With regard to the Waqf Act, he said there is no other law in any religion like this, giving such wide power to the Commissioner to declare any property as Waqf property.


Judges should not watch TV or consume other media. If they continue to form their views based on media reports, then what is need for them to hear arguments: Justice Dhingra


SC judges making oral comments based on what is discussed in media shows their prejudiced view and predetermined mind: Justice S N Dhingra


Watch full  interview on


Share this article:

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
Investor Vishvanidhi Dalmia accused of collusion in NSEL Scam, Maharashtra Govt Affidavit reveals [Read Affidavit]

Investor Vishvanidhi Dalmia accused of colluding with NSEL's prime accused Jignesh Shah, as revealed in Maharashtra Government's affidavit filed in Bombay High Court.

24 July, 2024 09:34 AM
Trending Judiciary
SC declines re-test of NEET UG, 2024

SC declines re-test for NEET UG 2024 due to insufficient evidence of systemic paper leak, affecting only 155 students and preserving the sanctity of the exam.

24 July, 2024 10:00 AM


Trending Judiciary

Supreme Court allows compounding of offence in cheque dishonour case, emphasizing the priority of compensatory aspects over punitive in settlements.

19 July, 2024 09:12 AM
Trending Judiciary
Allahabad HC directs Passport Authority to decide on application without prior court permission in pending criminal cases [Read Order]

Allahabad HC directs Passport Authority to decide applications without prior court permission for individuals with pending criminal cases within a specified timeframe.

19 July, 2024 10:03 AM
Trending Judiciary
Restrictions in law not to prevent constitutional court from granting bail if right to speedy trial infringed: SC [Read Judgement]

SC affirms constitutional courts can grant bail despite restrictive laws if the right to a speedy trial under Article 21 is infringed.

19 July, 2024 10:17 AM
Trending Judiciary
Sexual harrasment charges against WB Governor: SC to examine constitutional immunity

The Supreme Court will examine a plea to investigate sexual harassment allegations against West Bengal Governor C V Ananda Bose, challenging his constitutional immunity.

19 July, 2024 01:46 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email