38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, October 09, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

PIL by Ashwini Upadhyay in SC for declaring TDS as arbitrary, irrational and against Constitution

By Jhanak Sharma      30 December, 2024 06:06 AM      0 Comments
PIL by Ashwini Upadhyay in SC for declaring TDS as arbitrary irrational and against Constitution

NEW DELHI: A PIL has been filed by eminent lawyer Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay seeking a declaration that the Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) system is manifestly arbitrary, irrational and against Articles 14, 19, 21 of the Constitution, hence void and inoperative.

It claimed the regulatory and procedural framework surrounding TDS is excessively technical, often requiring specialised legal and financial expertise, which most assessees lack. The result is an unjust shifting of sovereign responsibilities from the government to private citizens without adequate compensation, resources, or legal safeguards.

Alternatively, the petitioner sought a direction to the NITI Ayog to consider the grounds and contentions raised in this petition and suggest the necessary changes in Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) system; or direct the Law Commission of India to examine the legality of the Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) system and prepare a report within three months.

The PIL contended Illiterate or economically weaker assessees, who lack the capacity to navigate technical framework, suffer undue hardship and harassment, undermining the constitutional guarantee of equality before the law under Article 14.

"This amounts to an indirect tax burden imposed on TDS assessees, which lacks explicit legislative sanction, making it unconstitutional and against public interest," it stated.

The TDS regime adversely impacts small earners and those below the taxable threshold, as tax is often deducted at source despite their incomes being non-taxable. This creates a system where small taxpayers are forced to file refund claims for excess TDS. It is economically unviable for many due to the cost of professional assistance and repeated visits to tax offices, which can lead to harassment and loss of time.

"Many taxpayers, especially in rural and economically weaker sections, forgo their rightful refunds, resulting in unwarranted enrichment of the Government. This practice violates the constitutional principles of fairness, equity, and public interest, as it disproportionately exploits the most vulnerable segments of society," it said.

The petitioner stated the PIL is for the benefit of TDS assessees who have become a cog in the financial machinery of the country.

"No heed is paid to the illogical work system where private entities are bound to stricter regulations than the government officials. The transfer of sovereign duty on private entities without compensating them for the same is arbitrary and against the fundamental principles of the constitution," the PIL said.

The petitioner stated the Government’s objectives of timely and regular tax collection can be achieved more effectively and equitably by replacing the TDS regime with a system of monthly advance tax payments.

"Under this alternative: Taxpayers earning taxable income beyond the exempt limit can be required to remit monthly installments of advance tax directly to the Government. This eliminates the need for intermediaries (i.e., TDS assessees) and reduces procedural complexities for individuals making payments subject to TDS. The Income Tax Department’s technological infrastructure, including the PAN and e-filing systems, is sufficiently advanced to track advance tax payments and ensure compliance," it said.

The PIL claimed the proposed system offers more advantages over the TDS regime as it reduces hardships for TDS Assessees. By shifting the tax compliance burden to those earning taxable income, the alternative system alleviates the hardships faced by TDS assessees, particularly those who are illiterate/lack expertise.

This new system enhances compliance by taxpayers as those with taxable income would be directly responsible for calculating and remitting taxes, ensuring greater accountability and transparency. It would encourage fairness in tax administration with the principles of equity and proportionality by holding actual income earners, rather than intermediaries, accountable for their tax liabilities.
 



Share this article:

About:

Jhanak is a lawyer by profession and legal journalist by passion. She graduated at the top of her cl...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Stop Dividing India On Minority-Majority Basis: BJP LEADER ASHWINI UPADHYAY Stop Dividing India On Minority-Majority Basis: BJP LEADER ASHWINI UPADHYAY

The Constitution of India is by the Indians and for the Indians. Globally, there are 6000 plus languages. Can we consider a Chinese or French-speaking person a linguistic minority? If yes, then India would end up having 60+ linguistic minorities. Linguistic minorities may be identified at the district level, and only Indian languages may be considered for protection under Articles 29-30, i.e. a Hindi speaking person is a linguistic minority in Kerala and Tamil speaking in Bihar. The same notion may follow for religious minorities too, and only India originated religions may be considered a religious minority

Ashwini Upadhyay Who Challenged Places of Worship Act Seeks Impleadment In Gyanvapi Dispute Before Supreme Court Ashwini Upadhyay Who Challenged Places of Worship Act Seeks Impleadment In Gyanvapi Dispute Before Supreme Court

The Supreme Court had on Friday heard the Special Leave Petition regarding the Gyanvapi issue and had ordered that Order 7 Rule 11 Application being tried in the subordinate court of Varanasi be sent to the District Judge, as the Court was of the opinion that a seasoned hand would be required to handle the matter.

SC to hear plea against validity of Places of Worship Act on Sep 9 SC to hear plea against validity of Places of Worship Act on Sep 9

The Supreme Court is likely to hear on September 9 a plea by BJP leader and advocate Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay challenging validity of the Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act, 1991, which mandated maintaining character of religious places as prevailed on August 15, 1947.

TRENDING NEWS

pmla-appellate-tribunal-orders-immediate-release-of-seized-bmw-x7-in-hemant-soren-land-scam-case
Trending Crime, Police And Law
PMLA appellate tribunal orders immediate release of seized BMW X7 in Hemant Soren land scam case [Read Order]

PMLA tribunal orders ED to release seized BMW X7 in Hemant Soren land scam case, citing lack of proof linking the luxury car to money laundering.

08 October, 2025 08:06 PM
offence-under-category-of-upholding-family-prestige-sc-orders-release-of-man-on-remission
Trending Judiciary
'Offence under category of upholding family prestige,' SC orders release of man on remission [Read Judgment]

SC orders immediate release of life convict who served 22 years for a murder committed to uphold family honour, citing Maharashtra remission guidelines.

08 October, 2025 08:19 PM

TOP STORIES

allahabad-hc-refuses-interim-protection-to-sambhal-mosque-asks-petitioners-to-approach-appellate-court
Trending Judiciary
Allahabad HC Refuses Interim Protection to Sambhal Mosque, Asks Petitioners to Approach Appellate Court [Read Order]

Allahabad High Court refused interim protection to Sambhal mosque, directing petitioners to seek remedy before the appellate court under UP Revenue Code.

06 October, 2025 04:48 PM
calling-off-marriage-after-courtship-not-a-crime-or-breach-of-promise-delhi-hc
Trending Judiciary
Calling Off Marriage After Courtship Not A Crime Or Breach Of Promise: Delhi HC [Read Order]

Delhi High Court grants bail, ruling that ending marriage plans after courtship is not a breach of promise or offence under false promise to marry.

06 October, 2025 05:03 PM
celebrating-bail-on-social-media-not-ground-for-cancellation-without-specific-threat-to-complainant-delhi-hc
Trending Judiciary
Celebrating Bail On Social Media Not Ground For Cancellation Without Specific Threat To Complainant: Delhi HC [Read Order]

Delhi HC rules that celebrating bail on social media isn’t grounds for cancellation unless a specific threat or intimidation is proven.

06 October, 2025 05:25 PM
woman-cannot-claim-maintenance-after-securing-rape-conviction-against-live-in-partner-jammu-and-kashmir-hc
Trending Judiciary
Woman Cannot Claim Maintenance After Securing Rape Conviction Against Live-In Partner: Jammu & Kashmir HC [Read Order]

J&K High Court held that a woman who secured a rape conviction against her live-in partner cannot claim maintenance under Section 125 CrPC.

06 October, 2025 06:08 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email