38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, November 21, 2024
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

SC by majority highlights 'Economic democracy’, trust on wisdom of elected government as backbone of high-growth rate of India’s economy [Read Judgment]

By Jhanak Singh      06 November, 2024 03:23 PM      0 Comments
SC by majority highlights Economic democracy trust on wisdom of elected government as backbone of high growth rate of Indias economy

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court has said that the vision of the framers while drafting the Constitution was not to lay down a particular form of social structure or economic policy for future governments, while it held by a majority view of 7:2 that all privately owned properties cannot be regarded as material resources of the community to be acquired by the state for public good.

In its historic verdict, the nine judge bench led by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud said to scuttle this constitutional vision by imposing a single economic theory, which views the acquisition of private property by the state as the ultimate goal, would undermine the very fabric and principles of our constitutional framework.

SC: Economic Policy Should Reflect People’s Choice, Not a Fixed Ideology

The judgment authored by CJI Chandrachud said the Constitution was framed in broad terms to allow succeeding governments to experiment with and adopt a structure for economic governance which would subserve the policies for which it owes accountability to the electorate.

The bench said, according to Dr B R Ambedkar, if the Constitution laid down a particular form of economic and social organisation, it would amount to taking away the liberty of people to decide the social organisation in which they wish to live. He opined on several occasions that economic democracy is not tied to one economic structure, such as socialism or capitalism, but to the aspiration for a ‘welfare state’.

"Thus, the role of this court is not to lay down economic policy, but to facilitate this intent of the framers to lay down the foundation for an ‘economic democracy'," the bench said.

Trust in Government Vital for High-Growth, Says CJI in Landmark Ruling

The court noted both Justice Krishna Iyer (in Ranganatha Reddy and Bhimsinghji judgments) and Justice Chinappa Reddy (in Sanjeev Coke judgment) consistently referred to the vision of the framers as the basis to advance this economic ideology as the guiding principle of the provision.

In Bhim Singhji, Justice Krishna Iyer cited Karl Marx in his judgment to observe that taking over large conglomerations of land is necessary to make Article 39 a “constitutional reality”. Interestingly, in the same decision, Justice Krishna Iyer also expressed his view about the nature of the economy and observed that our economy was “in the transitional stage … undergoing a fabian transformation”, the bench pointed out.

"Today, the Indian economy has transitioned from the dominance of public investment to the co-existence of public and private investment. The doctrinal error in the Krishna Iyer approach was, postulating a rigid economic theory, which advocates for greater state control over private resources, as the exclusive basis for constitutional governance," the CJI said.

He further said India’s economic trajectory indicates that the Constitution and the custodians of the Constitution – the electorate – have routinely rejected one economic dogma as being the exclusive repository of truth.

"As participants in a vibrant multi-party ‘economic democracy’, the ‘People of India’ have voted to power governments which have adopted varied economic and social policies, based on the country's evolving development priorities and challenges. The foresighted vision of our framers to establish an ‘economic democracy’ and trust the wisdom of  the elected government, has been the backbone of the high-growth rate of India’s economy, making it one of the fastest-growing economies in the world," the CJI said.
 

 [Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:

Jhanak is a lawyer by profession and legal journalist by passion. She graduated at the top of her cl...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Order to appoint One Man Committee of Justice (Retd.) Lokur for the Prevention of Stubble Burning Kept in Abeyance by SC itself [READ ORDER] Order to appoint One Man Committee of Justice (Retd.) Lokur for the Prevention of Stubble Burning Kept in Abeyance by SC itself [READ ORDER]

CJI suggests holding measures in abeyance, questioning the PIL petitioner in the stubble burning case. Justice (Retd.) Madan B Lokur's role also discussed.

"Experts Say Your Beautiful Cars Also Contribute to Air Pollution," CJI SA Bobde Says While Hearing Stubble Burning Issue "Experts Say Your Beautiful Cars Also Contribute to Air Pollution," CJI SA Bobde Says While Hearing Stubble Burning Issue

Chief Justice of India S.A. Bobde ensures no stubble burning orders will be passed without considering petitioners' input, confirms Senior Advocate Vikas Singh.

Centre states that Farmers Stubble Burning contributes to 10% Pollution; SC retailitates saying, 'Pollution is caused by city-related issues. Take care of them and then we will come to stubble burning' Centre states that Farmers Stubble Burning contributes to 10% Pollution; SC retailitates saying, 'Pollution is caused by city-related issues. Take care of them and then we will come to stubble burning'

Supreme Court urges Centre, Punjab, Haryana, and UP to implement work-from-home due to air pollution. Next hearing set for November 17, 2021.

WhatsApp Assures High Court Of Full Cooperation In Dhanbad Judge Murder Case WhatsApp Assures High Court Of Full Cooperation In Dhanbad Judge Murder Case

The CBI has charged auto-rickshaw driver Lakhan Verma and his brother Rahul with murder and false information, invoking IPC Sections 302, 201, and 34.

TRENDING NEWS

no-disciplinary-proceedings-allowed-against-employee-after-retirement-sc
Trending Judiciary
No disciplinary proceedings allowed against employee after retirement: SC [Read Judgment]

SC rules disciplinary proceedings cannot start after employee’s retirement or extended service. SBI directed to release pending dues within six weeks.

20 November, 2024 03:47 PM
sc-restores-criminal-charges-against-kerala-mla-for-tampering-of-evidence-in-a-drug-case
Trending Judiciary
SC restores criminal charges against Kerala MLA for tampering of evidence in a drug case

SC revives criminal charges against Kerala MLA Antony Raju for tampering evidence in 1990 drug case; directs trial completion within a year.

20 November, 2024 04:02 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-to-president-decide-death-row-convict-balwant-singhs-mercy-plea-in-2-weeks-or-court-will-intervene
Trending Judiciary
SC to President: Decide death row convict Balwant Singh’s mercy plea in 2 weeks or court will intervene

SC directs President to decide death row convict Balwant Singh Rajoana’s mercy plea in 2 weeks, warns of intervention if delay persists. Hearing on Dec 5.

18 November, 2024 01:11 PM
high-courts-must-ensure-genuineness-of-settlement-before-quashing-proceedings-sc
Trending Judiciary
High Courts must ensure genuineness of settlement before quashing proceedings: SC [Read Judgment]

SC mandates High Courts to verify the genuineness of settlements in serious offences like rape before quashing cases, ensuring justice and transparency.

18 November, 2024 01:49 PM
supreme-court-enforces-grap-4-measures-to-combat-delhis-severe-air-pollution-warns-against-relaxation
Trending Judiciary
Supreme Court enforces GRAP-4 measures to combat Delhi’s severe air pollution, warns against relaxation [Read Order]

Supreme Court enforces GRAP-4 measures in Delhi-NCR as air quality worsens, mandates strict action on pollution and stubble burning for immediate relief.

19 November, 2024 10:26 AM
cji-sanjiv-khanna-recuses-from-delhi-ridge-tree-felling-case-supreme-court-seeks-tree-restoration-updates
Trending Judiciary
CJI Sanjiv Khanna recuses from Delhi Ridge Tree Felling Case, Supreme Court seeks tree restoration updates

CJI Sanjiv Khanna recuses from Delhi Ridge tree felling case citing prior involvement; Supreme Court seeks updates on restoration and monitoring measures.

19 November, 2024 10:58 AM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email