38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, October 11, 2024
Judiciary

SC prohibits use of Bulldozer against accused without its permission [Read Order]

By Jhanak Singh      18 September, 2024 12:00 PM      0 Comments
SC prohibits use of Bulldozer against accused without its permission

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Tuesday issued an order barring the use of bulldozer by States for demolition of a property of an accused in a criminal case, without permission of this court, saying such action was against the ethos of the Constitution.

The court, however, clarified this order won't apply if there is any unauthorised construction on public road, footpaths, railway lines, water bodies, etc.

A bench of Justices B R Gavai and K V Vishwanathan objected to statements made after its September 2 order indicating framing of guidelines on the use of bulldozer.

The bench pointed out after the order, there have been statements that bulldozer will continue.

"After September 2 order, there has been grand standing and justification. Should this happen in our country? Should Election Commission be noticed? We will formulate directives," the bench said.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta objected to such directions, saying the hands of statutory authorities can't be tied like this.

"Heavens would not fall in 15 days," the bench said.

To this, Mehta said, "Heavens never fall".

"Let us clarify ours will be directives. They are being called guidelines. Till next date, there should be stay on demolition without leave of court," the bench said.

"We made it clear we won't come between unauthorised construction. But the executive can't be a judge," the bench said.

The court said it would issue directives in line with the Vishakha guidelines with regard to sexual harrasment at workplaces, invoking its power under Article 142 of the Constitution to do complete justice.

Senior advocate C U Singh, appearing for the petitioner Jamiat Ulama I Hind contended demolitions were taking place every day. He said despite indications on the last date, after some alleged incident happened of stone pelting, same night demolition happened.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Union government, said notices were served in 2022 and thereafter actions were taken.

"Let the state government be informed. Why hurriedly demolish in 2024? When notices were issued in 2022," the bench asked.

Mehta said a narrative was being built that all such actions were illegal and demolitions are in case of particular religion. He said the affected parties have not approached the court as they knew their constructions were illegal.

The bench, however, said the noise and narrative outside was not influencing it.

"We won't get into question of which community faced such action at this point. Even if there is one instance of illegal demolition, it is against ethos of Constitution," the bench said.

Also Read : SC to lay down guidelines on 'Bulldozer justice'

"Our only object is to streamline demolition actions," the bench said.

Singh contended demolitions were happening daily, the court should consider the matter on a short date.

Mehta said in case of Madhya Pradesh, 70 shops were demolished after following the procedure.

Of those, more than 50 belonged to Hindus. What are they saying "mohalla" etc, it is about narrative building, he claimed.

The court ordered to post the matter on October 1.

"Till next date, there shall be no demolitions unless the statutorily permitted. Stay your hands off. What will happen in 15 days," the bench said.

The bench again emphasised there has to be judicial oversight in such matters.

Mehta sought to emphasise the magnitude of the order. This court prevented officials across country, from exercising statutory rights, he said.

The Supreme Court had on September 2 said it would lay down pan India guidelines to deal with a controversial issue of "Bulldozer justice" resorted to by some state governments to demolish the house or shop of a person immediately after he or she is accused of an offence.

On September 12, a separate bench led by Justice Hrishikesh Roy made strong observations against "bulldozer justice", saying in a country where actions of the State are governed by the rule of law, the transgression by a family member cannot lead to demolition of their legally constructed house or it would be equivalent to running bulldozer over the laws.
 

[Read Order]



Share this article:

About:

Jhanak is a lawyer by profession and legal journalist by passion. She graduated at the top of her cl...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Order to appoint One Man Committee of Justice (Retd.) Lokur for the Prevention of Stubble Burning Kept in Abeyance by SC itself [READ ORDER] Order to appoint One Man Committee of Justice (Retd.) Lokur for the Prevention of Stubble Burning Kept in Abeyance by SC itself [READ ORDER]

CJI suggests holding measures in abeyance, questioning the PIL petitioner in the stubble burning case. Justice (Retd.) Madan B Lokur's role also discussed.

"Experts Say Your Beautiful Cars Also Contribute to Air Pollution," CJI SA Bobde Says While Hearing Stubble Burning Issue "Experts Say Your Beautiful Cars Also Contribute to Air Pollution," CJI SA Bobde Says While Hearing Stubble Burning Issue

Chief Justice of India S.A. Bobde ensures no stubble burning orders will be passed without considering petitioners' input, confirms Senior Advocate Vikas Singh.

Centre states that Farmers Stubble Burning contributes to 10% Pollution; SC retailitates saying, 'Pollution is caused by city-related issues. Take care of them and then we will come to stubble burning' Centre states that Farmers Stubble Burning contributes to 10% Pollution; SC retailitates saying, 'Pollution is caused by city-related issues. Take care of them and then we will come to stubble burning'

Supreme Court urges Centre, Punjab, Haryana, and UP to implement work-from-home due to air pollution. Next hearing set for November 17, 2021.

WhatsApp Assures High Court Of Full Cooperation In Dhanbad Judge Murder Case WhatsApp Assures High Court Of Full Cooperation In Dhanbad Judge Murder Case

The CBI has charged auto-rickshaw driver Lakhan Verma and his brother Rahul with murder and false information, invoking IPC Sections 302, 201, and 34.

TRENDING NEWS

meet-the-successors-of-ratan-tata-the-next-gen-tata-scions
Trending Business
Meet the successors of Ratan Tata, the next-gen Tata scions

Meet the next gen Tata scions, the successors of Ratan Tata. Ratan Tata never married and has no children, promoting speculation about future leadership of Tata Group.

10 October, 2024 10:44 AM
famous-quotes-of-ratan-tata-india-s-most-humble-businessman
Trending Business
Famous quotes of Ratan Tata, India's most humble businessman

Famous quotes of Ratan Tata that serve as valuable life lessons.

10 October, 2024 11:00 AM

TOP STORIES

plea-filed-in-sc-for-restoring-statehood-of-j-and-k
Trending Judiciary
Plea filed in SC for restoring statehood of J&K

A plea has been filed in the Supreme Court seeking a direction to restore statehood of Jammu and Kashmir as per the assurance given before it in the case titled as 'In re Article 370 of the Constitution', in a time bound manner within a period of two months.

09 October, 2024 03:18 PM
sc-dismisses-plea-for-review-of-judgment-on-electoral-bonds-scheme
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses plea for review of judgment on Electoral Bonds Scheme [Read Order]

The Supreme Court has dismissed a petition seeking review of the February 15, 2024 Constitution bench judgment which struck down the 2018 Electoral Bonds scheme as unconstitutional.

09 October, 2024 03:41 PM
sc-dismisses-review-plea-against-aug-1-judgment-on-sub-classification-of-sc-sts
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses review plea against Aug 1 judgment on sub classification of SC/STs [Read Order]

The Supreme Court has dismissed a plea for review of its August 1, 2024 judgment which allowed the States to sub classify Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes to provide preferential treatment to the disadvantaged groups among them in government jobs and education.

09 October, 2024 04:05 PM
meet-the-successors-of-ratan-tata-the-next-gen-tata-scions
Trending Business
Meet the successors of Ratan Tata, the next-gen Tata scions

Meet the next gen Tata scions, the successors of Ratan Tata. Ratan Tata never married and has no children, promoting speculation about future leadership of Tata Group.

10 October, 2024 10:44 AM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email