NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court in its minority view declared the 103 rd Constituional Amendment Act as unconstitutional for excluding SC/ST and OBCs from its ambit.
Justice S Ravindra Bhat, who authored the minority judgement along with CJI U U Lalit, said that 10% EWS quota has for the first time sanctioned an avowedly exclusionary, discriminatory principle, which is constituonally unsound.
Justice Bhat and CJI Lalit dissented with a majority view which upheld validity of the 103 rd Constituional Amendment Act, 2019.
He said that in his considered opinion, the amendment, by the language of exclusion, undermines the fabric of social justice, and thereby, the basic structure.
I regret my inability to concur with the views expressed by the majority opinion...that this court has for the first time, in the seven decades of the republic, sanctioned an avowedly exclusionary and discriminatory principle. Our Constitution does not speak the language of exclusion, Justice Bhat said.
He said a universally acknowledged truth is that reservations have been conceived and quotas created, through provision in the Constitution, only to offset fundamental, deep rooted generations of wrongs perpetrated on entire communities and castes.
Reservation is designed as a powerful tool to enable equal access and equal opportunity and introducing the economic basis for reservation as a new criterion, is permissible, he said.
Yet, the othering of socially and educationally disadvantaged classes including SCs/ STs/ OBCs by excluding them from this new reservation on the ground that they enjoy pre-existing benefits, is to heap fresh injustice based on past disability. The exclusionary clause operates in an utterly arbitrary manner, he added.
Justice Bhat further said, The net effect of the entire exclusionary principle is Orwellian, (so to say) which is that all the poorest are entitled to be considered, regardless of their caste or class, yet only those who belong to forward classes or castes, would be considered, and those from socially disadvantaged classes for SC/STs would be ineligible.
Read Order
