38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, August 29, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

SC Strikes Down ‘Both Hands Intact’ rule for MBBS, calls it ableist and unconstitutional [Read Judgment]

By Jhanak Sharma      24 February, 2025 05:48 PM      0 Comments
SC Strikes Down Both Hands Intact rule for MBBS calls it ableist and unconstitutional

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Friday said that there cannot be a “one size fits all” approach under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, since flexibility in answering individual needs and requirements is an essential component of reasonable accommodation under the law.

A bench of Justices B R Gavai and K V Vishwanathan disapproved the 2019 guidelines on admission of students with “specified disabilities” to MBBS Course, which said, "Both hands intact, with intact sensations, sufficient strength and range of motion are essential to be considered eligible for medical course”.

SC Rules ‘Both Hands Intact’ MBBS Eligibility Norm as Ableist, Violates RPwD Act

Dealing with a plea by a youth against denial of admission in MBBS course, the bench said, "In our view, this prescription of “both hands intact…” is completely antithetical to Article 41 of the Constitution; the principles enshrined in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and the salutary provisions of the RPwD Act."

The court said, it also indicates a classification which is overbroad and glorifies ‘ableism’. It propagates that persons with typical abilities and with faculties similar to what the majority may have or somehow superior, the bench said.

Supreme Court Rejects Medical Board’s Rigid Guidelines, Stresses Inclusive Education

"This is precisely what the Directive Principles of State Policy, the United Nations Convention and the RPwD Act abhor," the bench said

Justice Vishwanathan who wrote the judgment on behalf of the bench, detailed the reasons for its previous direction for admission of Anmol, a person with 58% disabilities in MBBS course at the government medical college in Rajasthan under PwD (OBC) quota.

The bench had rejected the AIIMS' medical board report and went by a separate member recommendation.

The bench said, "Accepting the report of five members and denying the admission of the appellant would be upholding the theory of ableism which we are not prepared to do".

With regard to NMC guidelines, the bench said, "A prescription such as “both hands intact…” reeks of ableism and has no place in a statutory regulation. In fact, it has the effect of denuding the rights guaranteed under the Constitution and the RPwD Act and makes a mockery of the principle of reasonable accommodation".

In the matter, the five-member of the board did not find the candidate 'fit' owing to the NMC guidelines, which it said, perhaps need revision.

However, Dr Satendra Singh, another member of the board, gave a separate report, stating that the appellant can successfully navigate the MBBS Course with clinical accommodations and assistive technologies.

The correct approach in such cases is the one that Dr Singh has adopted viz, to not bar a candidate at the threshold but grant the candidate the choice after completing the MBBS Course, to decide whether he whishes to specialize in a nonsurgical or medical branch or continue as a General Duty Medical Officer, the court said.

"It will be unfair to presume incompetence at the threshold without first providing an opportunity to the candidate and ensuring the availability of accommodations and assistive products," the bench said.

The court said, the “both hands intact…” prescription has no sanctity in law as it does not admit of a functional assessment of the individual candidate, a matter which is so fundamental in protecting the rights of persons with disabilities.

In fact, the court pointed out, it was the Union government, through the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment which took the lead in issuing the communication of January 24, 2024 pursuant to the directions in a judgment.

The Centre's letter had then mandated the review of regulations by the National Medical Commission (NMC), which were recorded by this court.

The court also decided to examine on March 3, 2025 whether the National Medical Commission has formulated the revised guidelines in accordance with the judgments of this Court, in Omkar Ramchandra Gond (on October 15, 2024) and Om Rathod (on October 25, 2024). The court directed the NMC to file an affidavit explaining the current status before the hearing date.
 

[Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:

Jhanak is a lawyer by profession and legal journalist by passion. She graduated at the top of her cl...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Another CBI Officer Investigating Rakesh Asthana Moves SC Against Transfer, Makes Startling Revelations Another CBI Officer Investigating Rakesh Asthana Moves SC Against Transfer, Makes Startling Revelations

After A.K. Bassi, another CBI officer who was investigating corruption allegations against Special Director Rakesh Asthana moved the Supreme Court.

Ayodhya verdict: SC rules in favour of Ram Lalla, Sunni Waqf Board gets alternate land Ayodhya verdict: SC rules in favour of Ram Lalla, Sunni Waqf Board gets alternate land

SC bench led by CJI Ranjan Gogoi has allotted the dispute site to Ram Janmabhoomi Nyas, while directing the government to allot an alternate 5 acre land within Ayodhya to Sunni Waqf Board to build a mosque.

Supreme Court: Money Spent On Judiciary Less Than 1% In All States Except Delhi Supreme Court: Money Spent On Judiciary Less Than 1% In All States Except Delhi

The court guided all states to document their response to the commission's report within four weeks. If any of the states fail to file a response, it will be presumed that they have no objections to the recommendations made by the commission, the court said.

Supreme Court Top Panel Names Chief Justices for Bombay, Orissa and Meghalaya High Courts Supreme Court Top Panel Names Chief Justices for Bombay, Orissa and Meghalaya High Courts

On April 18, 2020, the Supreme Court Collegium recommended new Chief Justices for three High Courts. Justice Dipankar Datta was proposed as Chief Justice of the Bombay High Court, succeeding Justice B.P. Dharmadhikari. Justice Biswanath Somadder was nominated as Chief Justice of Meghalaya High Court, while Justice Mohammad Rafiq was recommended for transfer as Chief Justice of Orissa High Court.

TRENDING NEWS


TOP STORIES

adult-woman-free-to-live-with-married-man-personal-autonomy-prevails-over-morality
Trending Judiciary
Adult Woman Free To Live With Married Man, Personal Autonomy Prevails Over Morality: Madhya Pradesh HC [Read Order]

Adult woman has right to live with married man, rules MP High Court; says personal autonomy outweighs moral concerns.

23 August, 2025 04:00 PM
sc-issues-notice-to-bci-on-plea-against-3-yr-moratorium-on-new-centre-for-legal-education
Trending Judiciary
SC issues notice to BCI on plea against 3-yr moratorium on new centre for legal education

SC issues notice to BCI on plea challenging 3-year moratorium on new legal education centres, calling it arbitrary and violative of fundamental rights.

23 August, 2025 05:13 PM
punjab-and-haryana-hc-upholds-denial-of-furlough-to-life-convict-rules-temporary-release-is-a-concession-not-a-right
Trending Judiciary
Punjab and Haryana HC Upholds Denial of Furlough to Life Convict, Rules Temporary Release Is A Concession, Not A Right [Read Order]

Punjab & Haryana HC upholds denial of furlough to life convict, rules temporary release is a concession, not a right, under 2022 law.

23 August, 2025 05:16 PM
sc-restores-mandatory-20-percent-deposit-for-suspension-of-sentence-in-cheque-bounce-case
Trending Judiciary
SC Restores Mandatory 20% Deposit for Suspension of Sentence in Cheque Bounce Case [Read Order]

SC sets aside P&H HC order; rules 20% deposit mandatory for suspension of sentence in ₹8.65 crore cheque bounce case under NI Act.

25 August, 2025 12:35 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email