38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, March 28, 2024
Judiciary

After Hearing For 16 Years, Supreme Court Reserves Meerut Fire Tragedy Case For Judgment

By AKSHAT BHAT      25 March, 2022 02:49 PM      0 Comments
Supreme Court Reserves Meerut Fire Tragedy Case

A Supreme Court bench consisting of Justices Hement Gupta and Ramasubramanian has reserved judgement in a petition brought by relatives of victims of the 2006 Meerut fire disaster. After 16 years, the case has been reserved for judgement.

It should be emphasised that throughout the hearing, two one-man commissions were appointed. Justice (retired) OP Garg was appointed by the state of Uttar Pradesh as a one-man committee to investigate the disaster. The Supreme Court, however, replaced him in 2014 with Justice (retired) SB Sinha.

Shanti Bhushan, a senior advocate and former Law Minister, continued his remarks today, claiming that there was no specific evidence to determine how the fire originated and that the event planners could not be held liable in these circumstances.

Bhushan, who was representing Mrinal Event Managing Corporation, contended that the company should not be held liable.

Referring to the order passed by the Supreme Court directing the event organisers to deposit a sum of Rs.30 lakhs, he said,  “How much will they have to suffer? They have already suffered enough.”

Justice Hemant Gupta at this point interjected Bhushan and questioned,
“What about the suffering of those who perished in the fire?”

Bhushan elected not to respond to this question. It was also argued that just the event managers were imprisoned, and that no one else was held guilty or imprisoned as a result of the incident.

Bhushan contended that the Justice SB Sinha committee's findings are not binding on the court because it was a State-appointed commission rather than a judicial one. He also claimed that the Supreme Court, in an order dated July 31, 2014, simply substituted Justice Sinha's name for Justice Garg, who was appointed by the State.

The Meerut fire catastrophe occurred on April 10, 2006, on the final day of Mrinal Events & Expositions' India Brand Consumer Show in Victoria Park. According to accounts, a short circuit at the venue produced a fire that killed 60 individuals. According to media accounts, the fire spread through a consumer show in Victoria Park, and almost 2000 people were present at the time of the fire. There was also a stampede-like situation as a result of the occurrence. According to media accounts, despite being arrested by the local police, the event organisers fled and never appeared in court.

Sanjay Gupta, who had lost five members of his family in the incident, filed the current case in 2006. The plea was entered on the grounds that the State's investigation into the tragedy was improperly conducted. Justice (retired) OP Garg of the Allahabad High Court was appointed by the then-Uttar Pradesh government as a one-man committee. The report's findings, however, were challenged by the organisers, who claimed that they were not heard.

By order dated July 31, 2014, the Supreme Court designated Justice (retired) SB Sinha as the one-man commission to investigate the subject. The state was ordered to pay Rs.5 lakhs to the legal representatives of the deceased, Rs.2 lakhs to those who were gravely injured, and Rs.75,000/- to those who had lesser injuries by the same judgement.

On hearing the parties, the court adjourned the matter for decision after 16 years and allowed the parties to offer brief written statements.

Bhushan had yesterday argued that the victims have already been paid enough compensation and said “How much more do they want?”



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

supreme-court-orders-cbi-probe-into-alleged-murder-of-manipur-girl-emphasizes-fair-criminal-investigation
Trending Judiciary
Supreme Court Orders CBI Probe into Alleged Murder of Manipur Girl: Emphasizes Fair Criminal Investigation [Read Judgment]

Supreme Court emphasizes fair criminal investigation, warns unresolved crimes erode public trust. Orders CBI probe into Manipur girl's alleged murder.

27 March, 2024 01:09 PM
india-summons-us-diplomat-over-state-dept-remarks-on-kejriwals-arrest
Trending International
India summons US diplomat over state dept remarks on Kejriwal's arrest

After CAA, U.S. wades into Arvind Kejriwal’s arrest. Here's how India responded.

27 March, 2024 04:41 PM

TOP STORIES

global-entertainment-giants-warner-bros-netflix-amazon-get-relief-from-delhi-hc-in-copyright-protection-case
Trending Business
Global entertainment giants Warner Bros, Netflix, Amazon get relief from Delhi HC in copyright protection case

Delhi HC grants relief to global entertainment giants like Netflix, Amazon, Warner Bros, ordering takedown of copyrighted content on rogue websites.

22 March, 2024 12:13 PM
arvind-kejriwal-arrested-can-cm-administer-a-region-while-being-in-jail
Trending Top Stories
Arvind Kejriwal Arrested | Can CM administer a region while being in jail?

Will President's rule be imposed in Delhi after Kejriwal’s arrest? Read the full article to know more.

22 March, 2024 03:16 PM
merely-because-you-are-politician-cant-bypass-statutory-remedies-procedure-sc-refuses-to-consider-bail-by-kavitha
Trending Judiciary
'Merely because you are politician, can't bypass statutory remedies, procedure,' SC refuses to consider bail by Kavitha

Supreme Court denies bail to politician Kavitha in Delhi Liquor Policy Scam; ED alleges Rs 100 crore illegal gratification.

22 March, 2024 03:34 PM
ponmudi-to-be-sworn-in-as-minister-tn-governor-relents-before-sc
Trending Judiciary
Ponmudi to be sworn in as Minister, TN Governor relents before SC

Tamil Nadu Governor relents to Supreme Court's order, agrees to swear in DMK leader K Ponmudi as Minister after court's rap.

22 March, 2024 03:54 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email