38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, October 25, 2024
Breaking News
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Legal Insiders

Always Remember Facts Like A Fiction Writer: Supreme Court Guides Young Lawyer to Argue Criminal Appeal

By Dolly Chhabda      04 February, 2022 11:12 AM      0 Comments
Always Remember Facts Like A Fiction Writer

Hearing a plea against a murder conviction and life sentence, the Supreme Court on Tuesday (1st February 2022) explained court craft and the art of argumenting to a young lawyer appearing for the petitioners, providing guidance on which portions of the court record to rely on and submissions to formulate, and finally, passing an order of acquittal.

The Court even arranged for a Senior Advocate to instruct the petitioners lawyer on how to argue a criminal appeal.

The bench of Justices D. Y. Chandrachud, Surya Kant, and Vikram Nath was hearing two SLPs filed in 2020 against a January 2019 decision of the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court on a criminal appeal. During the hearing, the lawyer for the petitioners appeared to be fumbling with the submissions at the opening, Justice Surya Kant instructed him- Always remember the facts like a fiction-writer. It should be like you are telling a story to us, the narrative should be also like that

When the lawyer attempted to take the bench through High Court judgement, Justice Chandrachud noted,

When you are in a criminal appeal against conviction, you must state your case without the High Court judgment. When you read a judgment, there may be a tendency to say that okay, these are the reasons for which the High Court said what it did. But that is what you have to overcome in the final hearing!You dont want the judges to get in an affirmation state of mind. You want a completely unbiased and uninfluenced view of your matterthis is a matter of court craft, which you must remember even while arguing a first appeal before the High Court.

When the lawyer requested a pass-over, Justice Chandrachud responded,

Now you have the valuable judicial time of the Supreme Court, dont ask for passovers. We will go through this together.

The bench advised him on how to advance arguments based on the case record, pointing out contradictions in the prosecution witnesses depositions, how they appeared to disintegrate in cross-examination, and how the evidence of certain key witnesses had come to be overlooked.

The bench then heard from the respondent state-lawyer. Following the completion of both parties arguments, the Bench proceeded to dictate its order acquitting the petitioners.

In addition, Justice Chandrachud asked Senior Advocate Manoj Swarup, who was standing before the bench in another issue, to meet with the lawyer in the evening of the same day to discuss how to argue a criminal appeal.



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

cheque-issued-for-bribe-payment-not-enforceable-under-ni-act-punjab-and-haryana-hc
Trending Judiciary
Cheque issued for bribe payment not enforceable under NI Act: Punjab and Haryana HC [Read Order]

The Punjab and Haryana High Court ruled that bribe payments do not constitute legally enforceable liabilities under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

24 October, 2024 10:56 AM
pune-porsche-accident-bombay-hc-rejects-anticipatory-bail-over-alleged-evidence-tampering-involving-3-lakh-bribe
Trending Judiciary
Pune Porsche Accident: Bombay HC rejects anticipatory bail over alleged evidence tampering involving ₹3 lakh bribe [Read Order]

Bombay High Court rejects anticipatory bail in Pune Porsche accident case, citing serious evidence tampering and bribery allegations against the accused’s father.

24 October, 2024 11:07 AM

TOP STORIES

sc-dismisses-plea-for-direction-to-set-up-regulatory-board-to-monitor-and-manage-ott-platforms
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses plea for direction to set up regulatory board to monitor & manage OTT platforms

SC dismisses plea to set up a regulatory board for OTT platforms, stating the issue falls under policy matters, not for the court to intervene.

19 October, 2024 06:22 PM
a-judges-praise-of-politician-may-affect-publics-trust-in-judiciary-sc-judge-b-r-gavai
Trending Judiciary
A judge's praise of politician may affect public's trust in judiciary: SC judge B R Gavai

SC Judge B R Gavai cautions that judges praising politicians and resigning to contest elections may erode public trust and compromise judicial impartiality.

21 October, 2024 01:34 PM
complainant-cant-insist-on-deciding-plea-to-summon-other-accused-before-cross-examination-sc
Trending Judiciary
Complainant can't insist on deciding plea to summon other accused before cross examination: SC [Read Judgment]

SC rules complainant can’t delay cross-examination to summon others as accused; trial court has discretion on timing under Section 319 CrPC.

21 October, 2024 01:36 PM
sc-dismisses-kejriwals-plea-against-summons-in-defamation-case-on-remarks-on-pms-academic-degree
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses Kejriwal's plea against summons in defamation case on remarks on PM's academic degree

SC dismisses Kejriwal’s plea challenging summons in defamation case over remarks on PM Modi’s degree, upholding Gujarat University’s complaint.

21 October, 2024 05:10 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email