38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, May 21, 2024
Legal Insiders

Mandating Aarogya Setu App Is Illegal: Justice B N Srikrishna

By Ghazal Bhootra      14 May, 2020 12:29 PM      0 Comments
Mandating Aarogya Setu App Is Illegal

Former Supreme Court Judge, Justice B N Srikrishna, who led the committee that released the first draft of the Personal Data Protection Bill, described the government’s aim to make Aarogya Setu app mandatory for everyone as “utterly illegal”.

“Under what law do you mandate it on anyone? So far it is not backed by any law,” said the now-retired judge.

The Ministry of Home Affairs made Aarogya Setu App mandatory for employees of private and public sector offices, in its guideline issued on May 1st, 2020. It required local governments to make sure that there was not a single person who did not have the app on their smartphones in the containment zones as determined by the government. These guidelines were released by the National Executive Committee mandated under the National Disaster Management Act (NDMA), 2005.

The police of Noida then issued a statement that if a person did not have the Aarogya Setu app on their smartphone, it would be punishable with imprisonment (6 months) or a fine (Rs. 1000)

“The Noida police order is totally unlawful. I am assuming this is still a democratic country and such orders can be challenged in court,” said Justice Srikrishna.

Justice Srikrishna mentioned that the guidelines issued by the police cannot be judged as having satisfactory legal backing to mandate the use of the app. “These pieces of legislation — both the National Disaster Management Act and Epidemic Diseases Act — are for a specific reason. The national executive committee in my view is not a statutory body,” he said.

The Supreme Court in the landmark 2017 judgment that recognized the right to privacy as a fundamental right, established a three-pronged evaluation to test if actions taken by the government are constitutional and if they could invade a citizen’s right to privacy. The first condition is defined as “the action taken must be under a law duly passed by Parliament and the government will have to show it had a “legitimate state interest” to violate the right to privacy apart from having considered all less intrusive measures before violating the right.”

On 11th May 2020, the Aarogya Setu Data Access and Knowledge Sharing protocol was released, establishing some principles for the collection and processing of data. The protocol is an “order” by the Empowered Group on Technology and Data Management set up by the National Executive of the Disaster Management Act.

Justice Srikrishna opined that the aforementioned order will not be enough to protect the data. “It is akin to an inter-departmental circular. It is good that they are keeping with the principles of the Personal Data Protection Bill but who will be responsible if there is a breach? It does not say who should be notified,” he said.

In a seminar online organized on 11th May 2020 by Daksha Fellowship, a legal education group, he termed the novel protocol a “patchwork” which will “cause more concern to citizens than benefit.”

“It is highly objectionable that such an order is issued at an executive level. Such an order has to be backed by Parliamentary legislation, which will authorize the government to issue such an order,” said the former judge.

“If it is traced to NDMA, the NDMA has no provision for the constitution of an empowered group. (Under) what provision of law is this order issued? I cannot understand … If there is a breach of data here, who is answerable, what action has to be taken and (who is) accountable for the data breach. This should really have been traced ideally to PDP (Personal Data Protection) or through NDMA by an appropriate amendment,” he said.



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

cannot-allow-the-game-of-hide-and-seek-for-committing-murder-of-an-unborn-child-mp-high-court
Trending Judiciary
Cannot Allow the Game of Hide and Seek for Committing Murder of an Unborn Child: MP High Court [Read Order]

MP High Court denies abortion for minor rape victim, condemns misuse of legal authority to terminate pregnancy and prevent justice.

20 May, 2024 03:52 PM
pune-porsche-hit-and-run-bail-granted-to-17-year-old-in-under-14-hours-asked-to-write-essay
Trending Judiciary
Pune Porsche Hit & Run: Bail Granted to 17 Year Old in Under 14 Hours, Asked to write essay

Bail granted to 17-year-old in Pune Porsche hit-and-run case within 14 hours. Conditions include educational tasks, supervision, and counseling. Incident killed two.

20 May, 2024 04:30 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-rebukes-ima-chief-rejects-apology-for-remarks
Trending Judiciary
SC rebukes IMA chief; rejects apology for remarks

SC rebukes IMA chief R V Asokan; rejects his apology for remarks against the court in contempt proceedings involving Baba Ramdev and Patanjali's MD Acharya Balkrishna.

15 May, 2024 11:02 AM
cant-allow-parole-for-having-procreation-with-live-in-partner-delhi-high-court
Trending Judiciary
Can't allow parole for having procreation with live-in partner: Delhi HC [Read Order]

Delhi HC denied parole for a convict seeking procreation with a live-in partner, stating it would set a harmful precedent, considering his legal marriage and children.

15 May, 2024 12:19 PM
sc-declares-arrest-of-newsclicks-editor-in-chief-prabir-purkayastha-as-invalid
Trending Judiciary
SC declares arrest of Newsclick's Editor-in-Chief Prabir Purkayastha as invalid

SC declares Newsclick Editor-in-chief Prabir Purkayastha's arrest invalid. He was detained in October 2023 under UAPA for alleged pro-China propaganda. SC orders release.

15 May, 2024 12:30 PM
sc-declines-to-entertain-plea-for-direction-to-ec-to-act-against-pm-bjp-leaders
Trending Judiciary
SC declines to entertain plea for direction to EC to act against PM, BJP leaders

SC rejects plea seeking Election Commission action against PM and BJP leaders for alleged hate speeches during elections.

15 May, 2024 12:55 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email