Legislators are allowed to practice law: BCI sub-committee

Legislative Corner Feb 07, 2018 Editor : Shreya Bansal 0 Shares

The expert panel which was constituted by the Bar Council of India to decide whether legislators are allowed to practice law or not has reached a majority decision holding that they can.

Also Read - Indira Jai Singh Suggests Enrolment of (Indian) Foreign Law Graduates Provisionally in Her Letter to Bar Council of India Chairperson

However, Advocate S. Prabhakaran, who was a special invitee in the panel, has differed from the majority view and said that MPs and MLAs cannot practice as lawyers due to their conflict of interest.

The other committee members - B.C. Thakur, R.G. Shah and D.P. Dhal, were of the view that legislators - MPs, MLAs, and MLCs can be allowed to practice.

Also Read - BCI Chairman Calls Outrage over CJI’s Remarks on Rape Cases, “Hue & Cry” as not all those comments result in Orders

Following this, BCI Chairman Manan Kumar Mishra after the General Council meeting has decided to defer the final decision for more thorough and wider consultation and discussion.

Today we discussed the report submitted by the four-member sub-committee. Out of the four honorable members, three (B.C. Thakur, R.G. Shah, D.P. Dhal) were of the view that legislators MPs, MLAs, and MLCs can be allowed to practice. One member S Prabhakaran said they should be debarred on the grounds of conflict of interest and office of profit, Mishra told reporters.

In this view of the matter, the General Council is of the view that the matter needs thorough consideration being a serious issue. Therefore we have deferred the final decision for the next meeting which will be held next week. It is to be noted some of the MPs and MLAs to which we had sent notices had sought eight weeks time for replying. That would also expire next week. So it will meet the end of natural justice before a decision pertaining them is taken. Because they should not say in the end that they were not heard before we took a final decision, said Mishra.

Bar Council was acting on a representation of advocate and Delhi BJP leader Ashwini Upadhyay who argued that MLAs and MPs get salary from the consolidated fund of India, hence, they are employee of the State, and the BCI rule 49 restricts a salaried employee from practicing as advocate.

He also contended that under Prevention of Corruption Act, MLAs and MPs are public servants.

Indira Jai Singh Suggests Enrolment of (Indian) Foreign Law Graduates Provisionally in Her Letter to Bar Council of India Chairperson

Indira Jai Singh Foreign Law Graduates BCI

Legal Insiders Apr 16, 2021 Tanya Sehrawat ( Editor: Ekta Joshi ) 44 Shares

Senior Advocate, Indira Jai Singh drew some light on how foreign law graduates face difficulties as their results of qualifying exams get delayed. Thereafter, she requested the Chairperson of the Bar Council of India to consider providing these students with provisional enrolment by laying down conditions as the BCI deems fit. In her letter, Singh said, "I have received many distress calls, from graduates who have been waiting for the last one year to be enrolled as Advocates in India...

Read full post

BCI Chairman Calls Outrage over CJI’s Remarks on Rape Cases, “Hue & Cry” as not all those comments result in Orders

Legal Insiders Mar 08, 2021 Tanya Sehrawat ( Editor: Ekta Joshi ) 56 Shares

Manan Kumar Mishra, Chairman of the Bar Council of India recently issued a press release on Thursday (March 4, 2021), which read, “It has become a fashion for some motivated people to make personal aspersions against our Judges. If this trend is allowed to continue, the Institution will lose its sanctity.”This statement was issued pertaining denunciation of remarks of Chief Justice SA Bobde when he asked the accused if he would marry the survivor in a rape case in its anticipatory bail...

Read full post