38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, August 23, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Political NEWS

Delhi HC refuses to entertain Shibu Soren's plea for quashing of disproportionate assets complaint by Nishikant Dubey [Read Judgment]

By Shreya Agarwal      23 January, 2024 07:40 PM      0 Comments

NEW DELHI: The Delhi High Court has refused to entertain a petition by Rajya Sabha MP and Jharkhand Mukti Morcha President Shibu Soren wherein he sought quashing of a disproportionate assets complaint filed against him with the Lokpal of India.

The Court held that it "does not want to enter into this realm at this juncture and it is for the Lokpal to take a decision as to whether there is sufficient material to proceed further for investigation or not."

Soren had moved Court seeking relief against a complaint filed against him by BJPs Lok Sabha MP Nishikant Dubey from Godda, Jharkhand.

The complaint alleges that Soren in his name and in the name of his family members including sons, daughters, daughters-in-law, friends, associates and various companies etc. has acquired about 80 immovable properties including plots of lands (residential, commercial and built up properties) in various districts of Jharkhand such as Ranchi, Dhanbad, Dumka etc.

Inter alia Dubey alleges that Soren has acquired properties completely disproportionate to his known sources of income and has been indulging in corrupt practices for many years and has illegally usurped huge portions of the lands belonging to poor tribals of the Santhal tribe at throwaway prices much below the prevailing circle rates.

Soren challenged the complaint and various orders passed therein primarily contending that the complaint itself ought not to have been entertained by the Lokpal since it is hit by Section 53 of the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013.

He also contended that the time limit mentioned in the Act has not been complied with in the enquiry process.

The Court noted that it was only to decide whether while exercising its discretion under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before the report is considered by the Lokpal, the Court should dismiss the complaint on the ground that it is hit by Section 53 of the Act or not, or whether all the contentions raised before this Court should be advanced before the Lokpal in the inquiry to be held under Section 20(3) of the Act or not.

It reasoned that the whole purpose of the Act is to ensure purity in public service.

In the process of statutory construction, the court must construe the Act before it and the attempt should always be to further the approach of the Act and to make it workable, it wrote.

The single judge bench of Justice Subramonium Prasad reasoned, The Lokpal is yet to apply its mind on the material provided by the CBI as to whether an investigation is necessary or not. It is well settled that while conducting an inquiry, the material that can be unearthed is limited compared to the material that is unearthed when an investigation is conducted by a competent authority.

It is well settled that writ courts while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India do not interfere if the matter is pending adjudication before an authority unless it is a case of patent lack of jurisdiction or where the nature of inquiry is for allegations which are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can reach a just conclusion or where the proceedings have been initiated are so manifestly attended with malice or the proceedings are initiated with the intention of wrecking vengeance on a person with a view to spite him due to any political or oblique motives," the Court said.

It then went on to reject Sorens contention that the entire complaint is completely motivated and Lokpal would invariably order for investigation.

Stating that, the Office of Lokpal is completely independent and an argument that the Lokpal would be influenced by political consideration cannot be countenanced. This allegation that the proceedings before the Lokpal is vitiated and can be politically motivated, cannot be accepted, the Court disposed of Sorens plea.

Cause Title: Shibu Soren v Lokpal of India & Anr

 

[Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:

A wanderer, aspiring yogini and writer. Shreya is a lawyer by profession, journalist by passion. A g...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

TMC's Mahua Moitra expelled from Lok Sabha over cash-for-query charges TMC's Mahua Moitra expelled from Lok Sabha over cash-for-query charges

Here's what Mahua Moitra said after her expulsion as TMC MP.

"May lead to political violence, hatred; seeks to polarize voters": Kerala High Court PIL against 26 opposition parties' use of 'I.N.D.I.A' "May lead to political violence, hatred; seeks to polarize voters": Kerala High Court PIL against 26 opposition parties' use of 'I.N.D.I.A'

A public interest litigation petition has been filed before the Kerala High Court to restrain the political alliance consisting of 26 opposition parties from using the acronym I.N.D.I.A (Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance) for the upcoming assembly and parliament elections.

What is Post Office Bill, 2023? Are there any privacy concerns? What is Post Office Bill, 2023? Are there any privacy concerns?

New Post Office Bill infringes right to privacy? Here's all you need to know the Bill.

UP govt objects before SC plea by gangster-politician to shift to non-BJP ruled state UP govt objects before SC plea by gangster-politician to shift to non-BJP ruled state

The Uttar Pradesh government on Wednesday objected before Supreme Court a plea made for shifting gangster-politician Mukhar Ansari lodged in Banda jail "to a state ruled by a party other than the BJP".

TRENDING NEWS

if-governor-does-not-declare-on-withholding-assent-for-time-immemorial-court-still-powerless-sc-poser-to-centre
Trending Judiciary
If Governor does not declare on withholding assent for time immemorial, court still powerless, SC poser to Centre

SC asks if Governor can withhold assent to Bills indefinitely, raising concern that legislature may be rendered defunct without judicial remedy.

22 August, 2025 12:41 PM
sc-widens-scope-of-suo-motu-hearing-on-stray-dogs-menace-suspends-previous-order-against-relocation
Trending Judiciary
SC widens scope of suo motu hearing on stray dogs menace; suspends previous order against relocation

SC expands stray dogs case to pan-India, suspends earlier relocation order; allows release after vaccination, bans unregulated feeding.

22 August, 2025 01:06 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-dismisses-plea-against-quashing-fir-in-case-of-suicide
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses plea against quashing FIR in case of suicide of then MP Mohan Delkar

SC dismisses plea against quashing of FIR in ex-MP Mohan Delkar suicide case; Bombay HC’s 2022 order stands, no interference by Supreme Court.

18 August, 2025 12:21 PM
no-automatic-arrest-on-rejection-of-anticipatory-bail-supreme-court
Trending Judiciary
No Automatic Arrest on Rejection of Anticipatory Bail: Supreme Court [Read Order]

SC clarifies that rejection of anticipatory bail doesn’t mean automatic arrest; custody depends on investigation, conduct, and case facts.

18 August, 2025 12:27 PM
court-holds-surgeon-guilty-of-indulging-in-black-magic-during-hearing-sentenced-till-rising-of-court
Trending Judiciary
Court holds Surgeon guilty of indulging in black magic during hearing; sentenced till rising of court [Read Order]

Delhi court convicts surgeon for disrupting proceedings with ‘black magic’; sentenced till rising of court with ₹2,000 fine after apology.

18 August, 2025 12:40 PM
want-bravehearts-to-be-in-forces-sc-for-giving-insurance-cover-to-cadets-discharged-during-military-training
Trending Judiciary
'Want bravehearts to be in forces,' SC for giving insurance cover to cadets discharged during military training

SC seeks insurance cover, rehab and higher aid for cadets injured during military training, stressing need to support bravehearts joining armed forces.

18 August, 2025 04:00 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email