38.6c New Delhi, India, Wednesday, November 06, 2024
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Business

Supreme Court Directs Airtel To Move To Alternate Forum For Videocon Dues

By Shahista Ansari      26 August, 2021 12:27 PM      0 Comments
Supreme Court Directs Airtel To Move To Alternate Forum For Videocon Dues

On Tuesday, 24th August 2021, the Supreme Court allowed Bharti Airtel to move to an alternate forum against the directions issued to it by DOT(department of telecommunications) to pay the AGR (adjusted gross revenue)dues of Videocon Telecommunications ltd.

Videocon had sold its spectrum to Airtel in 2016. The issue arises from the interpretation given by the Supreme Court in its October 2019 judgment to the term "Adjusted Gross Revenue" in the spectrum licensing agreements between telecom companies and the DoT. The license fee is computed based on AGR. 

The Supreme Court held that 'AGR' includes revenue from non-telecom operations of the companies like rent, profit on sale of fixed assets, dividend and treasury income. This resulted in an additional liability to the tune of Rs 92,000 crores on the telecom companies collectively.

A bench comprising of  justices L NAGESWARA RAO,ABDUL NAZEER,MR SHAH has been set up to hear the plea filed by Bharti Airtel to restrain the Department of Telecommunications from demanding AGR (adjusted gross revenues)dues of Videocon ltd from it.

Senior advocate Shyam Divan,appearing for Airtel submitted that according to the spectrum trading guidelines the liabilities of a telecom company before the sale of its spectrum are to be borne by it only and not by the subsequent purchaser. Therefore, the AGR dues of Videocon before it sold its spectrum to Airtel cannot be recovered from Airtel. 

Divan pointed that the order passed by the Supreme Court in September 2020 had also stated that the dues of a telecom service company existing before the sale of spectrum are to be borne by the seller and not the buyer.

Another point raised by Divan was that by adding the dues of Videocon to the demand made from Airtel, the DoT has violated the Supreme Court's order that AGR dues cannot be recalculated or reassessed.

Therefore the bench said that it will grant liberty to Airtel to move any other alternate forum to redress its grievances. Responding to a query from the bench, Divan said that the alternate forum will be the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal(TDSAT).


But the solicitor general Tussar Mehta submitted that it is the case of the DoT that the TDSAT has no jurisdiction to deal with the matter. He requested the bench to keep all contentions open.


Divan also sought for an order restraining the DoT from invoking the bank guarantees. In this regard, he submitted that Airtel has paid so far over Rs 18,000 crores, which is more than 10% of its total AGR dues to the tune of Rs 45,000, which it had to pay by March, 2021 as per the Supreme court order. 

 CONCLUSION

Ultimately, the bench allowed Airtel to withdraw the application with liberty to approach the alternate forum, and restrained the DoT from invoking its bank guarantee for 3 weeks starting from Tuesday 24th august 2021. 
 



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

patna-hc-expands-insurance-liability-for-paid-drivers-and-cleaners-under-motor-vehicles-act
Trending Judiciary
Patna HC expands insurance liability for paid drivers and cleaners under Motor Vehicles Act [Read Judgment]

Patna High Court rules insurers liable for paid drivers and cleaners with additional premium, emphasizing Motor Vehicles Act provisions on extended coverage.

05 November, 2024 10:20 AM
sc-upholds-validity-of-up-madrasas-act-allows-state-to-regulate-such-institutions
Trending Judiciary
SC upholds validity of UP Madrasas Act, allows state to regulate such institutions [Read Order]

SC upholds UP Madrasas Act, affirming state’s role in regulating educational standards while balancing minority rights and secularism in education.

05 November, 2024 01:56 PM

TOP STORIES

scba-scaora-strongly-condemn-ghaziabad-court-incident
Trending Judiciary
SCBA, SCAORA strongly condemn Ghaziabad court incident [Read SCBA, SCAORA Resolution]

SCBA, SCAORA condemn Ghaziabad court incident, demand inquiry, dismissal of judge, police, and Advocate Protection Act to prevent future violence.

04 November, 2024 11:18 AM
bail-conditions-must-be-fair-reasonable-cannot-tantamount-to-deprivation-of-civil-rights-sc
Trending Judiciary
Bail conditions must be fair, reasonable; cannot tantamount to deprivation of civil rights: SC [Read Judgment]

SC asserts that bail conditions must be fair and reasonable, ensuring accused’s presence without infringing civil rights, overturns Madhya Pradesh HC’s excessive terms.

04 November, 2024 11:55 AM
sc-declines-interim-relief-to-death-row-convict-rajoana-gives-two-weeks-to-punjab-to-file-response-to-plea-on-delay-in-mercy-petition
Trending Judiciary
SC declines interim relief to death row convict Rajoana; gives two weeks to Punjab to file response to plea on delay in mercy petition

SC denies interim relief to death row convict Rajoana; grants Punjab two weeks to respond on plea over delay in mercy petition. Next hearing on Nov 18.

04 November, 2024 03:56 PM
sc-modifies-bail-condition-to-report-to-local-police-station-every-week-for-kerala-journalist-sidhique-kappan
Trending Judiciary
SC modifies bail condition to report to local police station every week for Kerala journalist Sidhique Kappan

SC relaxes bail condition for Kerala journalist Sidhique Kappan, removing weekly police station visits in UAPA case linked to Hathras incident.

04 November, 2024 05:16 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email