Karnataka Quashes the NLSIU Amendment Act; States the Act is Contrary to the Parent Act

Executive Oct 01, 2020 Meghna Mishra ( Editor: Ekta Joshi ) 1 Shares

On September 30 2020, the Karnataka High Court quashed the National Law School of India University (NLSIU) Amendment Act, 2020. The Amendment Act guaranteed a 25 % reservation for students who had a state domicile. The order for quashing the amendment act was passed by a Division Bench that comprised of Hon’ble Justices BV Nagarathna and Ravi V Hosmani. The order was passed amidst a batch of pleas that challenged the 25 % Domicile reservation of the Premiere Bangalore College. While passing the order, the Bench held that the NLSIU Amendment Act, 2020 was ultra-virus and contrary to the provisions of the parent act.

The order passed by the Division Court read, “For the aforesaid reasons, the impugned reservation (under NLSIU Amendment Act) is struck down as the intelligible differentia has no nexus to the object sought to be achieved and therefore, does not meet the twin tests under Article 14 of the Constitution.”

Also Read - HC Directs NUALS to consider Granting 100% Waiver on Fees for Gym & Bus Facility Until Resumption of Physical Classes

Further, the Court opined that the State Government is not empowered to enact the Amendment Act. To upheld this, the Court added, “By this, we do not mean that it does not have the legislative competence under Schedule VII of the Constitution of India...We note that the state did not retain or reserve any role for itself in the matter of administration, management, and control of the Law School. Thus, the Amendment is ultra vires the Act.”

The court made a note that stated that while NLSIU might be an autonomous and independent entity. It has an “all India national character”. The Court also referred to the parent Act and stated that the power to introduce reservation lied only with the Executive Council of NLSIU. The court further opined that the NLSIU is not on par with other law schools there is a multitude of differences including its curriculum, reservation policy, control of Bar Council of India, trimester system, manner of incorporation, Chancellor being Chief Justice of India, etc.

Also Read - Law Students Move Delhi High Court Seeking Transparency in NLU- D’s Moot Court Competition; Seek Disclosure of Competition Records and Marks Secured [READ PETITION]

Further, the court held that due to the lack of scientific data validating the reservation, the policy serves no purpose along with being contrary to the objects to the objects of the law school.

However, in its order, the court stated that it shall not interfere with the decision to increase the seats for the undergraduate course of the college. The court has also directed NLSIU to comply with the timeline for admission of CLAT students.

HC Directs NUALS to consider Granting 100% Waiver on Fees for Gym & Bus Facility Until Resumption of Physical Classes

Judiciary Oct 29, 2020 Twinkle Agarwal ( Editor: Ekta Joshi ) 8 Shares

A writ petition was filed by the students of the National University of Advanced Legal Studies (NUALS) for granting them 100% concession on Gym and bus fees during this pandemic. They were of the opinion that in this pandemic the families are already undergoing financial problems and the institution is asking them to deposit fees permitting them to do so in installment. The students are not attending their physical classes and therefore those fees are not justified. In response to the...

Read full post

Law Students Move Delhi High Court Seeking Transparency in NLU- D’s Moot Court Competition; Seek Disclosure of Competition Records and Marks Secured [READ PETITION]

Legal Insiders Oct 19, 2020 Pavitra Shetty ( Editor: Ekta Joshi ) 3 Shares

A petition has been filed before the bench of Justice Jayant Nath in Delhi High Court for issuing a direction upon the Moot Court Organizing Committee of National Law University, Delhi (NLU) to release the marks obtained by the Petitioners in the moot court competition.The Petitioners are students of University Law College (ULC) Utkal University, Bhubaneshwar who had participated in the National Moot Court Competition organized by National Law University, Delhi. Debashish Kumar Panda, Deep...

Read full post