38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, September 27, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Criminal trial acquittal must influence disciplinary actions with identical charges: Calcutta HC [Read Order]

By Saket Sourav      04 September, 2024 03:10 PM      0 Comments
Criminal trial acquittal must influence disciplinary actions with identical charges Calcutta HC

Kolkata: The Calcutta High Court has delivered a significant judgment emphasizing that the outcome of a criminal trial should influence disciplinary proceedings, particularly when the charges are identical or closely related.

A Division Bench comprising Justices Tapabrata Chakraborty and Partha Sarathi Chatterjee made this observation while deciding a writ petition filed by Subal Makhal against the Indian Red Cross Society and others.

The court noted that the petitioner, a Group-D employee of the Indian Red Cross Society, was removed from service in 2008 following disciplinary proceedings initiated in 1995. He was later acquitted in a related criminal case in 2013.

Highlighting the importance of considering criminal trial outcomes, the court held, “The findings regarding the allegations in the disciplinary proceeding stood contradicted by the findings of the court in the criminal trial, and only thereafter could the petitioner have filed the application for review of the order of removal.”

The court observed that the charges in both the disciplinary proceedings and the criminal trial were almost identical, centering around an alleged act of breach of trust. It found that the petitioner was acquitted in the criminal trial after full consideration of the evidence.

Expressing its view on the impact of criminal acquittal on disciplinary proceedings, the court stated, “Mere suspicion should not be allowed to take the place of proof, even in domestic inquiries. It may be that the technical rules which govern criminal trials in courts may not necessarily apply to disciplinary proceedings, but nevertheless, the principle that in punishing the guilty, scrupulous care must be taken to ensure that the innocent are not punished, applies as much to regular criminal trials as to disciplinary inquiries held under statutory rules.”

The court directed a modification of the punishment from removal to a reduction in pay scale for two years, deeming the petitioner reinstated with continuity of service. It also ordered the payment of 50% back wages and all retirement benefits.

[Read Order]



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Birbhum Massacre: NHRC Takes Suo Motu Cognisance, Directs State Gov To Submit Detailed Report Within 4 Weeks Birbhum Massacre: NHRC Takes Suo Motu Cognisance, Directs State Gov To Submit Detailed Report Within 4 Weeks

According to reports, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Thursday met the families of the victims and announced Rs 2 lakh compensation for rebuilding the scorched homes. Promising jobs to ten families affected by the violence, Banerjee added that she would ensure "speedy justice".

Supreme Court Rejects West Bengal's Plea Against CBI Probe in Linked Municipality and Teachers' Recruitment Scam Supreme Court Rejects West Bengal's Plea Against CBI Probe in Linked Municipality and Teachers' Recruitment Scam

Supreme Court dismisses West Bengal's plea against CBI probe into municipality recruitment scam linked with teachers' recruitment irregularities. Abhishek Banerjee, TMC MP, faces setback as court refuses interference.

Calcutta High Court conducts late-evening hearing, orders release of lawyer arrested inside court [Read Order] Calcutta High Court conducts late-evening hearing, orders release of lawyer arrested inside court [Read Order]

After holding a late-evening hearing due to unprecedented events, a division bench of the Calcutta High Court stayed an order which directed a lawyers arrest inside the court on charges of contempt of court.

Indian Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [Jan 1 - Jan 6] Indian Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [Jan 1 - Jan 6]

A weekly round-up of the top stories from the Supreme Court of India and High Courts across the country summed up in a 3-minute read.

TRENDING NEWS

sc-permits-ramlila-at-school-playground-in-up
Trending Judiciary
SC permits Ramlila at school playground in UP

SC allows Ramlila at UP school ground, noting 100-year tradition, but urges finding alternate sites to keep playgrounds free for students.

26 September, 2025 12:08 AM
sc-stays-hcs-order-on-composition-of-sit-formed-to-probe-tirupati-parasadam-row
Trending Judiciary
SC stays HC's order on composition of SIT formed to probe Tirupati parasadam row

SC stays Andhra Pradesh HC order on SIT composition in Tirupati prasadam row, clarifying CBI Director’s role in appointing investigation officer.

26 September, 2025 07:53 PM

TOP STORIES

calcutta-hc-dismisses-plea-against-bengali-singer-for-allegedly-insulting-lord-ram-cites-lack-of-evidence
Trending Judiciary
Calcutta HC Dismisses Plea Against Bengali Singer For Allegedly Insulting Lord Ram, Cites Lack of Evidence [Read Judgment]

Calcutta HC dismisses plea against singer Nachiketa Chakraborty over alleged remarks on Lord Ram, citing lack of evidence and jurisdiction.

22 September, 2025 10:43 AM
allahabad-hc-slams-police-for-recording-caste-of-accused-in-firs-terms-it-identity-profiling
Trending Judiciary
Allahabad HC Slams Police for Recording Caste of Accused in FIRs, Terms It “Identity Profiling” [Read Order]

Allahabad HC condemns police for recording caste of accused in FIRs, calling it identity profiling that violates fundamental rights and constitutional values.

22 September, 2025 11:04 AM
spouse-may-claim-damages-for-marital-interference-by-third-party-delhi-hc
Trending Judiciary
Spouse May Claim Damages for Marital Interference by Third Party: Delhi HC [Read Order]

Delhi HC allows spouse to sue lover for ‘alienation of affection’, recognizing civil action for intentional interference in marriage.

22 September, 2025 01:06 PM
sc-notice-to-centre-others-on-plea-for-court-monitored-probe-into-air-india-crash
Trending Judiciary
SC notice to Centre, others on plea for court-monitored probe into Air India crash

SC issues notice on plea for court-monitored probe into Air India crash that killed 260; petitioner seeks independent, transparent, and fair investigation.

22 September, 2025 02:27 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email