38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, July 13, 2024
Judiciary

For Indians, it's a George Floyd moment: the Delhi High Court has ruled that the imposition of IGST on personal oxygen concentrators is 'unconstitutional'

By Kartikey Garg      25 May, 2021 09:06 PM      0 Comments
For Indians, it's a George Floyd moment: the Delhi High Court has ruled that the imposition of IGST on personal oxygen concentrators is 'unconstitutional'

The imposition of a 12 percent Integrated Goods and Service Tax (IGST) on oxygen concentrators for personal use or as gifts, according to the Delhi High Court, is "unconstitutional." 

In a different setting, a bench consisting of Justice Rajiv Shakdher and Justice Talwant Singh said this is a George Floyd moment for the citizens of the country, where several of them were gasping for air due to a lack of medical oxygen.

The court overturned the Union finance ministry's May 1 notification imposing a 12 percent IGST on concentrators imported for personal use, regardless of whether they were a gift or not, stating that the "virus has brought out the best and worst in people."

“We have messiahs,” says the narrator. There are charlatans among us. There are hoarders in our midst. Strangers have reached out with a kind and caring hand when they could have remained cocooned in the safety of their homes. In its 33-page order, the court noted, "Brave hearts, there are many doctors, nurses, and personnel manning public institutions."

The decision was based on a petition filed by advocate Siddharth Bambha on behalf of an 85-year-old Covid-19 patient who challenged the imposition of a 12 percent IGST on oxygen concentrators after his nephew sent them to him as a gift from the United States. To prevent the misuse of oxygen concentrators for commercial purposes, the court ordered that anyone importing concentrators for personal use or as a gift must provide a letter of undertaking to the Centre's designated officer stating that the device will not be used for commercial purposes.

On Monday (May 3, 2021) the finance ministry issued a notification in response to the petition, exempting IGST on oxygen concentrators received as donations or gifts for the state government, or if purchased through a canalising agency. Individuals, on the other hand, were not included in the exemption list. For the petitioners, senior advocate Sudhir Nandrajog and advocate Bambha argued that such a distinction was unconstitutional. According to the court, such a distinction is "arbitrary," "unreasonable," and in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution.



Share this article:



Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

bombay-high-court-denies-interim-relief-in-plea-against-1-year-pan-masala-ban
Trending Judiciary
Bombay High Court denies interim relief in plea against 1 year Pan Masala Ban [Read Order]

Bombay High Court denies interim relief to petitioners challenging the 1-year ban on pan masala, citing arguable questions and ongoing similar cases.

12 July, 2024 10:00 AM
sc-collegium-recommends-appointment-of-chief-justices-of-eight-high-courts
Trending Judiciary
SC Collegium recommends appointment of Chief Justices of eight High Courts [Read Order]

SC Collegium recommends appointments of Chief Justices for Delhi, Himachal Pradesh, J&K, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Madras, and Meghalaya High Courts.

12 July, 2024 10:55 AM

TOP STORIES

sc-to-hear-various-pleas-challenging-neet-ug-exam-today
Trending Judiciary
SC to Hear Various Pleas Challenging NEET-UG Exam Today

The Supreme Court will hear pleas challenging the NEET-UG exam today, with students raising concerns over malpractice and irregularities in the 2024 test.

08 July, 2024 10:23 AM
courts-cant-ask-accused-to-share-google-pin-location-as-bail-condition-sc
Trending Judiciary
Courts can't ask accused to share Google PIN location as bail condition: SC

Courts can't mandate sharing Google PIN location as bail condition, protecting privacy rights: Supreme Court. Decision overturns Delhi HC's bail condition requiring Google PIN sharing.

08 July, 2024 12:13 PM
madhya-pradesh-hc-quashes-fir-in-rape-case-rules-consensual-relationship-cannot-be-termed-rape
Trending Judiciary
Madhya Pradesh HC quashes FIR in rape case, rules consensual relationship cannot be termed rape [Read Order]

Madhya Pradesh HC quashes FIR in rape case, ruling consensual relationship between adults, even if promise of marriage is broken, cannot be termed rape.

08 July, 2024 12:47 PM
uttarakhand-hc-seeks-state’s-response-on-arresting-minors-found-dating
Trending Judiciary
Uttarakhand HC seeks State’s response on arresting minors found dating [Read Order]

Uttarakhand High Court seeks the state's response on arresting minors found dating, suggesting alternatives like counseling and statement recording.

08 July, 2024 01:34 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email