38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, October 31, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Dlhi High Court dismisses medical negligence petition, emphasises reasonable care standard Read Judgment]

By Saket Sourav      06 January, 2025 02:07 AM      0 Comments
Delhi High Court dismisses medical negligence petition emphasises reasonable care standard

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has dismissed a petition alleging medical negligence against doctors at Max Super Speciality Hospital, Patparganj, emphasizing that medical negligence cannot be established merely by dissatisfaction or an assertion of an “expected” standard of care.

Delhi High Court Ruling: Medical Negligence Allegations Against Max Hospital Dismissed

Justice Sanjeev Narula delivered a comprehensive judgment addressing allegations of medical negligence in the treatment of a patient who ultimately passed away.

The court addressed the case of Shiv Kumar, who alleged medical negligence against doctors at Max Hospital in the treatment of his wife, Late Smt. Kamini Gupta. The court noted:

“The instant case emerges from serious allegations of medical negligence and misconduct levelled against Respondent doctors at Max Super Speciality Hospital, Patparganj, Delhi.”

Understanding Reasonable Care: Key Takeaways from Delhi HC’s Judgment on Medical Negligence

Addressing the standard for medical negligence, the court observed:

“Medical negligence is not established by mere dissatisfaction or the assertion of an ‘expected’ standard of care. Instead, the yardstick is whether the doctor’s conduct and opinion fell below that of a reasonably competent practitioner in similar circumstances.”

The court highlighted the importance of findings by expert medical bodies, stating:

“The findings of medical bodies, composed of experts in the field, carry considerable weight. Their determinations, supported by peer review, merit deference unless tainted by palpable perversity or illegality.”

The court examined various allegations, including delays in treatment, excessive drug dosage, and unavailability of ICU beds, but found no evidence of negligence. It noted:

“The consistent view of both the DMC and NMC points toward the line of treatment provided considering the patient’s complex medical profile, rather than by professional misconduct.”

In response to the petition, the court rejected it, concluding:

“While the Court empathises with the Petitioner’s loss and appreciates the earnestness of his pursuit, it must emphasize that the findings of medical bodies, composed of experts in the field, carry considerable weight.”

The court effectively set a precedent for evaluating medical negligence cases, emphasizing the need to assess conduct against reasonable professional standards rather than idealized expectations.

Legal Representation:
For the petitioner: Mr. Vinay Rathi, Mr. Pratham Sharma, and Ms. Ashima Jayal.

For the National Medical Commission: Mr. T. Singhdev and others.

For the Delhi Medical Council: Mr. Praveen Khattar.

Case title: Shiv Kumar vs. National Medical Commission & Ors.



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

'Without documentary proof, Waqf Board can't lay claim over any property' 'Without documentary proof, Waqf Board can't lay claim over any property'

In 2012, the Anjuman Committee addressed a letter to the Chairman of the Waqf Board stating there is a wall and Chabutrah (platform) on a 'Tiranga Ki Qalandari Masjid where in olden times laborers used to offer prayers.

Delhi High Court Sets Aside Arbitral Tribunal's Award Against NHAI in Highway Project Delay Case [Read Judgment] Delhi High Court Sets Aside Arbitral Tribunal's Award Against NHAI in Highway Project Delay Case [Read Judgment]

The Delhi High Court sets aside an Arbitral Tribunal's award favoring IRB Pathankot Amritsar Toll Road Ltd over a delay in a highway project. The court finds that the tribunal did not address the essential dispute of whether the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) was in material default, rendering the award invalid.

Delhi Court Rejects Stay Request in Defamation Case Against Rajasthan CM Ashok Gehlot [Read Order] Delhi Court Rejects Stay Request in Defamation Case Against Rajasthan CM Ashok Gehlot [Read Order]

A Delhi court refuses to stay the defamation case filed by Union Cabinet minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat against Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot. The court declined to stay the summons and sets a hearing date for August 19.

Delhi High Court to Commence Daily Hearings on August 28 for Appeals Against Acquittals in 2G Case Delhi High Court to Commence Daily Hearings on August 28 for Appeals Against Acquittals in 2G Case

Delhi High Court is set to begin day-to-day hearings from August 28 for appeals by CBI and ED against acquittals in the 2G spectrum allocation case, expressing displeasure over adjournment requests. The case involves former telecom minister A Raja and business entities. Learn about the proceedings and details of the case.

TRENDING NEWS

sc-hints-at-pan-india-guidelines-on-timeline-to-frame-charges
Trending Judiciary
SC hints at pan-India guidelines on timeline to frame charges

SC mulls pan-India guidelines to curb delays in framing charges; notes cases where charges aren’t framed even after years despite BNSS mandate of 60 days.

30 October, 2025 12:22 PM
limitation-for-continuous-breach-runs-only-till-contract-expiry-kerala-hc-clarifies
Trending Judiciary
Limitation for Continuous Breach Runs Only Till Contract Expiry: Kerala High Court Clarifies [Read Judgment]

Kerala HC clarifies that for continuous breach of contract, limitation under Article 55 starts when breach ceases; once contract ends, breach cannot continue.

30 October, 2025 01:37 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-quashes-uapa-arrests-holds-remand-courts-explanation-cannot-replace-written-grounds-of-arrest
Trending Judiciary
SC Quashes UAPA Arrests, Holds Remand Court’s Explanation Cannot Replace Written Grounds Of Arrest [Read Order]

Supreme Court quashes UAPA arrests, ruling that remand court’s explanation cannot substitute the mandatory written grounds of arrest.

25 October, 2025 11:10 AM
ngt-orders-probe-into-illegal-tree-felling-in-delhis-civil-lines-directs-action-within-three-months
Trending Environment
NGT Orders Probe into Illegal Tree Felling in Delhi’s Civil Lines, Directs Action Within Three Months [Read Order]

NGT directs Tree Officer to probe illegal tree felling in Delhi’s Civil Lines and take action under the Delhi Preservation of Trees Act, 1994.

25 October, 2025 11:28 AM
gauhati-hc-quashes-fir-against-cnn-news18-anchor-akansha-swarup-over-kamakhya-temple-remarks
Trending CelebStreet
Gauhati HC Quashes FIR Against CNN-News18 Anchor Akansha Swarup Over Kamakhya Temple Remarks [Read Order]

Gauhati HC quashes FIR against CNN-News18 anchor Akansha Swarup, ruling her Kamakhya Temple remarks were careless but lacked malicious intent.

25 October, 2025 11:43 AM
delhi-hc-upholds-divorce-on-cruelty-grounds-denies-alimony-to-financially-independent-wife
Trending Judiciary
Delhi HC Upholds Divorce On Cruelty Grounds, Denies Alimony To Financially Independent Wife [Read Judgment]

Delhi HC upholds divorce on cruelty grounds, denies alimony to IRTS officer wife, ruling that alimony is for need-based justice, not enrichment.

25 October, 2025 12:10 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email