38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, December 10, 2024
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Kerala HC quashes charges against mother in law in dowry case, warns against misuse of sec 498A IPC [Read Order]

By Saket Sourav      03 June, 2024 11:36 AM      0 Comments
Kerala HC quashes charges against mother in law in dowry case warns against misuse of sec 498A IPC

Kerala: The Kerala High Court recently held that many women misuse Section 498A of IPC against their husbands and their relatives to defame them in society. "It is noticed that in matrimonial disputes, certain wives initiate criminal proceedings on the strength of vague and omnibus allegations against the parents, sisters, brothers, and other relatives of the husband with ulterior motives to put them under the veil of prosecution involving non-bailable offenses and to make the parents, sisters, brothers, and other relatives of the husband face the ordeal of criminal prosecution and trial, to malign and defame their image in society," the court said.

The court also held that in cases where no specific allegations are made, prima facie, such cases shall be quashed by the High Court by invoking power under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C.

FACTS:

The present Criminal Miscellaneous Case was filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for quashing criminal proceedings initiated by a woman against her 61-year-old mother-in-law on allegations of committing cruelty and demanding dowry. The main allegation against the petitioner in the FIR was that she was a spectator when her husband was beating and persecuting the complainant and did not interfere. There are also allegations that she abetted the continuous physical and mental cruelty inflicted by her husband on the complainant.

ARGUMENTS:

The counsel for the petitioner argued that she should not be prosecuted under Section 498A of the IPC as the prosecution materials do not suggest any overt acts by her to attract the ingredients of the offense. It was also argued that, as per the FIR, the only allegation against her is that she became a spectator while the complainant was persecuted by her husband and she did not interfere to stop it. Further, the counsel relied on Achin Gupta v. State of Haryana, wherein the Supreme Court held that the courts must appreciate the materials and all quarrels must be weighed from that point of view in determining what constitutes cruelty in each particular case. It was contended that the case against the petitioner was liable to be quashed.

Per contra, the counsel for the de facto complainant and the Public Prosecutor opposed the contentions raised by the petitioners and argued that the FIR itself contained specific allegations against the petitioner. Further, they also pointed to the statements of the complainant's mother and father, which alleged that the petitioner also persecuted the complainant, demanding more dowry. It was argued that these materials were sufficient to proceed to trial against the petitioner.

DECISION:

The court, after hearing both parties, held that only general and sweeping allegations were made against the petitioner without bringing on record any specific instance of cruelty at her instance, which is the substratum on which she got arraigned as an accused. The court observed that the allegations against the petitioner were merely omnibus in nature, stating that she abetted the crime without specifying any overt acts or providing certainty about how she ill-treated or persecuted the complainant. Furthermore, the court noted that the statements of the complainant's mother and father, which accused the petitioner of demanding dowry and mistreating the complainant, were hearsay and not based on direct knowledge or experience of the events.

In conclusion, the court quashed the charges against the petitioner and directed the trial court to expedite the trial against her husband. 

 

[Read Order]



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

'Only a Woman Knows How Difficult it is to Balance Motherhood and Career' : Kerala High Court Reinstates Woman Fired for Availing Maternity Leave 'Only a Woman Knows How Difficult it is to Balance Motherhood and Career' : Kerala High Court Reinstates Woman Fired for Availing Maternity Leave

"The mother's constant proximity to the child has been scientifically proven to be absolutely irreplaceable, which is why, among other things, maternity leave provisions are now internationally accepted," it further added. Kerala high court, Kerala high court order, Kerala high court judgement, Kerala high court chief justice, Motherhood and Career

Kerala HC Quashes 498A Dowry Harassment Case Against Live-In Partner, Citing Lack of Relative Status [Read Order] Kerala HC Quashes 498A Dowry Harassment Case Against Live-In Partner, Citing Lack of Relative Status [Read Order]

Read about a recent judgment by the Kerala High Court that quashed a dowry harassment case against a woman in a live-in relationship. The court ruled that she couldn't be considered a relative under Section 498A of the IPC, highlighting the importance of precise legal definitions.

Watching porn on mobile: Kerala HC highlights importance of mother cooked meals, outdoor sports [Read Order] Watching porn on mobile: Kerala HC highlights importance of mother cooked meals, outdoor sports [Read Order]

Kerala High Court emphasizes the importance of outdoor sports, home-cooked meals, and parental supervision, discouraging the gifting of mobile phones to minors. Learn why the court quashed a case related to private porn viewing and the need for responsible parenting.

Lakshadweep MP Mohammed Faizal Disqualified from Lok Sabha After Conviction Suspension Plea Rejected by Kerala High Court [Read Notice] Lakshadweep MP Mohammed Faizal Disqualified from Lok Sabha After Conviction Suspension Plea Rejected by Kerala High Court [Read Notice]

Lakshadweep MP Mohammed Faizal PP faces disqualification from Lok Sabha as Kerala High Court rejects plea to suspend his conviction in an attempt to murder case. Get the latest updates on his legal battle.

TRENDING NEWS

you-are-not-the-only-conscience-keeper-sc-to-activist-to-remove-protesting-farmers-from-highways
Trending Judiciary
'You are not the only conscience keeper,' SC to activist to remove protesting farmers from highways

SC declines PIL to remove protesting farmers from highways, says, ‘You are not the only conscience keeper.’ Court urges focus on pending petitions.

09 December, 2024 03:41 AM
sc-refuses-to-entertain-pil-for-bringing-political-parties-under-posh-act
Trending Judiciary
SC refuses to entertain PIL for bringing political parties under POSH Act

SC declines to entertain PIL seeking inclusion of political parties under POSH Act, directs petitioner to approach Election Commission for appropriate action.

09 December, 2024 07:22 PM

TOP STORIES

sc-transfers-probe-into-2-firs-against-bjp-leader-to-cbi-due-to-politically-charged-atmosphere-in-wb
Trending Judiciary
SC transfers probe into 2 FIRs against BJP leader to CBI due to politically charged atmosphere in WB [Read Judgment]

SC transfers probe into 2 FIRs against BJP leader Kabir Shankar Bose to CBI, citing politically charged atmosphere in West Bengal for a fair investigation.

05 December, 2024 02:10 AM
justice-manmohan-sworn-in-as-supreme-court-judge-boosting-sc-strength-to-33
Trending Legal Insiders
Justice Manmohan sworn in as Supreme Court judge, boosting SC strength to 33

Justice Manmohan sworn in as SC judge, raising the Supreme Court’s strength to 33. A seasoned jurist, he brings decades of legal expertise to the bench.

05 December, 2024 02:51 AM
cant-claim-parity-with-other-ministers-sc-to-ex-wb-minister-partha-chatterjee-reserves-order-on-bail-in-teachers-recruitment-scam
Trending Judiciary
'Can't claim parity with other Ministers,' SC to ex WB Minister Partha Chatterjee; reserves order on bail in teachers recruitment scam

SC tells ex-WB Minister Partha Chatterjee he can’t claim parity with TN Minister Senthil Balaji in bail plea; reserves verdict in teachers’ recruitment scam.

05 December, 2024 04:48 AM
have-sympathy-why-drag-soldiers-widow-to-court-sc-slaps-rs-50k-cost-on-centre-for-denying-liberalised-pension
Trending Judiciary
‘Have sympathy, why drag soldier's widow to court,' SC slaps Rs 50k cost on Centre for denying liberalised pension [Read Judgment]

SC slams Centre for denying liberalised pension to soldier’s widow; imposes ₹50k cost, orders pension disbursal in 3 months for ‘Battle Casualty’ case.

05 December, 2024 04:50 AM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email