38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, July 31, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Madhya Pradesh HC Commutes Death Penalty In Child Rape And Murder Case [Read Judgment]

By Saket Sourav      30 June, 2025 05:38 PM      0 Comments
Madhya Pradesh HC Commutes Death Penalty In Child Rape And Murder Case

Madhya Pradesh: The Madhya Pradesh High Court has delivered a significant judgment commuting the death penalty awarded to a man convicted of the rape and murder of a 12-year-old girl, emphasizing considerations of age and the potential for rehabilitation while upholding the conviction.

A division bench comprising Justice Vivek Agarwal and Justice Devnarayan Mishra made crucial observations on the appropriateness of capital punishment and its legal implications in cases involving young offenders.

The court was hearing Criminal Appeal No. 4401 of 2021 and Criminal Reference No. 03 of 2021 filed against the State of Madhya Pradesh. It noted that the appellant had been convicted by the Special Judge (POCSO Act)/Ninth Additional Sessions Judge, Sagar, under multiple sections, including those related to rape, kidnapping, and murder.

Addressing the specific circumstances of the case, the court observed that on April 6, 2019, the 12-year-old victim had gone to Village Aapchand with her grandmother to attend religious rites. The court stated, “When they were on their way back home from Village Aapchand, the accused approached them and offered to take the prosecutrix home on his bicycle.”

The court also highlighted the evidence presented, including DNA profiling, dog squad tracking, and witness testimonies. Regarding the DNA evidence, it noted, “DNA report (Ex. P-30) clearly mentions that the samples received by the Forensic Science Laboratory were intact, and the seals on the samples were found to be unbroken.”

On the admissibility of DNA evidence, the court emphasized, “DNA evidence is in the nature of opinion evidence as envisaged under Section 45, and like any other opinion evidence, its probative value varies from case to case.”

Upon examining the evidence, the court found that the prosecution had established a complete chain of circumstances pointing to the appellant’s guilt — including last-seen evidence, dog tracking that led directly to the appellant’s house, and corroborative DNA findings.

Regarding sentencing, the court observed, “Though the learned Public Prosecutor for the State argued that in view of a second conviction, the appellant appears to be a person of perverted mind with no chance of rehabilitation and thus deserves the death penalty, there are two intervening factors that must be considered.”

The court stressed the importance of balancing aggravating and mitigating circumstances, noting the appellant’s young age of 24 at the time of the offense and the potential for reform.

In its specific direction, the court ruled, “We allow the present appeal in part, and while maintaining the conviction, substitute the death sentence imposed by the learned trial court with life imprisonment. It is directed that ‘life’ shall mean imprisonment till the end of life, with a further stipulation that there shall be no remission until the accused completes 25 years of imprisonment.”

The court upheld all other convictions and sentences under various sections of the Indian Penal Code and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, commuting only the death sentence to life imprisonment without remission for 25 years.

The appellant is thus to remain imprisoned for life, with no possibility of remission until he completes 25 years, ensuring both punishment and a remote possibility of rehabilitation.

Senior Advocate Aditya Adhikari, along with Advocates Kaustubh Chaturvedi and Pramod Singh Tomar, appeared for the convict. Public Prosecutor Nitin Kumar Gupta appeared for the State.

Case Title: Virendra Adiwasi vs. State of Madhya Pradesh

[Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Madhya Pradesh High Court has ordered filing of complaint against petitioner for submitting fabricated documents Madhya Pradesh High Court has ordered filing of complaint against petitioner for submitting fabricated documents

The Court pointed out one medical document in particular, wherein there was mentioning of labour pains and contradicted that since petitioner is a male, it makes no sense. In view of the above, the Court opined that the Petitioner unabashedly filed fake documents with utter disdain and disregard for the Court.

Supreme Court allows Jr. Judge appointment to woman denied the same due to dog bite case Supreme Court allows Jr. Judge appointment to woman denied the same due to dog bite case

The Supreme Court of India overturns Madhya Pradesh High Court's decision, ordering the appointment of a woman who was previously denied the position of Civil Judge (Junior Division) due to a past minor offence related to a dog bite case. The Court emphasizes fairness and justice in its landmark ruling.

Fashionable to demolish homes without following natural justice, Madhya Pradesh HC on bulldozer action in Ujjain Fashionable to demolish homes without following natural justice, Madhya Pradesh HC on bulldozer action in Ujjain

Madhya Pradesh High Court says it has become fashionable to demolish any house without complying with natural justice.

Supporting defamatory WhatsApp posts doesn’t constitute involvement in offence of defamation: MP HC [Read Order] Supporting defamatory WhatsApp posts doesn’t constitute involvement in offence of defamation: MP HC [Read Order]

The MP High Court ruled that merely agreeing with or supporting defamatory WhatsApp posts doesn't necessarily involve liability for defamation.

TRENDING NEWS

a-new-dawn-in-indias-criminal-justice-system-replacing-colonial-shackles-with-indigenous-legal-reforms
Trending Vantage Points
A New Dawn in India’s Criminal Justice System: Replacing Colonial Shackles with Indigenous Legal Reforms

This research paper examines India’s transition from IPC, CrPC, and IEA to BNS, BNSS, and BSA, emphasizing victim-centric and technology-driven justice reforms.

30 July, 2025 12:41 PM
your-conduct-does-not-inspire-confidence-sc-reserves-judgment-on-justice-yashwant-varmas-plea
Trending Judiciary
‘Your Conduct Does Not Inspire Confidence’: SC Reserves Judgment on Justice Yashwant Varma’s Plea

CJI can recommend removal of a judge in cases of grave misconduct, SC says; clarifies CJI isn’t a mere post office & Parliament has final say.

30 July, 2025 04:14 PM

TOP STORIES

allegations-against-rahul-gandhi-indicated-deliberate-spreading-of-hatred-up-govt-tells-sc
Trending Executive
Allegations against Rahul Gandhi indicated deliberate spreading of hatred, UP govt tells SC

UP govt tells SC that Rahul Gandhi’s Savarkar remarks show deliberate hate-mongering; supports summons citing prima facie case under Sections 153A & 505 IPC.

25 July, 2025 01:45 PM
sc-raps-ktka-hc-on-manner-of-granting-bail-to-actor-darshan-in-murder-case
Trending CelebStreet
SC raps Ktka HC on manner of granting bail to actor Darshan in murder case

SC slams Karnataka HC for granting bail to actor Darshan in murder case, calls reasoning flawed and akin to acquittal; reserves order on state’s plea.

25 July, 2025 01:49 PM
sc-to-examine-inordinate-delay-in-judges-appointments
Trending Judiciary
SC to examine inordinate delay in judges appointments

SC to examine Centre’s delay in appointing judges despite Collegium reiteration; pleas allege 4-year lag affects judicial seniority and interest.

25 July, 2025 02:50 PM
sc-refuses-stay-on-udaipur-files-tells-petitioners-to-approach-delhi-hc
Trending Judiciary
SC refuses stay on 'Udaipur Files'; tells petitioners to approach Delhi HC

SC refuses to stay ‘Udaipur Files’ release; asks petitioners to approach Delhi HC over certification, says no views expressed on film’s merits.

25 July, 2025 03:37 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email