38.6c New Delhi, India, Thursday, April 25, 2024
Judiciary

Madras HC: Second wife eligible for pension after death of first

By LawStreet News Network      28 January, 2020 07:01 PM      0 Comments
Madras HC: Second wife eligible for pension after death of first

The Madras High Court on January 23, 2020 observed that family pension cannot be denied to second wife of a pensioner, on the ground of invalid marriage, particularly when there has been cohabitation between the two for a long period of time. The bench comprising of Justice Anand Venkatesh made the observation while directing the state government to extend the family pension benefit to the petitioner, who was the second wife of a government doctor.

The case relates to a petition filed by C Sarojini Devi. She married her husband A Chinnasamy who was working with the Morappur Panchayat Union in Dharmapuri district. 

Chinnasamy had married Sarojini Devi in 1975, while he was still married to his first wife Pancholai. He had three children with his former wife who died in 1997 due to ill health. After her death, the husband nominated his second wife to receive his pension, in 1999. He died in 2009. When Devi applied for pension, her application was brushed off citing the reason that her marriage to Chinnasamy was invalid.

After hearing the matter, Justice N Anand Venkatesh said there will be no difficulty in concluding that the marriage between Devi and Chinnasamy was ‘illegal and not recognised by law’.

It is very easy to brand the petitioner as a concubine and deprive her of her livelihood. However, the fact remains that the petitioner had lived with the deceased for nearly 34 years. The petitioner also gave birth to three children. If the petitioner had made this claim when the first wife was alive, then obviously the petitioner will not be entitled for family pension, since her relationship was not recognized by law,” Justice Venkatesh had said.

In this view, the court has to lean towards the presumption of marriage, rather than branding the petitioner as a concubine,” the judge said. The audit body has been asked to grant Devi pension, including arrears, and grant the sum within 12 weeks.

Justice Venkatesh pointed out that the rule had been already applied by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dhannulal & Ors. v. Ganesh Ram & Ors.,(2015) 12 SCC 301. In the judgment delivered by Justice M. Yusuf Eqbal, he opined, “It is well settled that the law presumes in favour of marriage and against concubinage, when a man and woman have cohabited continuously for a long time. However, the presumption can be rebutted by leading unimpeachable evidence. A heavy burden lies on a party, who seeks to deprive the relationship of legal origin.” 

Author: Nandini Gandhi



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

key-changes-in-the-law-of-evidence-bharatiya-sakshya-adhiniyam-2023
Trending Speak Legal
Key changes in the Law of Evidence - Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023

Explore the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023, a transformative legal framework designed to modernize, humanize, and decolonize India's evidence law.

24 April, 2024 06:13 PM
plea-in-sc-seeks-sit-probe-into-electoral-bonds-scam
Trending Judiciary
Plea in SC seeks SIT probe into 'Electoral Bonds scam'

NGOs seek SC probe into Electoral Bonds, alleging pay-offs and quid pro quo between corporates and governments, demanding an SIT to investigate and recover proceeds of crime.

25 April, 2024 10:50 AM

TOP STORIES

kejriwal-eating-mangoes-sweets-and-having-tea-with-sugar-ed-tells-court
Trending Judiciary
Kejriwal eating mangoes, sweets and having tea with sugar, ED tells court

Enforcement Directorate alleges Delhi CM Kejriwal consumed mangoes, sweets, and tea with sugar in jail, raising doubts on his diabetes claim for bail plea.

19 April, 2024 11:01 AM
sc-to-consider-forming-guidelines-on-trial-for-deaf-dumb-people
Trending Judiciary
SC to consider forming guidelines on trial for deaf-dumb people [Read Order]

Supreme Court to consider guidelines for trials of deaf-dumb individuals, addressing fairness in cases like rape. Notice issued to Union and Chhattisgarh govt.

19 April, 2024 11:50 AM
big-expose-aryan-khan-drug-case-ncb-gyaneshwar-singh
Trending Interview
Big Expose | Aryan Khan Drug Case | NCB | Gyaneshwar Singh

A news report is going viral regarding the Deputy Director General of the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB), Gyaneshwar Singh. Tarakant Dwivedi alias Akela, a Mumbai-based crime reporter has made big claims over the senior IPS officer's Gujarat visit.

19 April, 2024 05:10 PM
paralympic-athletes-application-for-license-renewal-raises-questions-on-condition-of-paralympic-sports-administration-in-india
Trending Executive
Paralympic athlete's application for license renewal raises questions on condition of Paralympic sports administration in India

Female paralympic athlete Jeetu Kanwar's application for license renewal has raised questions on the condition of paralympic sportspersons and paralympic sports administration in India.

19 April, 2024 06:06 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email