38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, June 22, 2024
Judiciary

Violation Of Law Under MV Act Doesn’t Ipso Facto Lead To The Conclusion Of Contributory Negligence By Petitioner: SC

By LawStreet News Network      16 January, 2020 12:01 PM      0 Comments
Violation Of Law Under MV Act Doesn’t Ipso Facto Lead To The Conclusion Of Contributory Negligence By Petitioner: SC

The Supreme Court in the case of Mohammed Siddique v. National Insurance Company Ltd. on January 8, 2020 held that the violation of law by itself in the Motor Accident Cases, cannot lead to a conclusion of contributory negligence on the part of petitioner. The judgement to this effect was passed by division bench headed by Justice N.V. Ramana and comprising Justice V. Ramasubramanian. 

Facts of the case are as following: 

The son of the appellants who was aged about 23 years, died on 7.09.2008 as a result of the injuries sustained in a road traffic accident two days after the accident. The victim was one of the 2 pillion riders on a motor cycle and he was thrown off the vehicle when a car hit the motor cycle from behind.

The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal concluded that the accident was caused due to the rash and negligent driving of the car. The Tribunal had awarded an amount of Rs.11,66,800/- as the total compensation. Aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, the Insurance Company had filed an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The findings of the Tribunal were confirmed by the High Court, but the HC also made a remark that the victim was also guilty of contributory negligence, in as much as there were 3 persons on the motor cycle at the time of the accident, and ordered a reduction of 10% of the compensation awarded by the Tribunal. The HC also revisited the calculation of compensation and arrived at a total amount of Rs. 4,60,000/-. After deduction of 10% towards contributory negligence, the compensation to be awarded was Rs. 4,14,000/-. Aggrieved by the decision of the High Court, the Appellant approached the Supreme Court.

The SC in paragraph 14 of the judgment held that,

“…. The fact that the deceased was riding on a motor cycle along with the driver and another, may not, by itself, without anything more, make him guilty of contributory negligence….”

“…. a person was a pillion rider on a motor cycle along with the driver and one more person on the pillion, may be a violation of the law. But such violation by itself, without anything more, cannot lead to a finding of contributory negligence, unless it is established that his very act of riding along with two others, contributed either to the accident or to the impact of the accident upon the victim….”

The SC also found errors in the HC’s method of calculation and proceeded to overturn the HC judgement and restore the judgement of the Tribunal in its entirety. 

Author: Parth Thummar



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

gravity-of-offence-not-relevant-when-considering-bail-for-juvenile
Trending Judiciary
Gravity of offence not relevant when considering bail for juvenile [Read Order]

Allahabad High Court grants bail to a juvenile in a serious criminal case, ruling that the gravity of the offence is not a relevant factor in bail decisions.

22 June, 2024 11:18 AM
new-anti-cheating-law-enacted-analysis
Trending Executive
New Anti-Cheating Law enacted: Analysis

In-depth analysis of India’s new Anti-Cheating Law, the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024, aimed at curbing exam malpractices.

22 June, 2024 11:38 AM

TOP STORIES

women-including-housewife-approach-ncw-against-controversial-ips-officer-gyaneshwar-singh
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Women, including housewife, approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh

Two women approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh, citing harassment for tweets based on news reports about his involvement in high-profile cases.

17 June, 2024 03:10 PM
courts-this-week-law-street-journal-s-weekly-round-up-of-sc-anf-hcs-june-10-june-15
Trending Judiciary
Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [June 10 - June 15]

Get the latest updates from the Supreme Court of India and the High Courts ! Here’s a round up of the week's top legal stories in a quick, easy-to-read summary.

17 June, 2024 03:29 PM
man-sues-apple-for-5-million-blaming-company-for-divorce-after-wife-discovers-deleted-messages-with-sex-workers
Trending Business
Man sues Apple for £5 million, blaming company for divorce after wife discovers ‘deleted messages’ with sex workers

A UK man sues Apple for £5M, claiming their unclear policy on deleted messages led to his divorce after his wife found texts to sex workers on another device.

17 June, 2024 04:26 PM
ex-karnataka-cm-yediyurappa-appears-before-cid-for-pocso-case-probe-with-protection-of-no-arrest
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Ex-Karnataka CM Yediyurappa appears before CID for POCSO case probe, with protection of 'no arrest'

Ex-Karnataka CM Yediyurappa appears before CID for POCSO case probe, denies allegations, granted ‘no arrest’ protection. Next hearing: June 28.

17 June, 2024 04:46 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email