38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, April 18, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Rajasthan High Court upholds Income Tax Notice based on WhatsApp Chats as valid evidence [Read Judgment]

By Saket Sourav      07 April, 2025 04:09 PM      0 Comments
Rajasthan High Court upholds Income Tax Notice based on WhatsApp Chats as valid evidence

Rajasthan: The Rajasthan High Court has dismissed a writ petition challenging a notice issued under Section 153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, upholding the validity of using WhatsApp chats as incriminating evidence when corroborated by specific transactions.

Hon’ble Dr. Justice Pushpendra Singh Bhati and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Chandra Prakash Shrimali made significant observations on the scope and application of Section 153C proceedings in cases where digital evidence is discovered during search operations.

WhatsApp Chats as Evidence: Rajasthan HC Sets Legal Precedent in Income Tax Case

The case involved Giriraj Pugalia, who challenged a notice dated 16.06.2023 issued under Section 153C of the Income Tax Act following search operations conducted on the Om Kothari Group. The court noted:
“The WhatsApp chat is completely corroborated, and the said chat, which could be considered to fall within the definition of ‘other documents’, is totally corroborated by the specific transactions that have taken place regarding the assessee.”

Addressing the specific evidence discovered during the search, the court observed:
“The persons having the WhatsApp chats were connected with both the companies herein, and the transactions were regarding specific plots. The details of cash payment were clearly contained in the WhatsApp chat. Thus, with such specific inputs, the same cannot be said to be vague or hit by the strict parameters of Section 153C.”

The court highlighted that the digital evidence revealed unaccounted cash transactions, stating:
“The big-size plots in VKI, Jaipur, i.e., plots No. SP 818-(II)-3 and 818-(II)-4, were purchased by the petitioner. The unaccounted money paid is reflected in the chats. The purchase of the said plots was also found from the extracted digital data.”

Section 153C Explained: Digital Evidence Accepted in IT Proceedings by High Court

On the legal standard for invoking Section 153C, the court emphasized:
“The law and statute, however, require strict interpretation—as if the information is vague, then the same cannot be made part of the sustaining material for such proceedings—which is not so in the present case.”

The court detailed the transactions revealed through digital evidence, which showed cash payments totaling Rs. 4,52,62,000 made on various dates in February 2019 for the purchase of plots.

It rejected the petitioner’s argument that WhatsApp chats cannot be considered “books of account or documents” under Section 153C, finding that when corroborated by actual transactions, such digital evidence can form the basis for initiating proceedings against an “other person” not directly subjected to the search.

Consequently, the court dismissed the petition.

Mr. Aditya Vijay and Mr. Pankaj Arora appeared for the petitioner, and Mr. K.K. Bissa appeared for the respondent.

Case Title: Giriraj Pugalia vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle-1, Income Tax Department, Bikaner

 [Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Rajasthan HC Issues Show Cause Notice to CM Gehlot Over Remarks on Judiciary Rajasthan HC Issues Show Cause Notice to CM Gehlot Over Remarks on Judiciary

The Rajasthan High Court issues a show cause notice to Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot for his remarks on alleged corruption in the judiciary. Advocates protest and demand accountability. Get the latest updates on this legal controversy.

Supreme Court gets 3 new judges, taking the strength to 34 Supreme Court gets 3 new judges, taking the strength to 34

Get the latest news about the Supreme Court as it welcomes three new judges, increasing its strength to 34. Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud administered the oath, addressing the mounting case backlog.

Supreme Court Collegium approves new Chief Justices for five key High Courts in India [Read Recommendations] Supreme Court Collegium approves new Chief Justices for five key High Courts in India [Read Recommendations]

The Supreme Court Collegium approves new Chief Justices for Allahabad, Jharkhand, Gauhati, Punjab & Haryana, and Rajasthan High Courts. Read about the appointments.

"Consolidate bail pleas in identical FIR cases to ensure consistent judicial decisions": Supreme Court to High Courts [Read Order] "Consolidate bail pleas in identical FIR cases to ensure consistent judicial decisions": Supreme Court to High Courts [Read Order]

The article details the Supreme Court's directive to High Courts for handling bail pleas in cases with co-accused. It highlights the court's concerns about inconsistencies in bail decisions and its efforts to ensure uniformity in the judicial process by having one bench hear all bail applications from the same FIR.

TRENDING NEWS

it-authorities-to-be-informed-if-suit-involved-cash-transaction-of-rs-two-lakh-or-more-sc
Trending Judiciary
IT authorities to be informed if suit involved cash transaction of Rs two lakh or more: SC [Read Judgment]

SC: Inform IT Dept if property suit involves cash transaction of ₹2 lakh+ to curb Section 269ST violations; non-reporting may invite action.

17 April, 2025 10:58 AM
couples-marrying-without-parental-consent-not-entitled-to-police-protection-without-proven-threat-allahabad-high-court
Trending Judiciary
Couples Marrying Without Parental Consent Not Entitled to Police Protection Without Proven Threat: Allahabad High Court

Allahabad HC rules couples marrying without family consent can’t seek police protection unless there’s a clear and serious threat to their life or liberty.

17 April, 2025 03:19 PM

TOP STORIES

arbitration-clause-with-may-not-binding-without-fresh-consent-calcutta-high-court
Trending Judiciary
Arbitration Clause with ‘May’ Not Binding Without Fresh Consent: Calcutta High Court [Read Order]

Calcutta High Court rules that arbitration clauses using “may” are not binding, requiring fresh consent from parties to proceed with arbitration.

14 April, 2025 01:19 PM
bail-must-be-decided-based-on-individual-contraband-recovery-even-if-accused-travelled-together-jammu-and-kashmir-hc
Trending Judiciary
Bail Must Be Decided Based on Individual Contraband Recovery, Even If Accused Travelled Together: Jammu & Kashmir HC [Read Judgment]

J&K High Court rules that individual contraband recovery must be assessed separately for bail, even if accused were traveling together.

14 April, 2025 01:40 PM
calcutta-high-court-orders-central-forces-deployment-in-murshidabad-amid-violent-protests-against-waqf-act
Trending Judiciary
Calcutta High Court Orders Central Forces Deployment in Murshidabad Amid Violent Protests Against Waqf Act [Read Order]

Calcutta High Court orders Central Armed Forces deployment in Murshidabad to restore law and order amid escalating communal violence in West Bengal.

14 April, 2025 02:12 PM
rajasthan-high-court-directs-workman-to-plant-trees-as-condition-for-adducing-new-evidence
Trending Judiciary
Rajasthan High Court directs workman to plant trees as condition for adducing new evidence [Read Order]

Rajasthan High Court directs workman to plant 21 trees as a condition to adduce new evidence in a labour dispute, blending justice with ecology.

14 April, 2025 02:23 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email