38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, November 05, 2024
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Supreme Court overturns HC ruling on child custody, stresses importance of Civil and Family Courts in Custody Disputes [Read Judgment]

By Saket Sourav      09 September, 2024 06:40 PM      0 Comments
Supreme Court overturns HC ruling on child custody stresses importance of Civil and Family Courts in Custody Disputes

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has delivered a significant judgment, setting aside Madhya Pradesh High Court order that disturbed the custody of a toddler in a writ proceeding. The apex court emphasized that regular civil courts or family courts are better equipped to handle child custody cases compared to writ courts.

A Division Bench comprising Justices Abhay S. Oka and Augustine George Masih dismissed an appeal arising from a custody dispute over a 2-year-7-month-old girl, whose mother had died an unnatural death.

The court noted that the High Court had ordered a change in custody based solely on the father’s legal rights, without considering the child’s welfare. Justice Oka observed, “The High Court has not dealt with or considered the issue of the welfare of the child. The High Court has disturbed the child’s custody based only on the father’s right as a natural guardian.”

Expressing its view on the appropriate forum for custody matters, the court stated, “Only in substantive proceedings under the GW Act can the appropriate Court decide the issue of child custody and guardianship. Regular civil/family courts dealing with child custody cases are in a better position.”

The court highlighted several advantages of civil/family courts in handling custody cases, including their ability to interact with the child more frequently, the availability of child centers/play areas for interaction, the capacity to record evidence, the option to appoint experts for psychological assessment, and their better positioning to monitor visitation/access arrangements.

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order and dismissed the writ petition. However, it laid down interim arrangements for the father and grandparents to have supervised access to the child under the supervision of the District Legal Services Authority, with the assistance of a child psychologist or psychiatrist.

Additionally, the court directed the appellants (maternal relatives with current custody) to file a petition seeking guardianship under the Guardians and Wards Act within two months. It stated, “As assured to the Court, the appellants or some of them shall file a petition seeking a declaration of guardianship and permanent custody of the child under the provisions of the GW Act before the competent court within a maximum period of two months from today.”

[Read Judgment]



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Order to appoint One Man Committee of Justice (Retd.) Lokur for the Prevention of Stubble Burning Kept in Abeyance by SC itself [READ ORDER] Order to appoint One Man Committee of Justice (Retd.) Lokur for the Prevention of Stubble Burning Kept in Abeyance by SC itself [READ ORDER]

CJI suggests holding measures in abeyance, questioning the PIL petitioner in the stubble burning case. Justice (Retd.) Madan B Lokur's role also discussed.

"Experts Say Your Beautiful Cars Also Contribute to Air Pollution," CJI SA Bobde Says While Hearing Stubble Burning Issue "Experts Say Your Beautiful Cars Also Contribute to Air Pollution," CJI SA Bobde Says While Hearing Stubble Burning Issue

Chief Justice of India S.A. Bobde ensures no stubble burning orders will be passed without considering petitioners' input, confirms Senior Advocate Vikas Singh.

Centre states that Farmers Stubble Burning contributes to 10% Pollution; SC retailitates saying, 'Pollution is caused by city-related issues. Take care of them and then we will come to stubble burning' Centre states that Farmers Stubble Burning contributes to 10% Pollution; SC retailitates saying, 'Pollution is caused by city-related issues. Take care of them and then we will come to stubble burning'

Supreme Court urges Centre, Punjab, Haryana, and UP to implement work-from-home due to air pollution. Next hearing set for November 17, 2021.

WhatsApp Assures High Court Of Full Cooperation In Dhanbad Judge Murder Case WhatsApp Assures High Court Of Full Cooperation In Dhanbad Judge Murder Case

The CBI has charged auto-rickshaw driver Lakhan Verma and his brother Rahul with murder and false information, invoking IPC Sections 302, 201, and 34.

TRENDING NEWS

scba-scaora-strongly-condemn-ghaziabad-court-incident
Trending Judiciary
SCBA, SCAORA strongly condemn Ghaziabad court incident [Read SCBA, SCAORA Resolution]

SCBA, SCAORA condemn Ghaziabad court incident, demand inquiry, dismissal of judge, police, and Advocate Protection Act to prevent future violence.

04 November, 2024 11:18 AM
bail-conditions-must-be-fair-reasonable-cannot-tantamount-to-deprivation-of-civil-rights-sc
Trending Judiciary
Bail conditions must be fair, reasonable; cannot tantamount to deprivation of civil rights: SC [Read Judgment]

SC asserts that bail conditions must be fair and reasonable, ensuring accused’s presence without infringing civil rights, overturns Madhya Pradesh HC’s excessive terms.

04 November, 2024 11:55 AM

TOP STORIES

scba-scaora-strongly-condemn-ghaziabad-court-incident
Trending Judiciary
SCBA, SCAORA strongly condemn Ghaziabad court incident [Read SCBA, SCAORA Resolution]

SCBA, SCAORA condemn Ghaziabad court incident, demand inquiry, dismissal of judge, police, and Advocate Protection Act to prevent future violence.

04 November, 2024 11:18 AM
bail-conditions-must-be-fair-reasonable-cannot-tantamount-to-deprivation-of-civil-rights-sc
Trending Judiciary
Bail conditions must be fair, reasonable; cannot tantamount to deprivation of civil rights: SC [Read Judgment]

SC asserts that bail conditions must be fair and reasonable, ensuring accused’s presence without infringing civil rights, overturns Madhya Pradesh HC’s excessive terms.

04 November, 2024 11:55 AM
sc-declines-interim-relief-to-death-row-convict-rajoana-gives-two-weeks-to-punjab-to-file-response-to-plea-on-delay-in-mercy-petition
Trending Judiciary
SC declines interim relief to death row convict Rajoana; gives two weeks to Punjab to file response to plea on delay in mercy petition

SC denies interim relief to death row convict Rajoana; grants Punjab two weeks to respond on plea over delay in mercy petition. Next hearing on Nov 18.

04 November, 2024 03:56 PM
sc-modifies-bail-condition-to-report-to-local-police-station-every-week-for-kerala-journalist-sidhique-kappan
Trending Judiciary
SC modifies bail condition to report to local police station every week for Kerala journalist Sidhique Kappan

SC relaxes bail condition for Kerala journalist Sidhique Kappan, removing weekly police station visits in UAPA case linked to Hathras incident.

04 November, 2024 05:16 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email