38.6c New Delhi, India, Saturday, July 26, 2025
Top Stories Supreme Court
Political NEWS Legislative Corner Celebstreet International Videos
Subscribe Contact Us
close
Judiciary

Well reasoned Arbitral Award backed by evidence cannot be challenged under section 34 [Read Order]

By Saket Sourav      27 August, 2024 02:59 PM      0 Comments
Well reasoned Arbitral Award backed by evidence cannot be challenged under section 34

Kolkatta: The Calcutta High Court has delivered a significant ruling, affirming that a well-reasoned arbitral award, supported by substantial evidence, cannot be challenged under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya passed the order while dismissing a challenge to an arbitral award filed by Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) against BLA Projects Pvt. Ltd.

The case arose from a contract between DVC and BLA Projects for the transportation of coal. DVC terminated the contract, alleging corrupt and fraudulent practices by BLA Projects. The arbitrator ruled in favor of BLA Projects on several claims, including unpaid bills and loss of profit, while rejecting DVC’s counterclaims.

The court noted that the arbitrator provided elaborate reasons and conducted a detailed factual appreciation of the entire evidence on record before arriving at his findings. Justice Bhattacharyya observed, “This Court, as is well-settled by the Supreme Court in several judgments, cannot enter into a reappreciation of evidence like a regular first appellate court, sitting in a challenge under Section 34 of the 1996 Act.”

Referring to the limited scope of patent illegality as a ground for challenge under Section 34(2A), the court highlighted, “Such patent illegality has to appear on the face of the award. Also, the proviso to the sub-section stipulates that an award shall not be set aside on the said score merely on the ground of an erroneous application of law or by reappreciation of evidence.”

The court found that the arbitrator had correctly interpreted the termination clause and considered extensive evidence regarding unpaid bills, loss of profit, and other claims. It stated, “The judgment of the Arbitrator is perfectly well-reasoned and supported by cogent evidence and, as such, none of the grounds of challenge under Section 34 of the 1996 Act are established.”

Emphasizing the limited scope of interference with arbitral awards, the court observed, “There is nothing in the award to attract the grounds of contravention of the fundamental policy of Indian law or to hold that it is in conflict with the basic notions of morality or justice.”

The court dismissed DVC’s challenge, thereby affirming the arbitral award dated August 14, 2021.

In conclusion, while dismissing the challenge to the arbitral award, the court reaffirmed the well-settled principle that courts cannot reappreciate evidence or interfere with well-reasoned arbitral awards under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, except on very limited grounds.

 

[Read Order]



Share this article:

About:

Saket is a final-year law student at The National Law University and Judicial Academy, Assam. He has...Read more

Follow:
Linkedin


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Birbhum Massacre: NHRC Takes Suo Motu Cognisance, Directs State Gov To Submit Detailed Report Within 4 Weeks Birbhum Massacre: NHRC Takes Suo Motu Cognisance, Directs State Gov To Submit Detailed Report Within 4 Weeks

According to reports, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Thursday met the families of the victims and announced Rs 2 lakh compensation for rebuilding the scorched homes. Promising jobs to ten families affected by the violence, Banerjee added that she would ensure "speedy justice".

Supreme Court Rejects West Bengal's Plea Against CBI Probe in Linked Municipality and Teachers' Recruitment Scam Supreme Court Rejects West Bengal's Plea Against CBI Probe in Linked Municipality and Teachers' Recruitment Scam

Supreme Court dismisses West Bengal's plea against CBI probe into municipality recruitment scam linked with teachers' recruitment irregularities. Abhishek Banerjee, TMC MP, faces setback as court refuses interference.

Calcutta High Court conducts late-evening hearing, orders release of lawyer arrested inside court [Read Order] Calcutta High Court conducts late-evening hearing, orders release of lawyer arrested inside court [Read Order]

After holding a late-evening hearing due to unprecedented events, a division bench of the Calcutta High Court stayed an order which directed a lawyers arrest inside the court on charges of contempt of court.

Indian Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [Jan 1 - Jan 6] Indian Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [Jan 1 - Jan 6]

A weekly round-up of the top stories from the Supreme Court of India and High Courts across the country summed up in a 3-minute read.

TRENDING NEWS

allegations-against-rahul-gandhi-indicated-deliberate-spreading-of-hatred-up-govt-tells-sc
Trending Executive
Allegations against Rahul Gandhi indicated deliberate spreading of hatred, UP govt tells SC

UP govt tells SC that Rahul Gandhi’s Savarkar remarks show deliberate hate-mongering; supports summons citing prima facie case under Sections 153A & 505 IPC.

25 July, 2025 01:45 PM
sc-raps-ktka-hc-on-manner-of-granting-bail-to-actor-darshan-in-murder-case
Trending Judiciary
SC raps Ktka HC on manner of granting bail to actor Darshan in murder case

SC slams Karnataka HC for granting bail to actor Darshan in murder case, calls reasoning flawed and akin to acquittal; reserves order on state’s plea.

25 July, 2025 01:49 PM

TOP STORIES

fight-your-battles-before-electorate-sc-to-ktka-govt-on-plea-against-quashing-fir-against-bjp-mp-tejaswi-surya
Trending Judiciary
'Fight your battles before electorate,' SC to Ktka govt on plea against quashing FIR against BJP MP Tejaswi Surya

SC tells K’taka to fight political battles at ballot, not court—rejects plea against HC order quashing FIR on Tejasvi Surya’s fake news tweet.

21 July, 2025 01:41 PM
sc-to-consider-on-july-22-president-reference-on-timeline-related-to-bills-passed-by-state-legislatures
Trending Judiciary
SC to consider on July 22 President reference on timeline related to Bills passed by State legislatures

SC to examine Presidential reference on July 22 over court’s power to set timelines for Governor, President on clearing state Bills.

21 July, 2025 01:46 PM
sc-issues-notice-to-centre-states-on-ashwini-upadhyays-pil-seeking-mandatory-disclosure-of-seller-details-under-consumer-protection-act
Trending Judiciary
SC Issues Notice To Centre, States on Ashwini Upadhyay’s PIL Seeking Mandatory Disclosure of Seller Details Under Consumer Protection Act

SC issues notice on Ashwini Upadhyay’s PIL seeking mandatory disclosure of seller details to protect consumers under Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

21 July, 2025 04:47 PM
let-political-battles-be-fought-in-electorate-sc-refuses-to-entertain-eds-plea-against-ktka-cms-wife-in-muda-scam
Trending Judiciary
'Let political battles be fought in electorate,' SC refuses to entertain ED's plea against Ktka CM's wife in MUDA scam

SC refuses to hear ED plea against K’taka CM’s wife in MUDA scam, says political battles must be fought in the electorate, not through agencies.

21 July, 2025 04:56 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email