New Delhi: The Supreme Court has held that a soldier who was wounded by the accidentaldischarge of his own weapon, while on duty during Operation Rakshak/Operation Parakram, is entitled to War Injury Element of pension, since an accidental discharge is not a self-inflicted injury. It set aside an Armed Forces Tribunal order that had denied the claim for want of a final Battle Casualty Certificate from MP-5 and the soldier’s absence from a later digital database.
A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, was hearing the appeal of JC-377745M Ex Subedar Major and Honorary Lieutenant Devi Singh against the Union of India. The appellant served in the Army from 24 June 1985 to 31 March 2019. On 7 August 2002, while serving with 31 Sub Area Signal Company in Jammu and Kashmir, his loaded weapon accidentallydischarged and the bullet passed through his left thigh and damaged the femoral vein. The Release Medical Board assessed the disability as attributable to service at 40% for life, and the Union had already granted Disability Element of pension, rounded to 50%, from 1 April 2019.
The Court noted that Regulation 103 of the Pension Regulations for the Army, 2008 does not treat every service-attributable disability as a war injury, and requires that it be sustained in the circumstances in Category ‘E’ of Regulation 82. It held that clause (h), covering action against extremists and anti-social elements, directly governed the case. Part II Order No. BC-59 of 16 December 2002 carried the heading “Battle Casualty Wound Op Rakshak Op Parakram” and recorded the injury as caused by “accidental discharge of his wpn while on duty”. Read with the undisputed posting, the Entitlement Cards and the Attributability Certificate of 5 February 2015, which certified the injury as a Battle Casualty, this established an operational connection and not mere presence in a sensitive area.
On the central question, the Court explained that Army Order 1/2003/MP excludes “self-inflicted” injuries, and not every injury where the serviceman’s own weapon is the source of the bullet. It observed that weapon ownership and intention are distinct facts, and the former cannot, without evidence of intention, prove the latter. A weapon may discharge through an impact, a fall, a snagged trigger, inadvertent pressure or a mechanical defect, and self-inflicted injury involves an element of knowledge or intention. The earliest surviving record called the discharge “accidental”, and no Court of Inquiry finding, disciplinary order or medical opinion treated it as deliberate or as an attempt to avoid duty.
The Court further held that paragraph 69 of Army Order 1/2003/MP itself recognises gunshot wounds “sustained accidentally” as capable of classification as wounded Battle Casualties, as otherwise self-inflicted injury would have been expressly carved out. Both cumulative parameters were met. Parameter No. 1 (operational cause) was satisfied by BC-59, the Entitlement Cards and the Brigadier’s certificate, and Parameter No. 2 (injury at least grievous) by the Severity Certificate, countersigned by the Commandant and approved by the Major General (Medical).
Relying on Union of India v. Saroj Devi, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3591, the Court said that a contemporaneous official certificate on matters within the issuing authority’s institutional knowledge deserves due evidentiary weight when uncontradicted. Such a certificate does not by itself create entitlement, and its function is evidentiary, but the entitlement arises once the established facts satisfy the Army Order and the regulations.
Rejecting the Union’s reliance on the lost Court of Inquiry file and the absent digital entry, the Court noted that the unit records were destroyed in the 2014 floods while in official custody, and MP-5 itself had permitted reconstruction from surviving documents. It held:
“The absence of the appellant’s name from a subsequently created digital database is merely the absence of further corroboration, but it is not affirmative evidence capable of disproving the contemporaneous and signed official records that have survived. The appellant, therefore cannot be made to suffer for no fault on his part.”
The appeal was allowed and the Armed Forces Tribunal’s judgment of 10 May 2023 and order of 19 July 2023 were set aside. The respondents were directed to sanction and pay War Injury Element from the date of retirement under Regulation 103, adjusting the Disability Element already paid, and to issue the revised Pension Payment Order and net arrears within three months.
Case Title: JC-377745M Ex Sub Maj and Hony Lt Devi Singh vs. Union of India & Ors., Civil Appeal arising out of Diary No. 33439 of 2023, 2026 INSC 1256
