Kolkata: The Calcutta High Court has confirmed the death sentence imposed on Ashok Singh for the rape and murder of a girl aged about five years in Hooghly district, and dismissed his appeal. The Division Bench found the circumstantial chain complete and held that the aggravating circumstances “heavily outweigh” the mitigating factors. It stayed its judgment for three months so that the convict can approach the Supreme Court.
A Bench of Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray heard the death reference (DR 2 of 2025) made by the State and the convict’s appeal (CRA (DB) 328 of 2025), against the judgment of 15/17.01.2025 of the Exclusive POCSO Court, Chinsurah, Hooghly. That court convicted him under Sections 65(2), 64(2)(1), 66, 103(1) and 163(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and Section 6(1) of the POCSO Act. It sentenced him to imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life under Section 64(2)(1) BNS and to death under Sections 103(1), 66 and 65(2) BNS and Section 6(1) POCSO.
The prosecution said that on 24.11.2024 the child, who lived a few houses from the convict, went missing in the evening. When the mother searched, the convict told her that the child had not come to his house. The family and neighbours then forced their way into his house after he refused entry, and found the child unconscious on a floor mat, without clothes and bleeding. She was taken to Dhaniakhali Rural Hospital and declared dead. The prosecution examined 27 witnesses; the defence examined none, and the convict took a plea of complete denial under Section 351 BNSS.
Counsel for the convict argued that the case rested wholly on circumstantial evidence, and that the chain of circumstances had gaps and contradictions. In the alternative, he argued that the case was not among the “rarest of rare” and that the death sentence lacked individualised reasons required by Bachan Singh. The Court noted the neighbour who saw the child going with him on the promise of chocolates, and the search party that found her in his room. It relied on the State Forensic Science Laboratory expert (P.W. 16), who found that the convict’s DNA matched swabs from the child, semen stains on the floor mat and her clothes, and that the child’s blood was on his gamcha, which the Court said showed that his plea was false. The autopsy doctor opined that death was homicidal, from intracranial haemorrhage.
Justice Ray held that a plea that someone else committed the crime and left the body in his room stood disproved. Justice Banerjee, agreeing and adding his own reasons, said the child and the convict were “last seen together”, her body was found soon after in his house, and he gave no explanation, so he failed to discharge the burden under Section 106 of the Evidence Act, 1872. He held that “nothing more was required” to convict.
On sentence, the Court considered the report filed under the Supreme Court’s directions in Manoj v. State of M.P., (2023) 2 SCC 353. A medical board found no diagnosable mental illness and that he understood the nature of the crime and punishment. The Probation Officer’s report recorded that he was about 45, illiterate and had no family. Justice Ray also relied on statements of two witnesses to the Magistrate that he had been suspected of inappropriately touching other village girls, one also five years old, and said this showed that he could not be reformed. He found no mitigating circumstances and said:
“The unspeakable ordeal suffered by the minor victim and her family vastly outweighs any abstract scope for the reformation of a hardened convict who displays complete absence of remorse or repentance.”
Justice Banerjee gave five reasons for treating this as a rarest of rare case: breach of trust by a neighbour whom the child called “Jethu”; the brutal manner of the crime; the shock to the collective conscience; the absence of remorse; and the finding that he was not mentally ill and so acted consciously. He rejected the plea of life imprisonment without remission as in Swamy Shraddananda. Mr. Kaushik Gupta and Mr. Apalak Basu appeared as counsel appointed by the Legal Services Committee in terms of Aman Singh v. State of Bihar (2026 INSC 424).
The Court also directed the State to enhance the victim compensation from Rs. 10 lakh to Rs. 15 lakh, which the parents had not received, and to pay it within two months, with a compliance report by 30.01.2027.
Appearances:
For the Appellant/Convict: Mr. Amit Ranjan Pati, Ms. Swastika Chowdhury, Ms. Ilika Nag, Mr. Yavik Singhal and Mr. Avijit Chatterjee, Advocates; Mr. Kaushik Gupta, Senior Advocate, and Mr. Apalak Basu, Advocate (appointed by the Calcutta High Court Legal Services Committee).
For the State: Mr. Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee, Special Public Prosecutor, with Mr. Santanu Talukdar, Ms. Moumita Pandit, Mr. Supreme Naskar and Ms. Ritushree Banerjee, Advocates.
Case Title: State of West Bengal vs. Ashok Singh, DR 2 of 2025 with CRA (DB) 328 of 2025
