Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has dismissed a criminal appeal filed in 1984 and upheld the conviction under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code and the sentence of four years’ rigorous imprisonment of Ram Raj alias Lala, for a sexual assault on a minor girl in Fatehpur district in July 1982.
The Court held that the testimony of the prosecutrix inspired confidence, was corroborated by medical evidence and the account of witnesses, and that minor variations did not go to the root of the case.
Justice Abdul Shahid was hearing Criminal Appeal No. 116 of 1984 against the judgment of 07.01.1984 of the III Additional Sessions Judge, Fatehpur, in Sessions Trial No. 39 of 1983. The trial court convicted him under Section 376 IPC, and so did not separately convict him under the alternative charge of Section 376 read with Section 511 IPC.
According to the prosecution, on 10.07.1982 at about 4:00 p.m. the victim had gone to graze cattle in a forest, where the appellant was also grazing his. It alleged that he forced her to the ground and attempted to penetrate her and, failing, inserted his fingers, causing bleeding. Her cries drew village residents, and the appellant fled. The father lodged a report at Police Station Hathgaon the next morning, and a blood-stained garment was handed over to the police.
The prosecution relied on the victim (P.W.-2), her father (P.W.-3), her grandfather (P.W.-4), who said he heard her cries and saw the appellant getting up, adjusting his dhoti and running away, the investigating officer, and the medical officer (P.W.-7). The doctor found her hymen ruptured with slight bleeding and tenderness, opined that she had been subjected to rape within 12 to 24 hours of the examination, and, on X-ray, put her age at about 14 years. The radiologist (P.W.-1) said her age could not have been more than 14, though it could be 15 in cross-examination.
The appellant said that he had been falsely implicated owing to enmity between his father and the complainant, and that the victim’s cattle had entered his uncle’s field, after which she fell and was injured. His counsel pointed to contradictions between her statement to the police and in court, said that the eyewitnesses’ presence was doubtful, and that the doctor had admitted that the injury could have been caused by a fall on a hard object or a pigeon pea stalk, and no external injury was found. The State relied on Yogesh Singh v. Mahabir Singh, (2017) 11 SCC 195, Prabhu Dayal v. State of Rajasthan, (2018) 8 SCC 127, and Ramayan Singh v. State, 2011 (2) ACR 1930.
The Court noted that the victim, being under 16, falls within the fifth description of Section 375 IPC as it then stood. It held that the appellant had gone beyond intention and preparation into execution, and observed that “the possibility of some degree of penetration cannot be ruled out, although complete penetration may not have taken place”. Citing State of Kerala v. Kundumkara Govindam, 1969 Cri LJ 818, Ghanashyam Mishra v. State, AIR 1957 Ori 78, and Nathu Ram v. State of Haryana, it held that the depth of penetration is immaterial and rupture of the hymen is not essential. On the prosecutrix’s testimony, it held:
“The statement of the prosecutrix, if found to be worthy of credence and reliable, does not require any corroboration, and the Court may convict the accused on the basis of her sole testimony.”
Relying on Vijay v. State of U.P., 2010 (3) SCC (Cri) 639, and State of U.P. v. Chhotey Lal, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 674, the Court said her evidence is treated at par with that of an injured witness. It accepted that the variations in her accounts about the precise manner of the act and the body part involved did not demolish the substratum of the case. It also held that a doctor’s admission of a possible alternative cause does not make the prosecution version unreliable, that absence of external injury does not discredit her, and that the plea of enmitywas not substantiated. The Court noted the delay in the F.I.R. was explained, as the father could not go to the police station in the evening, and that the standard of proof is beyond reasonable doubt and not beyond a shadow of doubt, citing Iqbal Moosa Patel v. State of Gujarat.
The conviction and sentence under Section 376 IPC were affirmed. As the appellant is on bail, he must surrender before the trial court within 15 days, failing which the trial court is at liberty to secure his presence. The period of incarceration already undergone is to be adjusted against the sentence.
Appearances:
For the Appellant: Mr. Shivam Kumar Pal, Advocate.
For the State: Mr. Manoj Kumar Singh, A.G.A.
Case Title: Ram Raj alias Lala vs. State of U.P., Criminal Appeal No. 116 of 1984,
