38.6c New Delhi, India, Tuesday, April 16, 2024

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal Upholds the Order Given By National Company Law Tribunal: No Insolvency Proceedings Against Tata Chemicals

By RITIK JAIN      20 August, 2020 07:52 PM      0 Comments
National Company Law Appellate Tribunal Upholds the Order Given By National Company Law Tribunal: No Insolvency Proceedings Against Tata Chemicals

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) dismissed an appeal filed by Allied Silica Limited questioning the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) Mumbai Bench's structure that had dismissed the Insolvency application for initiating the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process against Tata Chemicals Limited under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. 

The Three-Judges bench consisting of Acting Chairperson Justice Bansi Lal Bhat, Justice V. P. Singh Member (Technical) and Justice Shreesha Merla Member (Technical) while dismissing Allied Silica's ('Operational Creditor') claim for Rs 68.44 crore held that- 

"The Ld. adjudicating authority has rightly dismissed the application filed under Section 9 of the law. Thus, we do not find any reason to interfere with the impugned order. There is no substance in the appeal which is accordingly dismissed. 

In 2018, Tata Chemicals had gone into a Business Transfer Agreement ('BTA') for the exchange of Operational Creditor's silica business on a Slump Sale reason for an amount of Rs 123 crore.

The operational Creditor had contended that the Tata Group had moved just a sum of Rs. 65 Crores and the balance amount of Rs 58 crores remained unpaid. By default, the interest added up to Rs. 10.44 Crores, and in this manner a sum of Rs. 68 Crores were expected. They further contended that post-transfer of the undertaking, the parties had commonly consented to proceed with their respective rights and commitments to set out the pipeline, preliminary attempt, and good activity, and so on with the extra extent of work with other tranche installments, which were isolated and unmistakable from slump sale.

Refuting their claim, Tata Group contended that the Operational Creditor had suppressed facts and data and that the said obligation didn't fall under the meaning of an 'Operational Debt' and the Appellant was not an 'Operational Creditor' as characterized under IBC. They contended that the thought under BTA was divided into a 3 Tranche Payment framework and that they had properly paid the Closing Balance thought and Tranche I and Tranche II installments to the Operational creditor even though there existed a non-completion of Tranche I and Tranche II Conditions Precedent. Under the non-completion of Tranche II conditions point of reference by the Operational Creditor, Tata's had balanced the Tranche III installment against the improvement costs borne by it. 

Further, they had presented their answer to the demand notice of the Operational Creditor within 10 days, raising dispute to the case. The NCLT had dismissed the application, mostly on the ground of pre-existing debt. The Appellate bench expressed that the Operational Creditor had failed to prove the operational obligation and its default and there was a ground of a pre-existing dispute and held that:

"It is further evident from the Letter of Corporate Debtor dated 06.03.2019, wherein the Corporate Debtor had demanded a refund from the Applicant of Rs 15.01 Crores along with interest for violation of terms of Letter dated 08.01.2019 by the Applicant in the same Letter the Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 1522 of 2019 18 of 18 Corporate Debtor had also disputed that the Applicant is in non-compliance of the BTA and therefore is not liable to receive Tranche II and Tranche III payment under the BTA. These disputes by the Corporate Debtor are raised before the receipt of demand notices. Further, it is also pertinent to note that the Corporate Debtor had replied to the Demand Notices within the statutory period of 10 (Ten) days raising disputes with regards to the claim of Applicant and noncompliance of the BTA by the Applicant. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, we are satisfied that there is a plausible contention in the defense raised by the corporate debtor which requires further investigation and that the alleged "dispute" is not a patently feeble legal argument or an assertion of fact unsupported by evidence."

Share this article:

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Law School
Call For Chapters: Gender-Based Violence and Religion

Calling For Book Chapters: As an editor, Dr. Amit Anand, Assistant Professor, School of Legal Studies, REVA University, Bengaluru, is inviting people to contribute to a book, entitled "Gender-Based Violence and Religion." This book is scheduled to be published by Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

15 April, 2024 04:21 PM
Trending Judiciary
SC extends stay on Allahabad HC order approving survey of Shahi Idgah complex

SC extends stay on Allahabad HC's order for survey of Shahi Eidgah mosque next to Krishna Janmabhoomi.

15 April, 2024 05:19 PM


Trending Business
Misleading advts case: Baba Ramdev, Balkrishna tender apology

Baba Ramdev, Balkrishna apologize for misleading ads. SC contempt plea hearing set for April 10. Patanjali assures compliance with court orders.

10 April, 2024 10:44 AM
Trending Judiciary
SC allows gangster-turned-politician's son to attend 'Fatiha'

Supreme Court allows jailed MLA Abbas Ansari to attend his father's funeral prayers, granting temporary release under police custody.

10 April, 2024 11:11 AM
Trending Judiciary
Each moveable property not required to be disclosed by candidates in election: SC [Read Judgment]

SC rules not every movable asset needs disclosure in elections. Privacy rights preserved. Details vary per case. High value assets matter.

10 April, 2024 12:02 PM
Trending Judiciary
Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal moves Supreme Court

Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal moves Supreme Court against dismissal of plea in liquor policy scam case. Lawyers seek early hearing from CJI-led bench.

10 April, 2024 12:39 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email