Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has held that the principle of open justice does not amount to a “free broadcast” by any unauthorized individual, and that no person has the right to record court proceedings except with the leave of the Court. Taking a person found recording a hearing on his mobile phone into custody, it directed that he be produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, and barred litigants from entering courtrooms with mobile phones.
Justice Vikram D. Chauhan, hearing a matter under Article 227 filed by Kuldeep Batra against the State of U.P., was told by the learned A.G.A. that a person was recording the proceedings on his mobile phone without permission. The person, Raj Kulshrestha of Varanasi, admitted this but could not give any reason. The Bench Secretary took custody of his phone, which was found to hold three videos of the proceedings. He had no case listed, and he carried a pass issued by the Registry limited to the Advocates’ chamber, which does not permit entry into the courtroom. Kuldeep Batra, whose case was at Serial No. 27, was also present with a similar pass, and said that he did not know Kulshrestha.
Senior Advocate Dr. C.P. Upadhyaya, President of the High Court Bar Association, informed the Court that some advocates were recording and uploading videos of proceedings, which was against decorum. He also drew attention to the Association’s notice dated 18.11.2026, which prohibits making videos, reels or photographs inside the High Court premises, imposes a Rs 5,000 penalty, and warns of disciplinary action and possible termination of membership. Kulshrestha said that he had been brought to the Court by Bhanu Pratap Seth, Advocate, junior to Nitish Kumar Soni, Advocate, counsel for the petitioner, but neither was present, since Mr. Soni was out of station and Mr. Seth was absent when the matter was called.
The Court noted that it has criminal jurisdiction, and hears matters concerning personal liberty, child sexual abuse, CBI, Enforcement Directorate and MP/MLA cases, whose facts should not be put on social media before the Court has determined them. It said that it has inherent power to regulate its own procedure and maintain order. On open justice, the Court observed:
“The principle of open justice means proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, the same does not amount to ‘free broadcast’ by any unauthorized individual.”
The Court added that court proceedings are not for entertainment but a serious business affecting liberty and rights, and that recording or publishing them without leave may produce a social media trial before final determination, prejudice litigants, and expose victims to stigma. The broadcast, it said, is required to be regulated by the Presiding Officer of each Court.
The Court adjourned the matter to 20.11.2026 and directed that Kulshrestha be taken into custody, medically examined and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, who may release him on bail on personal bond and two sureties on condition that he appears before the High Court at 10 a.m. on 20.11.2026. His phone is to be kept in a sealed cover and produced. He must explain why the recording should not be treated as interference in the administration of justice. Mr. Soni and Mr. Seth were directed to appear and show cause why proceedings for interference in the administration of justice should not be initiated, Kuldeep Batra was directed to explain on affidavit why he was in the courtroom without a proper pass, and the Additional Advocate General, Manish Goyal, was asked to remain present.
In view of the security of the Court, the Court directed that litigants shall not be permitted to enter courtrooms with mobile phones, and the concerned advocate will be solely responsible if a phone is found with a litigant. The Registrar General is to paste a notice at the passcounter, and the Registrar (Protocol) is to ensure that litigants without proper passes are not admitted, to endorse on passes that phones are barred in courtrooms for non-advocates, and to submit a report.
Appearances:
For the Petitioner: Mr. Nitish Kumar Soni (not present when the matter was taken up).
For the Respondents: Mr. P.K. Singh, A.G.A., Mr. Prayageshwar Kumar Upadhyay and Mr. Saurabh Singh.
Case Title: Kuldeep Batra vs. State of U.P. and Another, Matters under Article 227 No. 14284 of 2026
